{"$schema":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/editorial-standards.json","name":"Policy Window editorial-quality scorecard","description":"Deterministic per-article scoring against the editorial-quality rubric (baseline guarantees + academic-research-practice depth signals). Re-derivable from the published catalog.","docs":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/editorial-standards","asOf":"2026-06-14","parameters":{"recencyWindowDays":365,"minEvidenceTypes":2},"summary":{"total":96,"meanScore":0.8742559523809516,"byKind":{"instrument":{"count":33,"meanScore":0.8838383838383836},"topic":{"count":23,"meanScore":0.9006211180124224},"concept":{"count":30,"meanScore":0.8571428571428574},"benchmark":{"count":10,"meanScore":0.8333333333333333}},"byCriterion":{"lede":{"label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","passRate":1,"applicable":96},"primary-citation":{"label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","passRate":0.9895833333333334,"applicable":96},"drafting-provenance":{"label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","passRate":1,"applicable":96},"evidence-base":{"label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","passRate":0.9895833333333334,"applicable":96},"evidence-diversity":{"label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","passRate":0.96875,"applicable":96},"editorial-recency":{"label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","passRate":0.22916666666666666,"applicable":96},"consensus-assessed":{"label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","passRate":1,"applicable":53}}},"articles":[{"kind":"instrument","slug":"eu-ai-act","title":"EU AI Act","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"236 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"us-eo-14110","title":"Executive Order 14110 on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"230 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"us-eo-14179","title":"Executive Order 14179 — Removing Barriers to American Leadership in AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":false,"note":"no citation anchor"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"0 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"0 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":3,"applicable":6,"score":0.5},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"uk-ai-white-paper","title":"UK Pro-Innovation Approach to AI Regulation (White Paper)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"145 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"6 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"china-genai-measures","title":"Interim Measures for Generative AI Service Management","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"148 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"g7-hiroshima-code","title":"G7 Hiroshima AI Process Code of Conduct","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"122 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"5 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"oecd-ai-principles","title":"OECD AI Principles (Recommendation)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"106 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"coe-ai-convention","title":"Council of Europe Framework Convention on AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"164 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"un-ai-resolution-2024","title":"UN GA Resolution on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"132 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"nist-ai-rmf","title":"NIST AI Risk Management Framework","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"123 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"bletchley-declaration","title":"Bletchley Declaration on AI Safety","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"97 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"seoul-declaration","title":"Seoul Declaration on Safe, Innovative and Inclusive AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"108 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"nist-ai-rmf-genai-profile","title":"NIST AI RMF Generative AI Profile","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"136 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"ca-sb-1047","title":"California SB-1047: Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier AI Models Act","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"99 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"india-dpdpa","title":"India Digital Personal Data Protection Act + AI Advisory (MEITY)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"120 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"brazil-ai-bill","title":"Brazil AI Bill (PL 2338/2023)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"134 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"asean-ai-guide","title":"ASEAN Guide on AI Governance and Ethics","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"99 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"5 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"au-continental-ai-strategy","title":"African Union Continental AI Strategy","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"98 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"anthropic-rsp","title":"Anthropic Responsible Scaling Policy (RSP) v2","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"126 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"openai-preparedness","title":"OpenAI Preparedness Framework","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"108 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"deepmind-fsf","title":"Google DeepMind Frontier Safety Framework","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"102 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"6 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"meta-frontier-ai-framework","title":"Meta Frontier AI Framework","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"119 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"uk-us-aisi-mou","title":"UK-US AI Safety Institute Memorandum of Understanding","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"82 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"5 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"wh-voluntary-2023","title":"White House Voluntary AI Commitments","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"110 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"singapore-model-ai-governance","title":"Singapore Model AI Governance Framework for Generative AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"106 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"6 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"japan-meti-ai-guidelines","title":"Japan METI AI Guidelines for Business","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"106 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"gdpr","title":"General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"69 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"gpai-code-of-practice","title":"EU General-Purpose AI Code of Practice","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"90 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"omb-m-24-10","title":"OMB Memorandum M-24-10 (Advancing Governance, Innovation, and Risk Management for Agency Use of AI)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"102 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"8 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-31"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"gsa-ai-acquisition-guide","title":"GSA Generative AI and Specialized Computing Infrastructure Acquisition Resource Guide","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"100 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-31"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"dod-rai-strategy","title":"DoD Responsible AI Strategy and Implementation Pathway","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"101 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-31"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"fedramp-ai-guidance","title":"FedRAMP AI Cloud Procurement Guidance","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"100 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-31"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"instrument","slug":"dfars-252-204","title":"DFARS Subpart 252.204 (Safeguarding Covered Defense Information and Cyber Incident Reporting)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"80 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-31"}],"passed":6,"applicable":6,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"foundation-models","title":"Foundation Models / GPAI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"biometric-id","title":"Biometric Identification","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"13 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"deepfakes","title":"Deepfakes / Synthetic Content","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"16 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-24"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"employment","title":"AI in Employment","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"13 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"healthcare","title":"AI in Healthcare","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"13 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"criminal-justice","title":"AI in Criminal Justice","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"12 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"1 type"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":5,"applicable":7,"score":0.7142857142857143},{"kind":"topic","slug":"education","title":"AI in Education","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"10 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"compute-reporting","title":"Compute-Threshold Reporting","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"25 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"transparency","title":"Transparency Obligations","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"26 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"redress","title":"Individual Redress","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"16 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"training-data","title":"Training-Data Rights","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"27 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"sovereign-ai","title":"Sovereign AI Doctrine","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"11 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"catastrophic-risk","title":"Catastrophic & Existential Risk","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"17 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"tech-sovereignty","title":"Technological Sovereignty","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"12 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"development-rights-framing","title":"Development-Rights Framings","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"15 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"1 type"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":5,"applicable":7,"score":0.7142857142857143},{"kind":"topic","slug":"international-coordination","title":"International Coordination","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"10 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"topic","slug":"agentic-systems-governance","title":"Agentic AI Governance","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"10 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-26"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"open-weight-release","title":"Open-Weight Frontier Release","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"11 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-26"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"synthetic-content-provenance","title":"Synthetic Content Provenance","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"10 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-26"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"compute-export-controls","title":"Compute + Model-Weight Export Controls","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"9 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"5 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-28"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"environmental-impact-of-training","title":"Environmental Impact of AI Training","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"13 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"2 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-28"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"national-security-carveouts","title":"National Security Carveouts in AI Regulation","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"13 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-28"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"topic","slug":"ai-worker-displacement","title":"AI-Driven Worker Displacement","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"coverage cells cited"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"19 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"last reviewed 2026-05-28"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":7,"applicable":7,"score":1},{"kind":"concept","slug":"frontier-tier","title":"Frontier-Tier AI","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"54 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"asl-3","title":"AI Safety Level 3 (ASL-3)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"54 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"systemic-risk","title":"Systemic Risk (AI)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"66 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"designated-systemic","title":"Designated Systemic-Risk Model","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"67 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"compute-threshold","title":"Compute Threshold (AI Governance)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"62 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"red-team-evaluation","title":"Red-Team Evaluation","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"68 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"model-card","title":"Model Card","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"61 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"alignment","title":"AI Alignment","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"67 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"deceptive-alignment","title":"Deceptive Alignment","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"54 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"mesa-optimization","title":"Mesa-Optimization","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"54 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"scalable-oversight","title":"Scalable Oversight","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"61 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"capability-elicitation","title":"Capability Elicitation","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"67 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"dual-use-research-taxonomy","title":"Dual-Use Research Norms (DURC for AI)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"68 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"provenance-watermarking","title":"Provenance & Watermarking","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"61 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"policy-instrument","title":"Policy Instrument","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"76 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"ai-supply-chain","title":"AI Supply Chain","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"75 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"training-data-attribution","title":"Training-Data Attribution","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"57 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"prompt-injection","title":"Prompt Injection","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"51 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"agentic-system","title":"Agentic AI System","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"63 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"tool-use-safety","title":"Tool-Use Safety","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"50 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"multi-turn-evaluation","title":"Multi-Turn Evaluation","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"67 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"data-poisoning","title":"Data Poisoning","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"68 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"model-distillation-risk","title":"Model Distillation Risk","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"62 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"jailbreak-resistance","title":"Jailbreak Resistance","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"63 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"model-merging-risk","title":"Model-Merging Risk","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"58 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"inference-time-compute","title":"Inference-Time Compute","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"65 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"emerging"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"sandbagging","title":"Sandbagging","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"54 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"contested"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"hallucination","title":"Hallucination","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"73 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"4 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"in-context-learning","title":"In-Context Learning","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"67 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"concept","slug":"retrieval-augmented-generation","title":"Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"primary source linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"78 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"7 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"},{"id":"consensus-assessed","label":"Consensus/contestation assessed (and locus named if contested)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"settled"}],"passed":6,"applicable":7,"score":0.8571428571428571},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"swe-bench-verified","title":"SWE-bench Verified","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"48 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"mmlu","title":"MMLU","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"mmlu-pro","title":"MMLU-Pro","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"gpqa-diamond","title":"GPQA Diamond","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"arc-agi-v2","title":"ARC-AGI v2","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"humaneval","title":"HumanEval","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"math-benchmark","title":"MATH (Hendrycks)","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"aime-2024","title":"AIME 2024","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"humanitys-last-exam","title":"Humanity's Last Exam","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334},{"kind":"benchmark","slug":"frontiermath","title":"FrontierMath","criteria":[{"id":"lede","label":"Opens with a substantive lede","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"lede present"},{"id":"primary-citation","label":"Anchored to a primary source","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"methodology linked"},{"id":"drafting-provenance","label":"Drafting provenance disclosed (charter §7.9)","klass":"baseline","pass":true,"note":"footer discloses drafting mode"},{"id":"evidence-base","label":"Has an academic evidence base","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"38 sources"},{"id":"evidence-diversity","label":"Evidence base spans ≥2 source types (not single-type / critique-only)","klass":"depth","pass":true,"note":"3 types"},{"id":"editorial-recency","label":"Editorially reviewed within 365 days","klass":"depth","pass":false,"note":"no review date"}],"passed":5,"applicable":6,"score":0.8333333333333334}]}