{"name":"Policy Window — article prose citation index","description":"Inline citations parsed deterministically from every published article's developed body sections. Citation kinds: doi, arxiv (resolved against the literature corpus when catalogued), provision (statute/treaty pinpoint — a primary source), author_year. Complements /wiki/graph.json and /wiki/verification.json.","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/prose-citations.json","license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","citationLicense":"CC0 1.0 (citation data, per I4OC)","attribution":"Source: Policy Window AI Governance Catalog (https://policywindow.org/wiki).","catalogContentHash":{"algorithm":"sha256","hash":"27f88c1d52b0836d71db03c6da9b36adf9db9e383e5bfb2fadb0081f2ff6a4ff","cellCount":525,"recipe":"SHA-256 (hex) of the published coverage cells rendered as one line each, `<instrument>:<topic>\\t<type>\\t<citation>\\t<confidence>` (confidence empty if unset), the lines sorted ascending and joined with '\\n'. Re-derive from /wiki/catalog/json: for each entry in `.coverage` emit the same line, sort, hash."},"summary":{"articles":105,"articlesWithCitations":105,"totalCitations":1845,"byKind":{"doi":611,"arxiv":486,"provision":651,"author_year":97},"distinctCorpusSources":332,"corpusResolutionRate":0.8195077484047402,"sectionCitationRate":0.9947916666666666},"articles":[{"slug":"eu-ai-act","kind":"instrument","title":"EU AI Act","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/eu-ai-act","total":45,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":33,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative mechanics: a risk-tiered, product-safety architecture","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(c))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(c))"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(e))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(e))"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(f))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(f))"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(h)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(h))."},{"raw":"Art. 6","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6"},{"raw":"Art. 9)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9)"},{"raw":"Art. 10)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10)"},{"raw":"Art. 11)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 11)"},{"raw":"Art. 12)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 12)"},{"raw":"Art. 13)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 13)"},{"raw":"Art. 14)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14)"},{"raw":"Art. 15)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 15)"},{"raw":"Art. 26(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(2))"},{"raw":"Art. 26(6))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(6))"},{"raw":"Art. 26(7))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(7))"},{"raw":"Art. 27).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 27)."},{"raw":"Art. 50)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50)"},{"raw":"Art. 53)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53)"},{"raw":"Art. 55)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55)"},{"raw":"Art. 51","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2))"},{"raw":"Art. 99","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 99"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-jurisdiction position: the only binding horizontal regime","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.105985","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.105985"},{"raw":"10.1080/17579961.2021.1898300","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/17579961.2021.1898300"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 2","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 58499","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 58499"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2))"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines: enforcement architecture and rights redress","citations":[{"raw":"10.54648/cola2025004","kind":"doi","key":"10.54648/cola2025004"},{"raw":"arXiv:2107.03721","kind":"arxiv","key":"2107.03721"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.16869","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.16869"},{"raw":"Art. 85","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 85"},{"raw":"Art. 86","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 86"},{"raw":"Art. 43","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 43"},{"raw":"Art. 51","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation and trajectory: staggered timeline and the Digital Omnibus","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 113","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113"},{"raw":"Art. 5)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5)"}]}]},{"slug":"us-eo-14110","kind":"instrument","title":"Executive Order 14110 on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/us-eo-14110","total":30,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":15,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 75191","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 75191"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)).","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a))."},{"raw":"§4.2(b))","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(b))"},{"raw":"§4.2(b)).","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(b))."},{"raw":"§4.2(c)-(d)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(c)-(d)"},{"raw":"§4.5","kind":"provision","key":"§4.5"},{"raw":"§4.1","kind":"provision","key":"§4.1"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-jurisdiction position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2)"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"},{"raw":"§4.5)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.5)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines and critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"§4","kind":"provision","key":"§4"},{"raw":"§4.5","kind":"provision","key":"§4.5"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation and trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","sourceId":"lit-megha-shrivastava-and-amrita-jash-china-s-semiconducto","sourceTitle":"China's semiconductor conundrum: understanding US export controls and their efficacy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"§4.1","kind":"provision","key":"§4.1"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8741","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8741"},{"raw":"(Skadden, 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(skadden, 2024)"}]}]},{"slug":"us-eo-14179","kind":"instrument","title":"Executive Order 14179 — Removing Barriers to American Leadership in AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/us-eo-14179","total":15,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":3,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Deregulatory Directive, Not a Substantive Mandate","citations":[{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8741","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8741"},{"raw":"§708","kind":"provision","key":"§708"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position: Deregulatory Pole Against the EU Risk Model","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1017/err.2024.97","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2024.97","sourceId":"lit-francesca-palmiotto-the-ai-act-roller-coaster-the-evol","sourceTitle":"The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1177/0308518X251369704","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0308518x251369704","sourceId":"lit-justin-kollar-andrew-stokols-geopolitical-ecologies-of","sourceTitle":"Geopolitical ecologies of cloud capitalism: Territorial restructuring and the making of national computing power in the U.S. and China"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines: Silence as Governance and the Rights Vacuum","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory: A Live Order Spawning a Broader Arc","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1177/20539517251330160","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20539517251330160","sourceId":"lit-rafael-grohmann-latin-american-critical-data-studies","sourceTitle":"Latin American critical data studies"},{"raw":"10.1080/00083968.2025.2456619","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/00083968.2025.2456619","sourceId":"lit-thompson-gyedu-kwarkye-we-know-what-we-are-doing-the-p","sourceTitle":"\"We know what we are doing\": the politics and trends in artificial intelligence policies in Africa"}]},{"sectionId":"downstream-record","heading":"The Downstream Record: A 180-Day Mandate and the Preemption Offensive","citations":[{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8741","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8741"},{"raw":"(BakerHostetler 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(bakerhostetler 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"uk-ai-white-paper","kind":"instrument","title":"UK Pro-Innovation Approach to AI Regulation (White Paper)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/uk-ai-white-paper","total":18,"distinctSources":14,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the White Paper Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/jols.12535","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/jols.12535","sourceId":"lit-natalie-sheard-algorithm-facilitated-discrimination-a","sourceTitle":"Algorithm-facilitated discrimination: a socio-legal study of the use by employers of artificial intelligence hiring systems"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","sourceId":"lit-gary-e-weissman-toni-mankowitz-genevieve-p-kanter-unre","sourceTitle":"Unregulated large language models produce medical device-like output"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding AI Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"(DSIT 2023)","kind":"author_year","key":"(dsit 2023)"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Coverage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","sourceId":"lit-pedro-robles-daniel-j-mallinson-eric-best-cheryl-devan","sourceTitle":"Global perspectives on regulating facial recognition technology utilization for criminal justice arrests"},{"raw":"10.1080/15614263.2026.2627208","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/15614263.2026.2627208","sourceId":"lit-emelie-stiernstr-mer-facial-recognition-technology-in","sourceTitle":"Facial recognition technology in law enforcement: a scoping review of existing empirical studies"},{"raw":"10.1177/0032258X261439572","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0032258x261439572","sourceId":"lit-shai-farber-machines-of-justice-a-systematic-review-of","sourceTitle":"Machines of justice: A systematic review of AI applications in policing and criminal justice"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","sourceId":"lit-chiara-gallese-predictive-policing-and-predictive-just","sourceTitle":"Predictive policing and predictive justice: Ethics, data protection, and the AI act"},{"raw":"10.21037/jmai-2025-196","kind":"doi","key":"10.21037/jmai-2025-196","sourceId":"lit-aditya-loganathan-michael-friedman-tayab-waseem-et-al","sourceTitle":"Current state of Food and Drug Administration-approved artificial intelligence/machine learning medical devices: pathways, transparency, and evidence gaps"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"(Jones and Lanneau 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(jones and lanneau 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]}]},{"slug":"china-genai-measures","kind":"instrument","title":"Interim Measures for Generative AI Service Management","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/china-genai-measures","total":38,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":17,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"Art. 2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2)"},{"raw":"Art. 4","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4"},{"raw":"Art. 4(1))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(1))"},{"raw":"Art. 4(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(2))"},{"raw":"Art. 4(3))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(3))"},{"raw":"Art. 4(4)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(4))."},{"raw":"Art. 7)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7)"},{"raw":"Art. 8","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 8"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 12","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 12"},{"raw":"Art. 17","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-jurisdiction position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.21279","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.21279"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 17","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"Art. 4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines and critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"arXiv:2401.02799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2401.02799"},{"raw":"Art. 7)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7)"},{"raw":"Art. 4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4)"},{"raw":"Art. 2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2)"},{"raw":"Art. 20)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 20)"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation and trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","kind":"doi","key":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","sourceId":"lit-kyrie-zhixuan-zhou-abhinav-choudhry-ece-gumusel-and-ma","sourceTitle":"'Sora is incredible and scary': public perceptions and governance challenges of text-to-video generative AI models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.21279","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.21279"},{"raw":"Art. 17","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17"},{"raw":"Art. 12","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 12"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"Art. 16)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16)"},{"raw":"(Bird & Bird 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(bird & bird 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"g7-hiroshima-code","kind":"instrument","title":"G7 Hiroshima AI Process Code of Conduct","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/g7-hiroshima-code","total":19,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Code Commits Signatories To","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Implementation Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Influence","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"(Kolt 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(kolt 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"reporting-framework-in-practice","heading":"What the Reporting Framework Has Revealed","citations":[{"raw":"(Brookings 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(brookings 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"oecd-ai-principles","kind":"instrument","title":"OECD AI Principles (Recommendation)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/oecd-ai-principles","total":16,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Recommendation Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Coverage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1145/3724499","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3724499","sourceId":"lit-pengfei-li-jianyi-yang-mohammad-a-islam-shaolei-ren-ma","sourceTitle":"Making AI Less 'Thirsty': Uncovering and Addressing the Secret Water Footprint of AI Models"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-the-simple-macroeconomics-of-ai","sourceTitle":"The simple macroeconomics of AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"revisions-and-monitoring","heading":"Inside the 2023-24 Revisions and the Monitoring Record","citations":[]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Equity Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1080/00083968.2025.2456619","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/00083968.2025.2456619","sourceId":"lit-thompson-gyedu-kwarkye-we-know-what-we-are-doing-the-p","sourceTitle":"\"We know what we are doing\": the politics and trends in artificial intelligence policies in Africa"},{"raw":"10.1177/20539517251330160","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20539517251330160","sourceId":"lit-rafael-grohmann-latin-american-critical-data-studies","sourceTitle":"Latin American critical data studies"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"(OECD 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(oecd 2024)"}]}]},{"slug":"coe-ai-convention","kind":"instrument","title":"Council of Europe Framework Convention on AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/coe-ai-convention","total":39,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":21,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"},{"raw":"Art. 2","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2"},{"raw":"Art. 7)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7)"},{"raw":"Art. 8)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 8)"},{"raw":"Art. 9)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9)"},{"raw":"Art. 10)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10)"},{"raw":"Art. 11).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 11)."},{"raw":"Art. 14)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14)"},{"raw":"Art. 15).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 15)."},{"raw":"Art. 16)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16)"},{"raw":"Art. 16","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16"},{"raw":"Art. 26)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26)"},{"raw":"Art. 23","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 23"},{"raw":"Art. 3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3)"},{"raw":"Art. 3(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(1)(a)"},{"raw":"Art. 3(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(1)(b)"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-jurisdiction position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2025.10070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2025.10070"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","sourceId":"lit-pedro-robles-daniel-j-mallinson-eric-best-cheryl-devan","sourceTitle":"Global perspectives on regulating facial recognition technology utilization for criminal justice arrests"},{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 3(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(1)(b)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines and critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2025.10070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2025.10070"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","sourceId":"lit-chiara-gallese-predictive-policing-and-predictive-just","sourceTitle":"Predictive policing and predictive justice: Ethics, data protection, and the AI act"},{"raw":"Art. 3(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 3(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(3)"},{"raw":"Art. 3(4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(4)"},{"raw":"Art. 3(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(1)(b)"},{"raw":"Art. 23","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 23"},{"raw":"Art. 26)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26)"},{"raw":"(Tzanou & Vogiatzoglou 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(tzanou & vogiatzoglou 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation and trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"Art. 30","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 30"},{"raw":"Art. 16","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16"},{"raw":"Art. 3(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(1)(b)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]}]},{"slug":"un-ai-resolution-2024","kind":"instrument","title":"UN GA Resolution on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/un-ai-resolution-2024","total":19,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: Hortatory Architecture and the Limits of Consensus","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"A/RES/78/265","kind":"provision","key":"A/RES/78/265"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Position Against Binding Regimes and Rival UN Tracks","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines: Aspiration Without Apparatus","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory: Superseded as the UN's Leading Edge","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","sourceId":"lit-erik-brynjolfsson-danielle-li-and-lindsey-r-raymond-ge","sourceTitle":"Generative AI at Work"},{"raw":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-the-simple-macroeconomics-of-ai","sourceTitle":"The simple macroeconomics of AI"},{"raw":"A/RES/79/325","kind":"provision","key":"A/RES/79/325"},{"raw":"A/RES/78/265","kind":"provision","key":"A/RES/78/265"}]}]},{"slug":"nist-ai-rmf","kind":"instrument","title":"NIST AI Risk Management Framework","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/nist-ai-rmf","total":15,"distinctSources":14,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdictional Position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","kind":"doi","key":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","sourceId":"lit-huijuan-peng-and-pey-woan-lee-reimagining-u-s-tort-law","sourceTitle":"Reimagining U.S. Tort Law for Deepfake Harms: Comparative Insights from China and Singapore"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"}]}]},{"slug":"bletchley-declaration","kind":"instrument","title":"Bletchley Declaration on AI Safety","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/bletchley-declaration","total":11,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Declaration Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/risa.70105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/risa.70105","sourceId":"lit-david-m-allison-stephen-herzog-artificial-intelligence","sourceTitle":"Artificial Intelligence and Nuclear Weapons Proliferation: The Technological Arms Race for (In)visibility"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Operative Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]}]},{"slug":"seoul-declaration","kind":"instrument","title":"Seoul Declaration on Safe, Innovative and Inclusive AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/seoul-declaration","total":12,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Declaration Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]}]},{"slug":"nist-ai-rmf-genai-profile","kind":"instrument","title":"NIST AI RMF Generative AI Profile","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/nist-ai-rmf-genai-profile","total":27,"distinctSources":14,"provisionAnchors":11,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Risk Taxonomy, Not a Rule","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"§2","kind":"provision","key":"§2"},{"raw":"§2.1)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.1)"},{"raw":"§2.2)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.2)"},{"raw":"§2.4)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.4)"},{"raw":"§2.10)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.10)"},{"raw":"§2.8)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.8)"},{"raw":"§2.5)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.5)"},{"raw":"§2.12).","kind":"provision","key":"§2.12)."},{"raw":"§3","kind":"provision","key":"§3"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Key Fault-Lines and Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","kind":"doi","key":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","sourceId":"lit-huijuan-peng-and-pey-woan-lee-reimagining-u-s-tort-law","sourceTitle":"Reimagining U.S. Tort Law for Deepfake Harms: Comparative Insights from China and Singapore"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"§2.1)","kind":"provision","key":"§2.1)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory and Political Headwinds","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"}]}]},{"slug":"ca-sb-1047","kind":"instrument","title":"California SB-1047: Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier AI Models Act","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/ca-sb-1047","total":19,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":7,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Compute-and-Cost Threshold Never Brought Into Force","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"§ 22602","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602"},{"raw":"§ 22603).","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22603)."},{"raw":"§ 22602(g))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(g))"},{"raw":"§ 22606)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22606)"},{"raw":"§ 22607)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22607)"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position: A US State Mirror of EU Systemic-Risk Logic","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"§ 22603)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22603)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines: Threshold Evasion, Redress Gaps, and the Veto Rationale","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"§ 22603)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22603)"},{"raw":"§ 22607","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22607"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory: From Veto to the Enforceable SB-53 Successor","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adn0117","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adn0117","sourceId":"lit-bengio-hinton-yao-song-et-al-managing-extreme-ai-risks","sourceTitle":"Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]}]},{"slug":"india-dpdpa","kind":"instrument","title":"India Digital Personal Data Protection Act + AI Advisory (MEITY)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/india-dpdpa","total":21,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":7,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Data-Protection Statute Doing AI's Regulatory Work","citations":[{"raw":"§4-7","kind":"provision","key":"§4-7"},{"raw":"§5","kind":"provision","key":"§5"},{"raw":"§11-14","kind":"provision","key":"§11-14"},{"raw":"§18.","kind":"provision","key":"§18."}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position: Development-First Sovereignty Against the EU Model","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault-Lines: Consent Fictions, Security Carveouts, and a Training-Data Void","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","sourceId":"lit-chiara-gallese-predictive-policing-and-predictive-just","sourceTitle":"Predictive policing and predictive justice: Ethics, data protection, and the AI act"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"§4-7","kind":"provision","key":"§4-7"},{"raw":"§17","kind":"provision","key":"§17"},{"raw":"§11-14","kind":"provision","key":"§11-14"},{"raw":"(Jones & Lanneau 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(jones & lanneau 2025)"},{"raw":"(Tzanou & Vogiatzoglou 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(tzanou & vogiatzoglou 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory: From Paused AI Law to Phased Rules and Labelling Mandates","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"§3(1)(b)(v)","kind":"provision","key":"§3(1)(b)(v)"},{"raw":"(MediaNama 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(medianama 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"brazil-ai-bill","kind":"instrument","title":"Brazil AI Bill (PL 2338/2023)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/brazil-ai-bill","total":18,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":7,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics and Risk Architecture","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Comparative Position and Borrowed Architecture","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines and Critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"Art. 7)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7)"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"},{"raw":"Art. 9)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Legislative Status and Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","sourceId":"lit-erik-brynjolfsson-danielle-li-and-lindsey-r-raymond-ge","sourceTitle":"Generative AI at Work"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"}]}]},{"slug":"asean-ai-guide","kind":"instrument","title":"ASEAN Guide on AI Governance and Ethics","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/asean-ai-guide","total":16,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":3,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Guide Commits Member States To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiae073","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiae073","sourceId":"lit-roberts-hine-taddeo-floridi-global-ai-governance-barri","sourceTitle":"Global AI governance: barriers and pathways forward"},{"raw":"10.1080/01425692.2025.2502808","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/01425692.2025.2502808","sourceId":"lit-yoko-mochizuki-eric-bruillard-audrey-bryan-the-ethics","sourceTitle":"The ethics of AI or techno-solutionism? UNESCO's policy guidance on AI in education"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Regimes","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"},{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Operational Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1145/3724499","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3724499","sourceId":"lit-pengfei-li-jianyi-yang-mohammad-a-islam-shaolei-ren-ma","sourceTitle":"Making AI Less 'Thirsty': Uncovering and Addressing the Secret Water Footprint of AI Models"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Sovereignty Stakes","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"(ASEAN 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(asean 2024)"}]}]},{"slug":"au-continental-ai-strategy","kind":"instrument","title":"African Union Continental AI Strategy","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/au-continental-ai-strategy","total":21,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Strategy Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164.","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"(Kwarkye 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(kwarkye 2025)"},{"raw":"(Grohmann 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(grohmann 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"(FPF 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(fpf 2024)"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093.","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","sourceId":"lit-martin-kretschmer-bartolomeo-meletti-lionel-bently-gab","sourceTitle":"Copyright and AI in the UK: Opting-In or Opting-Out?"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-the-simple-macroeconomics-of-ai","sourceTitle":"The simple macroeconomics of AI"},{"raw":"(Baur 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(baur 2026)"},{"raw":"(Weymouth 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(weymouth 2025)"},{"raw":"(Havlikova 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(havlikova 2025)"},{"raw":"(Acemoglu 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(acemoglu 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","sourceId":"lit-erik-brynjolfsson-danielle-li-and-lindsey-r-raymond-ge","sourceTitle":"Generative AI at Work"},{"raw":"(Robinson 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(robinson 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"anthropic-rsp","kind":"instrument","title":"Anthropic Responsible Scaling Policy (RSP) v2","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/anthropic-rsp","total":13,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Policy Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9.","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"(Eskandar 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(eskandar 2026)"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques, Gaps, and the Agentic Frontier","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Superseded Status","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","sourceId":"lit-megha-shrivastava-and-amrita-jash-china-s-semiconducto","sourceTitle":"China's semiconductor conundrum: understanding US export controls and their efficacy"},{"raw":"(Anthropic 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(anthropic 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"openai-preparedness","kind":"instrument","title":"OpenAI Preparedness Framework","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/openai-preparedness","total":13,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Framework Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1111/risa.70105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/risa.70105","sourceId":"lit-david-m-allison-stephen-herzog-artificial-intelligence","sourceTitle":"Artificial Intelligence and Nuclear Weapons Proliferation: The Technological Arms Race for (In)visibility"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption and Versioning Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"}]}]},{"slug":"deepmind-fsf","kind":"instrument","title":"Google DeepMind Frontier Safety Framework","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/deepmind-fsf","total":10,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Framework Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Coverage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption and Versioning Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"}]}]},{"slug":"meta-frontier-ai-framework","kind":"instrument","title":"Meta Frontier AI Framework","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/meta-frontier-ai-framework","total":21,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Framework Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"(Eskandar 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(eskandar 2026)"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2.","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"(Hulok 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(hulok 2025)"},{"raw":"(Radeisen 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(radeisen 2026)"},{"raw":"(Ruschemeier 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(ruschemeier 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"},{"raw":"(Kasirzadeh 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(kasirzadeh 2025)"},{"raw":"(Kolt 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(kolt 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption and Revision Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","sourceId":"lit-megha-shrivastava-and-amrita-jash-china-s-semiconducto","sourceTitle":"China's semiconductor conundrum: understanding US export controls and their efficacy"},{"raw":"10.1111/risa.70105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/risa.70105","sourceId":"lit-david-m-allison-stephen-herzog-artificial-intelligence","sourceTitle":"Artificial Intelligence and Nuclear Weapons Proliferation: The Technological Arms Race for (In)visibility"},{"raw":"(Shrivastava & Jash 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(shrivastava & jash 2025)"},{"raw":"(Allison & Herzog 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(allison & herzog 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"uk-us-aisi-mou","kind":"instrument","title":"UK-US AI Safety Institute Memorandum of Understanding","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/uk-us-aisi-mou","total":17,"distinctSources":14,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adn0117","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adn0117","sourceId":"lit-bengio-hinton-yao-song-et-al-managing-extreme-ai-risks","sourceTitle":"Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51-55)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51-55)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.09674","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.09674","sourceId":"lit-tobin-south-samuele-marro-thomas-hardjono-robert-mahar","sourceTitle":"Authenticated Delegation and Authorized AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10010","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10010","sourceId":"lit-ana-maria-corr-a-sara-garsia-abdullah-elbi-better-toge","sourceTitle":"Better together? Human oversight as means to achieve fairness in the European AI Act governance"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]}]},{"slug":"wh-voluntary-2023","kind":"instrument","title":"White House Voluntary AI Commitments","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/wh-voluntary-2023","total":19,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Commitments Actually Commit To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","kind":"doi","key":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","sourceId":"lit-huijuan-peng-and-pey-woan-lee-reimagining-u-s-tort-law","sourceTitle":"Reimagining U.S. Tort Law for Deepfake Harms: Comparative Insights from China and Singapore"},{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Current Standing","citations":[{"raw":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","kind":"doi","key":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","sourceId":"lit-kyrie-zhixuan-zhou-abhinav-choudhry-ece-gumusel-and-ma","sourceTitle":"'Sora is incredible and scary': public perceptions and governance challenges of text-to-video generative AI models"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)"}]}]},{"slug":"singapore-model-ai-governance","kind":"instrument","title":"Singapore Model AI Governance Framework for Generative AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/singapore-model-ai-governance","total":18,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Framework Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","kind":"doi","key":"10.1515/jtl-2025-0028","sourceId":"lit-huijuan-peng-and-pey-woan-lee-reimagining-u-s-tort-law","sourceTitle":"Reimagining U.S. Tort Law for Deepfake Harms: Comparative Insights from China and Singapore"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","kind":"doi","key":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","sourceId":"lit-kyrie-zhixuan-zhou-abhinav-choudhry-ece-gumusel-and-ma","sourceTitle":"'Sora is incredible and scary': public perceptions and governance challenges of text-to-video generative AI models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"(OECD.AI 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(oecd.ai 2024)"},{"raw":"(IMDA 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(imda 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"japan-meti-ai-guidelines","kind":"instrument","title":"Japan METI AI Guidelines for Business","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/japan-meti-ai-guidelines","total":18,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Guidelines Commit To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"(FPF 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(fpf 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"binding-perimeter","heading":"Where Duties Actually Bite: Copyright and Hiroshima Attestation","citations":[{"raw":"Article 30-4","kind":"provision","key":"Article 30-4"},{"raw":"(OECD.AI 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(oecd.ai 2025)"},{"raw":"(MIC 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(mic 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Coverage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","kind":"doi","key":"10.47989/ir30iconf47290","sourceId":"lit-kyrie-zhixuan-zhou-abhinav-choudhry-ece-gumusel-and-ma","sourceTitle":"'Sora is incredible and scary': public perceptions and governance challenges of text-to-video generative AI models"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-the-simple-macroeconomics-of-ai","sourceTitle":"The simple macroeconomics of AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","sourceId":"lit-erik-brynjolfsson-danielle-li-and-lindsey-r-raymond-ge","sourceTitle":"Generative AI at Work"}]}]},{"slug":"gdpr","kind":"instrument","title":"General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/gdpr","total":43,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":30,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","sourceId":"lit-taner-kuru-lawfulness-of-the-mass-processing-of-public","sourceTitle":"Lawfulness of the mass processing of publicly accessible online data to train large language models"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2016/679","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2016/679"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(a)-(f)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(a)-(f)"},{"raw":"Art. 5(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 6(1)(a)-(f)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6(1)(a)-(f)"},{"raw":"Art. 9(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9(1)"},{"raw":"Art. 9(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 22(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22(1)"},{"raw":"Art. 22(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 22(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22(3)"},{"raw":"Art. 35(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 35(1)"},{"raw":"Art. 35(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 35(3)"},{"raw":"Art. 35(7).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 35(7)."},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"Art. 3(1))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(1))"},{"raw":"Art. 3(2)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(2))."},{"raw":"Art. 83","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 83"},{"raw":"Art. 83(4))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 83(4))"},{"raw":"Art. 83(5))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 83(5))"},{"raw":"Art. 65.","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 65."}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-jurisdiction position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"arXiv:2312.08237","kind":"arxiv","key":"2312.08237"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(c)-(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(c)-(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 26(11)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(11)"},{"raw":"Art. 22","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22"},{"raw":"Art. 27","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 27"},{"raw":"Art. 35","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 35"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines and critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","sourceId":"lit-wachter-mittelstadt-floridi-why-a-right-to-explanation","sourceTitle":"Why a Right to Explanation of Automated Decision-Making Does Not Exist in the General Data Protection Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipx022","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipx022"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"Art. 22(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22(3)"},{"raw":"Art. 22(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22(1)"},{"raw":"Art. 65","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 65"},{"raw":"Art. 6(1)(f)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6(1)(f)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation and trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","sourceId":"lit-taner-kuru-lawfulness-of-the-mass-processing-of-public","sourceTitle":"Lawfulness of the mass processing of publicly accessible online data to train large language models"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2025/2518","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2025/2518"},{"raw":"Art. 88c","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 88c"},{"raw":"Art. 6(1)(f)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6(1)(f)"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"}]}]},{"slug":"gpai-code-of-practice","kind":"instrument","title":"EU General-Purpose AI Code of Practice","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/gpai-code-of-practice","total":23,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":11,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Code Commits Adherents To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"Article 56","kind":"provision","key":"Article 56"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(a)-(c)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(a)-(c)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(c)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(c)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"},{"raw":"Art. 56(8)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 56(8)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"},{"raw":"Art. 65","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 65"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Compliance Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","sourceId":"lit-martin-kretschmer-bartolomeo-meletti-lionel-bently-gab","sourceTitle":"Copyright and AI in the UK: Opting-In or Opting-Out?"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"(Havlikova 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(havlikova 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Outlook","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"}]}]},{"slug":"omb-m-24-10","kind":"instrument","title":"OMB Memorandum M-24-10 (Advancing Governance, Innovation, and Risk Management for Agency Use of AI)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/omb-m-24-10","total":15,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: Three Pillars and the Risk-Management Floor","citations":[{"raw":"§5(c)","kind":"provision","key":"§5(c)"},{"raw":"§3(a)(iv)","kind":"provision","key":"§3(a)(iv)"},{"raw":"§3(a)(v)","kind":"provision","key":"§3(a)(v)"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"§5(c)(v)(D)","kind":"provision","key":"§5(c)(v)(D)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1111/jols.12535","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/jols.12535","sourceId":"lit-natalie-sheard-algorithm-facilitated-discrimination-a","sourceTitle":"Algorithm-facilitated discrimination: a socio-legal study of the use by employers of artificial intelligence hiring systems"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","sourceId":"lit-gary-e-weissman-toni-mankowitz-genevieve-p-kanter-unre","sourceTitle":"Unregulated large language models produce medical device-like output"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"§5(c)","kind":"provision","key":"§5(c)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory and Redress Design","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.48550/arXiv.2504.18236","kind":"doi","key":"10.48550/arxiv.2504.18236","sourceId":"lit-timoth-e-schmude-mireia-yurrita-kars-alfrink-thomas-le","sourceTitle":"Two Means to an End Goal: Connecting Explainability and Contestability in the Regulation of Public Sector AI"},{"raw":"§3(a)(iv)","kind":"provision","key":"§3(a)(iv)"},{"raw":"§5(c)(v)(D)","kind":"provision","key":"§5(c)(v)(D)"}]}]},{"slug":"gsa-ai-acquisition-guide","kind":"instrument","title":"GSA Generative AI and Specialized Computing Infrastructure Acquisition Resource Guide","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/gsa-ai-acquisition-guide","total":14,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-directs-agencies-to-do","heading":"What the Guide Directs Agencies to Do","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"}]},{"sectionId":"what-the-primary-text-contains","heading":"What the Primary Text Actually Contains","citations":[]},{"sectionId":"standing-relative-to-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","sourceId":"lit-martin-kretschmer-bartolomeo-meletti-lionel-bently-gab","sourceTitle":"Copyright and AI in the UK: Opting-In or Opting-Out?"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"(Havlikova 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(havlikova 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Outlook","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2024.97","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2024.97","sourceId":"lit-francesca-palmiotto-the-ai-act-roller-coaster-the-evol","sourceTitle":"The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","sourceId":"lit-ezgi-yazici-toward-a-global-standard-for-ethical-ai-re","sourceTitle":"Toward a global standard for ethical AI regulation: addressing gaps in AI-driven biometric and high-resolution satellite imaging in the EU AI Act"}]}]},{"slug":"dod-rai-strategy","kind":"instrument","title":"DoD Responsible AI Strategy and Implementation Pathway","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/dod-rai-strategy","total":14,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Strategy Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adn0117","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adn0117","sourceId":"lit-bengio-hinton-yao-song-et-al-managing-extreme-ai-risks","sourceTitle":"Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2024.97","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2024.97","sourceId":"lit-francesca-palmiotto-the-ai-act-roller-coaster-the-evol","sourceTitle":"The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"(Jones & Lanneau 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(jones & lanneau 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Coverage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Outlook","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"10.1111/risa.70105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/risa.70105","sourceId":"lit-david-m-allison-stephen-herzog-artificial-intelligence","sourceTitle":"Artificial Intelligence and Nuclear Weapons Proliferation: The Technological Arms Race for (In)visibility"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"}]}]},{"slug":"fedramp-ai-guidance","kind":"instrument","title":"FedRAMP AI Cloud Procurement Guidance","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/fedramp-ai-guidance","total":16,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Guidance Commits To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"§3607)","kind":"provision","key":"§3607)"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Structural Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Adoption Trajectory and Outlook","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2024.97","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2024.97","sourceId":"lit-francesca-palmiotto-the-ai-act-roller-coaster-the-evol","sourceTitle":"The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","sourceId":"lit-ezgi-yazici-toward-a-global-standard-for-ethical-ai-re","sourceTitle":"Toward a global standard for ethical AI regulation: addressing gaps in AI-driven biometric and high-resolution satellite imaging in the EU AI Act"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"(Jones and Lanneau 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(jones and lanneau 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"prioritization-experiment","heading":"The Prioritization Experiment: What Concretely Changed","citations":[{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 75220","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 75220"},{"raw":"(Winvale 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(winvale 2025)"},{"raw":"(NIST 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(nist 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"dfars-252-204","kind":"instrument","title":"DFARS Subpart 252.204 (Safeguarding Covered Defense Information and Cyber Incident Reporting)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/dfars-252-204","total":11,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: CDI Safeguarding and 72-Hour Incident Reporting","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"}]},{"sectionId":"ai-coverage-by-designation","heading":"AI Coverage as a Designation Artefact, Not a Technology Rule","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"}]},{"sectionId":"national-security-overlay","heading":"The Subpart as a National-Security Overlay Regime","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2024.97","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2024.97","sourceId":"lit-francesca-palmiotto-the-ai-act-roller-coaster-the-evol","sourceTitle":"The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","sourceId":"lit-ezgi-yazici-toward-a-global-standard-for-ethical-ai-re","sourceTitle":"Toward a global standard for ethical AI regulation: addressing gaps in AI-driven biometric and high-resolution satellite imaging in the EU AI Act"},{"raw":"(Jones and Lanneau 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(jones and lanneau 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"fault-lines-and-trajectory","heading":"Fault Lines and Implementation Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"}]}]},{"slug":"ca-sb-53","kind":"instrument","title":"California SB-53: Transparency in Frontier Artificial Intelligence Act (TFAIA)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/ca-sb-53","total":22,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":12,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Disclosure Regime Keyed to Compute","citations":[{"raw":"§ 22757.11).","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.11)."},{"raw":"§ 22757.12).","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.12)."},{"raw":"§ 22757.13","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.13"},{"raw":"§ 22757.15).","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.15)."}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1177/0308518X251369704","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0308518x251369704","sourceId":"lit-justin-kollar-andrew-stokols-geopolitical-ecologies-of","sourceTitle":"Geopolitical ecologies of cloud capitalism: Territorial restructuring and the making of national computing power in the U.S. and China"},{"raw":"§ 22757.11","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.11"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"},{"raw":"§ 11546.8)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 11546.8)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault-Lines and Critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"§ 22757.11.","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.11."},{"raw":"§ 22757.13)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.13)"},{"raw":"§ 1107","kind":"provision","key":"§ 1107"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-025-00872-9","sourceId":"lit-kirolos-eskandar-artificial-intelligence-and-synthetic","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and synthetic biology: biosecurity risks, dual-use concerns, and governance pathways"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"§ 22757.12","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.12"},{"raw":"§ 11546.8)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 11546.8)"}]}]},{"slug":"ca-sb-243","kind":"instrument","title":"California SB 243: Companion Chatbots","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/ca-sb-243","total":22,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":10,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics","citations":[{"raw":"§ 22601","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22601"},{"raw":"§ 22602(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(a)"},{"raw":"§ 22602(b))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(b))"},{"raw":"§ 22602(c))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(c))"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position","citations":[{"raw":"§ 22602(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(a)"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3544548.3581161","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3544548.3581161","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-tim-draws-agathe-balayn-dave-murray-rus","sourceTitle":"Disentangling Fairness Perceptions in Algorithmic Decision-Making: the Effects of Explanations, Human Oversight, and Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11023-022-09611-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11023-022-09611-z","sourceId":"lit-kars-alfrink-ianus-keller-gerd-kortuem-neelke-doorn-co","sourceTitle":"Contestable AI by Design: Towards a Framework"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","sourceId":"lit-gary-e-weissman-toni-mankowitz-genevieve-p-kanter-unre","sourceTitle":"Unregulated large language models produce medical device-like output"},{"raw":"10.1016/S2589-7500(24)00124-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/s2589-7500(24)00124-9","sourceId":"lit-oscar-freyer-isabella-catharina-wiest-jakob-nikolas-ka","sourceTitle":"A future role for health applications of large language models depends on regulators enforcing safety standards"},{"raw":"§ 22605","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22605"},{"raw":"§ 22602(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(a)"},{"raw":"§ 22602(b)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(b)"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3632753","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3632753","sourceId":"lit-henrik-palmer-olsen-thomas-troels-hildebrandt-corneliu","sourceTitle":"The Right to Transparency in Public Governance: Freedom of Information and the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Public Agencies"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01717-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01717-9","sourceId":"lit-boris-babic-i-glenn-cohen-ariel-dora-stern-yiwen-li-me","sourceTitle":"A general framework for governing marketed AI/ML medical devices"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01618-x","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01618-x","sourceId":"lit-vijaytha-muralidharan-madelena-y-ng-shada-alsalamah-sa","sourceTitle":"Global Initiative on AI for Health (GI-AI4H): strategic priorities advancing governance across the United Nations"},{"raw":"§ 22602","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602"},{"raw":"§ 22603","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22603"},{"raw":"§ 22602(b)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22602(b)"}]}]},{"slug":"ca-sb-942","kind":"instrument","title":"California SB 942: AI Transparency Act","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/ca-sb-942","total":23,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":14,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Provenance-and-Disclosure Triad","citations":[{"raw":"§ 22757","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757"},{"raw":"§ 22757.1)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.1)"},{"raw":"§ 22757.2(a))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.2(a))"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(a))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(a))"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(b)).","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(b))."},{"raw":"§ 22757.4)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.4)"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position: A Watermarking Convergence","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(b))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(b))"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault Lines: Scope Hooks, Foundation-Model Silence, and Detection Fragility","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","sourceId":"lit-groh-sankaranarayanan-singh-kim-lippman-picard-human-d","sourceTitle":"Human detection of political speech deepfakes across transcripts, audio, and video"},{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"§ 22757.2","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.2"},{"raw":"§ 22757.1","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.1"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory: A Phased, Deferred Rollout","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.07918","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.07918","sourceId":"lit-sayash-kapoor-rishi-bommasani-kevin-klyman-shayne-long","sourceTitle":"On the Societal Impact of Open Foundation Models"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3.1","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3.1"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3.2","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3.2"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3.3)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3.3)"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(c))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(c))"}]}]},{"slug":"eu-product-liability-directive","kind":"instrument","title":"Revised Product Liability Directive (Directive (EU) 2024/2853)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/eu-product-liability-directive","total":21,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":11,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative mechanics: strict liability re-engineered for software and AI","citations":[{"raw":"Art. 4(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(1)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 6","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6"},{"raw":"Art. 8","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 8"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 10","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10"}]},{"sectionId":"the-complexity-presumption","heading":"The complexity presumption and the opacity problem","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658948","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658948","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-carson-ezell-max-kaufmann-kevin-wei-lewis-ha","sourceTitle":"Visibility into AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.12137","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.12137","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-noam-kolt-peter-wills-usman-anwar-christian","sourceTitle":"IDs for AI Systems"},{"raw":"Art. 10(4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10(4)"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 10(2)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10(2)(a)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"agentic-and-post-market-mutability","heading":"Agentic systems and post-market mutability","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.10114","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.10114","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-kevin-wei-sihao-huang-nitarshan-rajkumar-eli","sourceTitle":"Infrastructure for AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.09674","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.09674","sourceId":"lit-tobin-south-samuele-marro-thomas-hardjono-robert-mahar","sourceTitle":"Authenticated Delegation and Authorized AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"Art. 7(2)(c)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7(2)(c)"},{"raw":"Art. 11(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 11(2)"}]},{"sectionId":"fault-lines-and-trajectory","heading":"Fault lines, status, and implementation trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"Art. 2(1))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2(1))"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]}]},{"slug":"unesco-ai-ethics-recommendation","kind":"instrument","title":"UNESCO Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/unesco-ai-ethics-recommendation","total":15,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"what-it-commits-to","heading":"What the Recommendation Commits Member States To","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/indlaw/dwaf018","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/indlaw/dwaf018","sourceId":"lit-sandra-fredman-darcy-du-toit-alessio-bertolini-jonas-v","sourceTitle":"Fair Work for Platform Workers: Lessons from the EU Directive and Beyond"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","sourceId":"lit-gary-e-weissman-toni-mankowitz-genevieve-p-kanter-unre","sourceTitle":"Unregulated large language models produce medical device-like output"},{"raw":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s44387-025-00048-0","sourceId":"lit-maarten-buyl-alexander-rogiers-sander-noels-et-al-larg","sourceTitle":"Large language models reflect the ideology of their creators"}]},{"sectionId":"standing-vs-binding-law","heading":"Legal Standing Relative to Binding Law","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-gaps","heading":"Critiques and Coverage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/15614263.2026.2627208","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/15614263.2026.2627208","sourceId":"lit-emelie-stiernstr-mer-facial-recognition-technology-in","sourceTitle":"Facial recognition technology in law enforcement: a scoping review of existing empirical studies"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","sourceId":"lit-pedro-robles-daniel-j-mallinson-eric-best-cheryl-devan","sourceTitle":"Global perspectives on regulating facial recognition technology utilization for criminal justice arrests"},{"raw":"10.1177/0032258X261439572","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0032258x261439572","sourceId":"lit-shai-farber-machines-of-justice-a-systematic-review-of","sourceTitle":"Machines of justice: A systematic review of AI applications in policing and criminal justice"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1111/jols.12535","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/jols.12535","sourceId":"lit-natalie-sheard-algorithm-facilitated-discrimination-a","sourceTitle":"Algorithm-facilitated discrimination: a socio-legal study of the use by employers of artificial intelligence hiring systems"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"}]},{"sectionId":"adoption-trajectory","heading":"Implementation and Adoption Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-the-simple-macroeconomics-of-ai","sourceTitle":"The simple macroeconomics of AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","sourceId":"lit-erik-brynjolfsson-danielle-li-and-lindsey-r-raymond-ge","sourceTitle":"Generative AI at Work"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"}]}]},{"slug":"eu-platform-work-directive","kind":"instrument","title":"Directive (EU) 2024/2831 on improving working conditions in platform work","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/eu-platform-work-directive","total":22,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":10,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: Two Pillars over Platform Work","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/indlaw/dwaf018","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/indlaw/dwaf018","sourceId":"lit-sandra-fredman-darcy-du-toit-alessio-bertolini-jonas-v","sourceTitle":"Fair Work for Platform Workers: Lessons from the EU Directive and Beyond"},{"raw":"10.1177/20319525231167299","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20319525231167299","sourceId":"lit-jeremias-adams-prassl-halefom-abraha-aislinn-kelly-lyt","sourceTitle":"Regulating algorithmic management: A blueprint"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"},{"raw":"Art. 8","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 8"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 10","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10"},{"raw":"Art. 11","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 11"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","sourceId":"lit-wachter-mittelstadt-floridi-why-a-right-to-explanation","sourceTitle":"Why a Right to Explanation of Automated Decision-Making Does Not Exist in the General Data Protection Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1177/10242589221141055","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/10242589221141055","sourceId":"lit-valerio-de-stefano-and-simon-taes-algorithmic-manageme","sourceTitle":"Algorithmic management and collective bargaining"},{"raw":"Article 22","kind":"provision","key":"Article 22"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 11","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 11"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault-Lines and Critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/rego.12391","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/rego.12391","sourceId":"lit-emre-bayaml-o-lu-the-right-to-contest-automated-decisi","sourceTitle":"The right to contest automated decisions under the General Data Protection Regulation: Beyond the so-called 'right to explanation'"},{"raw":"10.1177/20319525231167299","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20319525231167299","sourceId":"lit-jeremias-adams-prassl-halefom-abraha-aislinn-kelly-lyt","sourceTitle":"Regulating algorithmic management: A blueprint"},{"raw":"arXiv:1711.00399","kind":"arxiv","key":"1711.00399","sourceId":"lit-sandra-wachter-brent-mittelstadt-chris-russell-counter","sourceTitle":"Counterfactual Explanations Without Opening the Black Box: Automated Decisions and the GDPR"},{"raw":"Art. 11)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 11)"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"}]},{"sectionId":"implementation-trajectory","heading":"Implementation Trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1257/jep.33.2.3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1257/jep.33.2.3","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-and-pascual-restrepo-automation-and-new","sourceTitle":"Automation and New Tasks: How Technology Displaces and Reinstates Labor"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.019","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.019","sourceId":"lit-frey-osborne-the-future-of-employment-how-susceptible","sourceTitle":"The future of employment: How susceptible are jobs to computerisation?"},{"raw":"Art. 9)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9)"},{"raw":"Art. 10)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10)"}]}]},{"slug":"china-deep-synthesis-provisions","kind":"instrument","title":"Provisions on the Administration of Deep Synthesis of Internet Information Services","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/china-deep-synthesis-provisions","total":31,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":14,"sections":[{"sectionId":"operative-mechanics","heading":"Operative Mechanics: A Two-Tier Labelling Regime","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3610061","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3610061","sourceId":"lit-k-j-kevin-feng-nick-ritchie-pia-blumenthal-andy-parson","sourceTitle":"Examining the Impact of Provenance-Enabled Media on Trust and Accuracy Perceptions"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10676-023-09728-4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10676-023-09728-4","sourceId":"lit-alistair-knott-dino-pedreschi-raja-chatila-et-al-incl","sourceTitle":"Generative AI models should include detection mechanisms as a condition for public release"},{"raw":"Art. 16)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16)"},{"raw":"Art. 18","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 18"},{"raw":"Art. 17)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17)"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"Art. 12","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 12"}]},{"sectionId":"cross-jurisdiction-position","heading":"Cross-Jurisdiction Position","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Art. 17","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"Art. 23","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 23"},{"raw":"Art. 19)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 19)"},{"raw":"Art. 20)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 20)"},{"raw":"Art. 9)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9)"},{"raw":"(White & Case 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(white & case 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key Fault-Lines and Critiques","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","sourceId":"lit-keith-raymond-harris-ai-or-your-lying-eyes-some-shortc","sourceTitle":"AI or Your Lying Eyes: Some Shortcomings of Artificially Intelligent Deepfake Detectors"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","sourceId":"lit-groh-sankaranarayanan-singh-kim-lippman-picard-human-d","sourceTitle":"Human detection of political speech deepfakes across transcripts, audio, and video"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.04378","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.04378","sourceId":"lit-hanlin-zhang-benjamin-l-edelman-danilo-francati-daniel","sourceTitle":"Watermarks in the Sand: Impossibility of Strong Watermarking for Generative Models"},{"raw":"Art. 16","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16"},{"raw":"Art. 18","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 18"},{"raw":"Art. 17)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17)"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"}]},{"sectionId":"harm-landscape","heading":"The Harm Landscape the Labels Target","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s13347-020-00419-2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s13347-020-00419-2","sourceId":"lit-fallis-the-epistemic-threat-of-deepfakes","sourceTitle":"The Epistemic Threat of Deepfakes"},{"raw":"10.1177/2056305120903408","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/2056305120903408","sourceId":"lit-vaccari-chadwick-deepfakes-and-disinformation-explorin","sourceTitle":"Deepfakes and Disinformation: Exploring the Impact of Synthetic Political Video on Deception, Uncertainty, and Trust in News"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106024","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106024","sourceId":"lit-beatriz-kira-when-non-consensual-intimate-deepfakes-go","sourceTitle":"When non-consensual intimate deepfakes go viral: The insufficiency of the UK Online Safety Act"},{"raw":"Art. 17","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"},{"raw":"Art. 12","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 12"}]}]},{"slug":"foundation-models","kind":"topic","title":"Foundation Models / GPAI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/foundation-models","total":23,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":14,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches: the concrete mechanisms","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Article 53(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 53(1)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(a)-(d)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(a)-(d))."},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)-(d))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)-(d))"},{"raw":"Article 17","kind":"provision","key":"Article 17"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","sourceId":"lit-hacker-engel-mauer-regulating-chatgpt-and-other-large","sourceTitle":"Regulating ChatGPT and other Large Generative AI Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.05694","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.05694"},{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2203.15556","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.15556","sourceId":"lit-jordan-hoffmann-sebastian-borgeaud-arthur-mensch-et-al","sourceTitle":"Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Art. 51","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51"},{"raw":"§22757.11)","kind":"provision","key":"§22757.11)"},{"raw":"Art. 2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2)"},{"raw":"§5","kind":"provision","key":"§5"},{"raw":"Article 53","kind":"provision","key":"Article 53"},{"raw":"§22602)","kind":"provision","key":"§22602)"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory: what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Article 101","kind":"provision","key":"Article 101"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8741","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8741"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8237","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8237"}]}]},{"slug":"biometric-id","kind":"topic","title":"Biometric Identification","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/biometric-id","total":25,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":14,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43508-025-00117-9","sourceId":"lit-pedro-robles-daniel-j-mallinson-eric-best-cheryl-devan","sourceTitle":"Global perspectives on regulating facial recognition technology utilization for criminal justice arrests"},{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-021-00077-w","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-021-00077-w","sourceId":"lit-almeida-shmarko-lomas-the-ethics-of-facial-recognition","sourceTitle":"The ethics of facial recognition technologies, surveillance, and accountability in an age of artificial intelligence"},{"raw":"10.1177/14613557221089558","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/14613557221089558","sourceId":"lit-dallas-hill-christopher-d-o-connor-andrea-slane-police","sourceTitle":"Police use of facial recognition technology: The potential for engaging the public through co-constructed policy-making"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(h))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(h))"},{"raw":"Art. 5(2)-(7))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(2)-(7))"},{"raw":"Art. 26(10)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(10))."},{"raw":"Art. 9(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 22","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22"},{"raw":"Art. 14).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14)."},{"raw":"(DSIT 2023)","kind":"author_year","key":"(dsit 2023)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1468-2230.12862","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1468-2230.12862","sourceId":"lit-daragh-murray-police-use-of-retrospective-facial-recog","sourceTitle":"Police Use of Retrospective Facial Recognition Technology: A Step Change in Surveillance Capability Necessitating an Evolution of the Human Rights Law Framework"},{"raw":"10.3390/laws13030035","kind":"doi","key":"10.3390/laws13030035","sourceId":"lit-nessa-lynch-facial-recognition-technology-in-policing","sourceTitle":"Facial Recognition Technology in Policing and Security—Case Studies in Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1111/1468-2230.12623","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1468-2230.12623","sourceId":"lit-bernard-keenan-automatic-facial-recognition-and-the-in","sourceTitle":"Automatic Facial Recognition and the Intensification of Police Surveillance"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(h))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(h))"},{"raw":"Art. 26(10))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(10))"},{"raw":"Article 8","kind":"provision","key":"Article 8"},{"raw":"Art. 9(2)(g)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9(2)(g)"},{"raw":"Art. 22(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22(2)"},{"raw":"Article 7).","kind":"provision","key":"Article 7)."}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory / what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10610-022-09512-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10610-022-09512-y","sourceId":"lit-raposo-the-use-of-facial-recognition-technology-by-law","sourceTitle":"The Use of Facial Recognition Technology by Law Enforcement in Europe: a Non-Orwellian Draft Proposal"},{"raw":"10.3389/fdata.2024.1354659","kind":"doi","key":"10.3389/fdata.2024.1354659","sourceId":"lit-mais-qandeel-facial-recognition-technology-regulations","sourceTitle":"Facial recognition technology: regulations, rights and the rule of law"},{"raw":"10.1080/15614263.2026.2627208","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/15614263.2026.2627208","sourceId":"lit-emelie-stiernstr-mer-facial-recognition-technology-in","sourceTitle":"Facial recognition technology in law enforcement: a scoping review of existing empirical studies"},{"raw":"Article 5","kind":"provision","key":"Article 5"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"}]}]},{"slug":"deepfakes","kind":"topic","title":"Deepfakes / Synthetic Content","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/deepfakes","total":25,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":16,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches: four distinct mechanisms","citations":[{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106024","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106024","sourceId":"lit-beatriz-kira-when-non-consensual-intimate-deepfakes-go","sourceTitle":"When non-consensual intimate deepfakes go viral: The insufficiency of the UK Online Safety Act"},{"raw":"Art. 50(4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(4)"},{"raw":"Art. 50(4)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(4))."},{"raw":"Art. 50(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 50(2)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(2))."},{"raw":"Art. 6).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6)."},{"raw":"§3).","kind":"provision","key":"§3)."},{"raw":"§5","kind":"provision","key":"§5"},{"raw":"§5)","kind":"provision","key":"§5)"},{"raw":"Art. 17).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17)."},{"raw":"§3(1)(b)(v)","kind":"provision","key":"§3(1)(b)(v)"},{"raw":"§3(1)(b)(v)).","kind":"provision","key":"§3(1)(b)(v))."}]},{"sectionId":"definitional-contestation","heading":"Definitional contestation: what counts as a deepfake","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.09961","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.09961"},{"raw":"Art. 3(60)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(60)"},{"raw":"Art. 3(60)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(60))."},{"raw":"Art. 50(4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(4)"},{"raw":"§2).","kind":"provision","key":"§2)."}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines: where jurisdictions and experts diverge","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","sourceId":"lit-keith-raymond-harris-ai-or-your-lying-eyes-some-shortc","sourceTitle":"AI or Your Lying Eyes: Some Shortcomings of Artificially Intelligent Deepfake Detectors"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10011","sourceId":"lit-bao-kham-chau-and-george-he-audio-deepfakes-and-the-re","sourceTitle":"Audio deepfakes and the regulation of the landlords of creativity"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"arXiv:2306.01953","kind":"arxiv","key":"2306.01953"},{"raw":"Art. 6)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6)"},{"raw":"§4.5","kind":"provision","key":"§4.5"}]}]},{"slug":"employment","kind":"topic","title":"AI in Employment","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/employment","total":18,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":7,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1177/20319525211062558","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20319525211062558","sourceId":"lit-jeremias-adams-prassl-regulating-algorithms-at-work-le","sourceTitle":"Regulating Algorithms at Work: Lessons for a 'European Approach to Artificial Intelligence'"},{"raw":"10.1145/3351095.3372828","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3351095.3372828","sourceId":"lit-manish-raghavan-solon-barocas-jon-kleinberg-karen-levy","sourceTitle":"Mitigating Bias in Algorithmic Hiring: Evaluating Claims and Practices"},{"raw":"§4","kind":"provision","key":"§4"},{"raw":"Article 26","kind":"provision","key":"Article 26"},{"raw":"Art. 26(7))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 26(7))"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 27)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 27)"},{"raw":"§20-870","kind":"provision","key":"§20-870"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658998","sourceId":"lit-lucas-wright-roxana-mika-muenster-briana-vecchione-tia","sourceTitle":"Null Compliance: NYC Local Law 144 and the Challenges of Algorithm Accountability"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658959","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658959","sourceId":"lit-lara-groves-jacob-metcalf-alayna-kennedy-briana-vecchi","sourceTitle":"Auditing Work: Exploring the New York City Algorithmic Bias Audit Regime"},{"raw":"10.1177/10242589221141055","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/10242589221141055","sourceId":"lit-valerio-de-stefano-and-simon-taes-algorithmic-manageme","sourceTitle":"Algorithmic management and collective bargaining"},{"raw":"10.1177/20319525231167299","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20319525231167299","sourceId":"lit-jeremias-adams-prassl-halefom-abraha-aislinn-kelly-lyt","sourceTitle":"Regulating algorithmic management: A blueprint"},{"raw":"10.1177/20319525231167300","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/20319525231167300","sourceId":"lit-aislinn-kelly-lyth-algorithmic-discrimination-at-work","sourceTitle":"Algorithmic discrimination at work"},{"raw":"10.1111/jols.12535","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/jols.12535","sourceId":"lit-natalie-sheard-algorithm-facilitated-discrimination-a","sourceTitle":"Algorithm-facilitated discrimination: a socio-legal study of the use by employers of artificial intelligence hiring systems"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658998","sourceId":"lit-lucas-wright-roxana-mika-muenster-briana-vecchione-tia","sourceTitle":"Null Compliance: NYC Local Law 144 and the Challenges of Algorithm Accountability"},{"raw":"10.1093/indlaw/dwaf018","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/indlaw/dwaf018","sourceId":"lit-sandra-fredman-darcy-du-toit-alessio-bertolini-jonas-v","sourceTitle":"Fair Work for Platform Workers: Lessons from the EU Directive and Beyond"},{"raw":"§6","kind":"provision","key":"§6"},{"raw":"§4","kind":"provision","key":"§4"}]}]},{"slug":"healthcare","kind":"topic","title":"AI in Healthcare","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/healthcare","total":22,"distinctSources":13,"provisionAnchors":8,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/S2589-7500(20)30292-2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/s2589-7500(20)30292-2","sourceId":"lit-muehlematter-daniore-vokinger-approval-of-artificial-i","sourceTitle":"Approval of artificial intelligence and machine learning-based medical devices in the USA and Europe (2015–20): a comparative analysis"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-020-0262-2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-020-0262-2","sourceId":"lit-gerke-babic-evgeniou-cohen-the-need-for-a-system-view","sourceTitle":"The need for a system view to regulate artificial intelligence/machine learning-based software as medical device"},{"raw":"Article 6(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 6(1)"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2017/745","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2017/745"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2017/746","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2017/746"},{"raw":"Art. 6(1)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6(1)"},{"raw":"Article 6(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 6(2)"},{"raw":"§5(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§5(a)"},{"raw":"§360c)","kind":"provision","key":"§360c)"},{"raw":"(MHRA 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(mhra 2024)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","sourceId":"lit-gary-e-weissman-toni-mankowitz-genevieve-p-kanter-unre","sourceTitle":"Unregulated large language models produce medical device-like output"},{"raw":"10.1016/S2589-7500(24)00124-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/s2589-7500(24)00124-9","sourceId":"lit-oscar-freyer-isabella-catharina-wiest-jakob-nikolas-ka","sourceTitle":"A future role for health applications of large language models depends on regulators enforcing safety standards"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-023-00873-0","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-023-00873-0","sourceId":"lit-bertalan-mesk-eric-j-topol-the-imperative-for-regulato","sourceTitle":"The imperative for regulatory oversight of large language models (or generative AI) in healthcare"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41591-023-02540-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41591-023-02540-z","sourceId":"lit-alexey-youssef-michael-pencina-anshul-thakur-tingting","sourceTitle":"External validation of AI models in health should be replaced with recurring local validation"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41591-021-01312-x","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41591-021-01312-x","sourceId":"lit-wu-wu-daneshjou-ouyang-ho-zou-how-medical-ai-devices-a","sourceTitle":"How medical AI devices are evaluated: limitations and recommendations from an analysis of FDA approvals"},{"raw":"10.1126/science.aax2342","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.aax2342","sourceId":"lit-obermeyer-powers-vogeli-mullainathan-dissecting-racial","sourceTitle":"Dissecting racial bias in an algorithm used to manage the health of populations"},{"raw":"arXiv:2202.03629","kind":"arxiv","key":"2202.03629","sourceId":"concept-hallucination","sourceTitle":"Hallucination"},{"raw":"§22602(b))","kind":"provision","key":"§22602(b))"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01618-x","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01618-x","sourceId":"lit-vijaytha-muralidharan-madelena-y-ng-shada-alsalamah-sa","sourceTitle":"Global Initiative on AI for Health (GI-AI4H): strategic priorities advancing governance across the United Nations"},{"raw":"10.2196/30545","kind":"doi","key":"10.2196/30545","sourceId":"lit-stephen-gilbert-matthew-fenech-martin-hirsch-shubhanan","sourceTitle":"Algorithm Change Protocols in the Regulation of Adaptive Machine Learning-Based Medical Devices"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01717-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01717-9","sourceId":"lit-boris-babic-i-glenn-cohen-ariel-dora-stern-yiwen-li-me","sourceTitle":"A general framework for governing marketed AI/ML medical devices"},{"raw":"10.21037/jmai-2025-196","kind":"doi","key":"10.21037/jmai-2025-196","sourceId":"lit-aditya-loganathan-michael-friedman-tayab-waseem-et-al","sourceTitle":"Current state of Food and Drug Administration-approved artificial intelligence/machine learning medical devices: pathways, transparency, and evidence gaps"}]}]},{"slug":"criminal-justice","kind":"topic","title":"AI in Criminal Justice","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/criminal-justice","total":29,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":17,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10610-022-09512-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10610-022-09512-y","sourceId":"lit-raposo-the-use-of-facial-recognition-technology-by-law","sourceTitle":"The Use of Facial Recognition Technology by Law Enforcement in Europe: a Non-Orwellian Draft Proposal"},{"raw":"10.1145/3514094.3534200","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3514094.3534200","sourceId":"lit-miri-zilka-holli-sargeant-adrian-weller-transparency-g","sourceTitle":"Transparency, Governance and Regulation of Algorithmic Tools Deployed in the Criminal Justice System: a UK Case Study"},{"raw":"Article 5(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 5(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 113(a)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113(a))."},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(d)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(d))."},{"raw":"Art. 27(1))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 27(1))"},{"raw":"Art. 113).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113)."},{"raw":"§7.1(b)","kind":"provision","key":"§7.1(b)"},{"raw":"§7.1(b)).","kind":"provision","key":"§7.1(b))."},{"raw":"Art. 14)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14)"},{"raw":"Art. 15)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 15)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/24751979.2024.2371781","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/24751979.2024.2371781","sourceId":"lit-youngsub-lee-ben-bradford-krisztian-posch-the-effectiv","sourceTitle":"The Effectiveness of Big Data-Driven Predictive Policing: Systematic Review"},{"raw":"10.1177/0032258X261439572","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0032258x261439572","sourceId":"lit-shai-farber-machines-of-justice-a-systematic-review-of","sourceTitle":"Machines of justice: A systematic review of AI applications in policing and criminal justice"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(d))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(d))"},{"raw":"§7.1(b)).","kind":"provision","key":"§7.1(b))."},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 2025","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 2025"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1089/big.2016.0047","kind":"doi","key":"10.1089/big.2016.0047","sourceId":"lit-chouldechova-fair-prediction-with-disparate-impact-a-s","sourceTitle":"Fair Prediction with Disparate Impact: A Study of Bias in Recidivism Prediction Instruments"},{"raw":"arXiv:1609.05807","kind":"arxiv","key":"1609.05807","sourceId":"lit-kleinberg-mullainathan-raghavan-inherent-trade-offs-in","sourceTitle":"Inherent Trade-Offs in the Fair Determination of Risk Scores"},{"raw":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Reg. (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 113(a))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113(a))"},{"raw":"Article 27","kind":"provision","key":"Article 27"},{"raw":"Art. 113).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113)."},{"raw":"§7.1(b)","kind":"provision","key":"§7.1(b)"},{"raw":"CETS No. 225","kind":"provision","key":"CETS No. 225"},{"raw":"Article 14","kind":"provision","key":"Article 14"}]}]},{"slug":"education","kind":"topic","title":"AI in Education","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/education","total":23,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":9,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1186/s41239-023-00408-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1186/s41239-023-00408-3","sourceId":"lit-chan-a-comprehensive-ai-policy-education-framework-for","sourceTitle":"A comprehensive AI policy education framework for university teaching and learning"},{"raw":"10.1111/bjet.13556","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/bjet.13556","sourceId":"lit-hyunkyung-chee-solmoe-ahn-and-jihyun-lee-a-competency","sourceTitle":"A Competency Framework for AI Literacy: Variations by Different Learner Groups and an Implied Learning Pathway"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Article 5(1)(f)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 5(1)(f)"},{"raw":"§8(d)","kind":"provision","key":"§8(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 10)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10)"},{"raw":"Art. 4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s40979-023-00146-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s40979-023-00146-z","sourceId":"lit-weber-wulff-anohina-naumeca-bjelobaba-et-al-testing-of","sourceTitle":"Testing of detection tools for AI-generated text"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.patter.2023.100779","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.patter.2023.100779","sourceId":"lit-liang-yuksekgonul-mao-wu-zou-gpt-detectors-are-biased","sourceTitle":"GPT detectors are biased against non-native English writers"},{"raw":"10.1186/s41239-024-00468-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1186/s41239-024-00468-z","sourceId":"lit-qi-xia-xiaojing-weng-fan-ouyang-tzung-jin-lin-and-thom","sourceTitle":"A scoping review on how generative artificial intelligence transforms assessment in higher education"},{"raw":"10.1111/bjet.13585","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/bjet.13585","sourceId":"lit-alexander-k-kofinas-crystal-han-huei-tsay-and-david-pi","sourceTitle":"The impact of generative AI on academic integrity of authentic assessments within a higher education context"},{"raw":"10.1007/s40979-023-00133-4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s40979-023-00133-4","sourceId":"lit-tom-folt-nek-sonja-bjelobaba-irene-glendinning-zeenath","sourceTitle":"ENAI Recommendations on the ethical use of Artificial Intelligence in Education"},{"raw":"10.54675/EWZM9535","kind":"doi","key":"10.54675/ewzm9535","sourceId":"lit-unesco-miao-holmes-guidance-for-generative-ai-in-educa","sourceTitle":"Guidance for generative AI in education and research"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(f))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(f))"},{"raw":"Art. 10).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 10)."}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.54675/EWZM9535","kind":"doi","key":"10.54675/ewzm9535","sourceId":"lit-unesco-miao-holmes-guidance-for-generative-ai-in-educa","sourceTitle":"Guidance for generative AI in education and research"},{"raw":"10.1177/23328584251331956","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/23328584251331956","sourceId":"lit-richard-arum-maria-calderon-leon-xunfei-li-and-jomar-l","sourceTitle":"ChatGPT Early Adoption in Higher Education: Variation in Student Usage, Instructional Support, and Educational Equity"},{"raw":"Article 5","kind":"provision","key":"Article 5"},{"raw":"Art. 5(1)(f))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5(1)(f))"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 113","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113"},{"raw":"§8(d)","kind":"provision","key":"§8(d)"},{"raw":"(Oct. 2023)","kind":"author_year","key":"(oct. 2023)"}]}]},{"slug":"compute-reporting","kind":"topic","title":"Compute-Threshold Reporting","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/compute-reporting","total":24,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":11,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches: how the binding regimes actually work","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"Art. 51(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(1)(a)"},{"raw":"Art. 52(1))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 52(1))"},{"raw":"Art. 52(2)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 52(2))."},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 73","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 73"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines: the contested design choices","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.08501","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.08501","sourceId":"lit-lennart-heim-tim-fist-janet-egan-sihao-huang-stephen-z","sourceTitle":"Governing Through the Cloud: The Intermediary Role of Compute Providers in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.13625","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.13625","sourceId":"lit-janet-egan-lennart-heim-oversight-for-frontier-ai-thro","sourceTitle":"Oversight for Frontier AI through a Know-Your-Customer Scheme for Compute Providers"},{"raw":"Art. 51(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(1)(a)"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 73","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 73"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2))."}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory: what has changed and what is pending","citations":[{"raw":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","kind":"doi","key":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","sourceId":"lit-lehdonvirta-w-hawkins-compute-north-vs-compute-south-t","sourceTitle":"Compute North vs. Compute South: The Uneven Possibilities of Compute-based AI Governance Around the Globe"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11341","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11341","sourceId":"lit-shavit-what-does-it-take-to-catch-a-chinchilla-verifyi","sourceTitle":"What does it take to catch a Chinchilla? Verifying Rules on Large-Scale Neural Network Training via Compute Monitoring"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 73","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 73"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8237","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8237"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8741","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8741"},{"raw":"Art. 52","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 52"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"}]}]},{"slug":"transparency","kind":"topic","title":"Transparency Obligations","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/transparency","total":29,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":13,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.5840/techne202323172","kind":"doi","key":"10.5840/techne202323172","sourceId":"lit-corinne-cath-fieke-jansen-dutch-comfort-the-limits-of","sourceTitle":"Dutch Comfort: The Limits of AI Governance through Municipal Registers"},{"raw":"10.1145/3458723","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3458723","sourceId":"lit-gebru-morgenstern-vecchione-et-al-datasheets-for-datas","sourceTitle":"Datasheets for Datasets"},{"raw":"10.1145/3287560.3287596","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3287560.3287596","sourceId":"lit-mitchell-wu-zaldivar-et-al-model-cards-for-model-repor","sourceTitle":"Model Cards for Model Reporting"},{"raw":"Art. 49","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 49"},{"raw":"Art. 71","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 71"},{"raw":"Art. 49(4))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 49(4))"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"Art. 50(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 16","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 16"},{"raw":"Art. 17","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17"},{"raw":"Article 9","kind":"provision","key":"Article 9"},{"raw":"(White & Case 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(white & case 2025)"},{"raw":"(Loeb & Loeb 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(loeb & loeb 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s40319-023-01328-5","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s40319-023-01328-5","sourceId":"lit-ulla-maija-mylly-transparent-ai-navigating-between-rul","sourceTitle":"Transparent AI? Navigating Between Rules on Trade Secrets and Access to Information"},{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","sourceId":"lit-wachter-mittelstadt-floridi-why-a-right-to-explanation","sourceTitle":"Why a Right to Explanation of Automated Decision-Making Does Not Exist in the General Data Protection Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1177/1461444816676645","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/1461444816676645","sourceId":"lit-ananny-crawford-seeing-without-knowing-limitations-of","sourceTitle":"Seeing without knowing: Limitations of the transparency ideal and its application to algorithmic accountability"},{"raw":"Art. 49)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 49)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(d))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(d))"},{"raw":"Art. 78","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 78"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 9088","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 9088"},{"raw":"(Selbst & Barocas 2018)","kind":"author_year","key":"(selbst & barocas 2018)"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-2025-2026","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing (2025–2026)","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3632753","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3632753","sourceId":"lit-henrik-palmer-olsen-thomas-troels-hildebrandt-corneliu","sourceTitle":"The Right to Transparency in Public Governance: Freedom of Information and the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Public Agencies"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","sourceId":"lit-petros-terzis-michael-veale-no-lle-gaumann-law-and-the","sourceTitle":"Law and the Emerging Political Economy of Algorithmic Audits"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"(Latham & Watkins 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(latham & watkins 2025)"},{"raw":"(TechPolicy.Press 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(techpolicy.press 2026)"},{"raw":"(Loeb & Loeb 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(loeb & loeb 2025)"},{"raw":"(White & Case 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(white & case 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"redress","kind":"topic","title":"Individual Redress","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/redress","total":27,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":15,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/rego.12391","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/rego.12391","sourceId":"lit-emre-bayaml-o-lu-the-right-to-contest-automated-decisi","sourceTitle":"The right to contest automated decisions under the General Data Protection Regulation: Beyond the so-called 'right to explanation'"},{"raw":"10.1145/3544548.3581161","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3544548.3581161","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-tim-draws-agathe-balayn-dave-murray-rus","sourceTitle":"Disentangling Fairness Perceptions in Algorithmic Decision-Making: the Effects of Explanations, Human Oversight, and Contestability"},{"raw":"Art. 85)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 85)"},{"raw":"Art. 15)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 15)"},{"raw":"Art. 86","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 86"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"},{"raw":"§5(c)(v)(D))","kind":"provision","key":"§5(c)(v)(D))"},{"raw":"Art. 77)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 77)"},{"raw":"Art. 79)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 79)"},{"raw":"Art. 82)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 82)"},{"raw":"Art. 22","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22"},{"raw":"Art. 12).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 12)."},{"raw":"Article 11","kind":"provision","key":"Article 11"},{"raw":"Article 11).","kind":"provision","key":"Article 11)."}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipx005","sourceId":"lit-wachter-mittelstadt-floridi-why-a-right-to-explanation","sourceTitle":"Why a Right to Explanation of Automated Decision-Making Does Not Exist in the General Data Protection Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1145/3613904.3641898","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3613904.3641898","sourceId":"lit-naveena-karusala-sohini-upadhyay-rajesh-veeraraghavan","sourceTitle":"Understanding Contestability on the Margins: Implications for the Design of Algorithmic Decision-making in Public Services"},{"raw":"10.1111/rego.12391","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/rego.12391","sourceId":"lit-emre-bayaml-o-lu-the-right-to-contest-automated-decisi","sourceTitle":"The right to contest automated decisions under the General Data Protection Regulation: Beyond the so-called 'right to explanation'"},{"raw":"10.1145/3449180","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3449180","sourceId":"lit-henrietta-lyons-eduardo-velloso-tim-miller-conceptuali","sourceTitle":"Conceptualising Contestability: Perspectives on Contesting Algorithmic Decisions"},{"raw":"10.1007/s11023-022-09611-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11023-022-09611-z","sourceId":"lit-kars-alfrink-ianus-keller-gerd-kortuem-neelke-doorn-co","sourceTitle":"Contestable AI by Design: Towards a Framework"},{"raw":"Art. 85)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 85)"},{"raw":"Art. 80","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 80"},{"raw":"Art. 22","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 22"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/ojls/gqab032","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ojls/gqab032","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-williams-rethinking-administrative-law-for-alg","sourceTitle":"Rethinking Administrative Law for Algorithmic Decision Making"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"Art. 86","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 86"},{"raw":"Art. 113.","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113."},{"raw":"Art. 113).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 113)."}]}]},{"slug":"training-data","kind":"topic","title":"Training-Data Rights","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/training-data","total":19,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":9,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","sourceId":"lit-longpre-mahari-et-al-data-provenance-initiative-a-larg","sourceTitle":"A large-scale audit of dataset licensing and attribution in AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikac054","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikac054","sourceId":"lit-margoni-kretschmer-a-deeper-look-into-the-eu-text-and","sourceTitle":"A Deeper Look into the EU Text and Data Mining Exceptions: Harmonisation, Data Ownership, and the Future of Technology"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(c)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(c)"},{"raw":"Art. 4(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(3)"},{"raw":"Art. 6","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 6"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","sourceId":"lit-kaigeng-li-hong-wu-yupeng-dong-copyright-protection-du","sourceTitle":"Copyright protection during the training stage of generative AI: Industry-oriented U.S. law, rights-oriented EU law, and fair remuneration rights for generative AI training under the UN's international governance regime for AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","sourceId":"lit-martin-kretschmer-bartolomeo-meletti-lionel-bently-gab","sourceTitle":"Copyright and AI in the UK: Opting-In or Opting-Out?"},{"raw":"Art. 4(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4(3)"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","sourceId":"lit-kaigeng-li-hong-wu-yupeng-dong-copyright-protection-du","sourceTitle":"Copyright protection during the training stage of generative AI: Industry-oriented U.S. law, rights-oriented EU law, and fair remuneration rights for generative AI training under the UN's international governance regime for AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","sourceId":"lit-taner-kuru-lawfulness-of-the-mass-processing-of-public","sourceTitle":"Lawfulness of the mass processing of publicly accessible online data to train large language models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14933","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14933","sourceId":"lit-shayne-longpre-robert-mahari-ariel-lee-et-al-consent-i","sourceTitle":"Consent in Crisis: The Rapid Decline of the AI Data Commons"},{"raw":"Art. 101).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 101)."},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"}]}]},{"slug":"sovereign-ai","kind":"topic","title":"Sovereign AI Doctrine","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/sovereign-ai","total":12,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1787/876367e3-en","kind":"doi","key":"10.1787/876367e3-en","sourceId":"lit-oecd-a-blueprint-for-building-national-compute-capacit","sourceTitle":"A blueprint for building national compute capacity for artificial intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"Article 17","kind":"provision","key":"Article 17"},{"raw":"Article 7","kind":"provision","key":"Article 7"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"§4.2).","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2)."},{"raw":"§11546.8)","kind":"provision","key":"§11546.8)"}]},{"sectionId":"definitional-contestation","heading":"Definitional contestation","citations":[{"raw":"10.1177/01622439211030007","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/01622439211030007","sourceId":"lit-jascha-bareis-christian-katzenbach-talking-ai-into-bei","sourceTitle":"Talking AI into Being: The Narratives and Imaginaries of National AI Strategies and Their Performative Politics"},{"raw":"10.1007/s00146-021-01258-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s00146-021-01258-1","sourceId":"lit-guy-paltieli-the-political-imaginary-of-national-ai-st","sourceTitle":"The political imaginary of National AI Strategies"},{"raw":"arXiv:2511.15734","kind":"arxiv","key":"2511.15734"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1177/0308518X251369704","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0308518x251369704","sourceId":"lit-justin-kollar-andrew-stokols-geopolitical-ecologies-of","sourceTitle":"Geopolitical ecologies of cloud capitalism: Territorial restructuring and the making of national computing power in the U.S. and China"}]}]},{"slug":"catastrophic-risk","kind":"topic","title":"Catastrophic & Existential Risk","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/catastrophic-risk","total":20,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2305.15324","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.15324","sourceId":"lit-shevlane-farquhar-garfinkel-et-al-model-evaluation-for","sourceTitle":"Model evaluation for extreme risks"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"},{"raw":"§ 22757.11","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.11"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adn0117","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adn0117","sourceId":"lit-bengio-hinton-yao-song-et-al-managing-extreme-ai-risks","sourceTitle":"Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.07300","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.07300","sourceId":"lit-jonas-schuett-markus-anderljung-alexis-carlier-leonie","sourceTitle":"From Principles to Rules: A Regulatory Approach for Frontier AI"},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18956","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18956","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-scholefield-samuel-martin-otto-barten-internat","sourceTitle":"International Agreements on AI Safety: Review and Recommendations for a Conditional AI Safety Treaty"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"Art. 55)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55)"},{"raw":"(Morrison & Foerster 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(morrison & foerster 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"mechanisms-and-evidence","heading":"What the risk claims rest on — mechanisms and evidence","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"arXiv:2210.01790","kind":"arxiv","key":"2210.01790"},{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.04984","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.04984"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.14093","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.14093"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.07358","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.07358","sourceId":"concept-sandbagging","sourceTitle":"Sandbagging"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.07510","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.07510","sourceId":"lit-sumeet-ramesh-motwani-mikhail-baranchuk-martin-strohme","sourceTitle":"Secret Collusion among AI Agents: Multi-Agent Deception via Steganography"}]}]},{"slug":"tech-sovereignty","kind":"topic","title":"Technological Sovereignty","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/tech-sovereignty","total":16,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/13501763.2023.2248204","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/13501763.2023.2248204","sourceId":"lit-timo-seidl-luuk-schmitz-moving-on-to-not-fall-behind-t","sourceTitle":"Moving on to not fall behind? Technological sovereignty and the 'geo-dirigiste' turn in EU industrial policy"},{"raw":"Art. 4","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 4"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 1(1))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 1(1))"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.respol.2023.104765","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.respol.2023.104765","sourceId":"lit-jakob-edler-knut-blind-henning-kroll-torben-schubert-t","sourceTitle":"Technology sovereignty as an emerging frame for innovation policy. Defining rationales, ends and means"},{"raw":"10.1080/1369118X.2025.2516545","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/1369118x.2025.2516545","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-ambitions-captured-by-american-c","sourceTitle":"European ambitions captured by American clouds: digital sovereignty through Gaia-X?"},{"raw":"10.1080/14650045.2022.2151902","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/14650045.2022.2151902","sourceId":"lit-andreas-baur-european-dreams-of-the-cloud-imagining-in","sourceTitle":"European Dreams of the Cloud: Imagining Innovation and Political Control"},{"raw":"10.1111/jcms.13594","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/jcms.13594","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-adler-nissen-kristin-anabel-eggeling-the-discu","sourceTitle":"The Discursive Struggle for Digital Sovereignty: Security, Economy, Rights and the Cloud Project Gaia-X"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.437","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.437","sourceId":"lit-julia-pohle-riccardo-nanni-mauro-santaniello-unthinkin","sourceTitle":"Unthinking Digital Sovereignty: A Critical Reflection on Origins, Objectives, and Practices"},{"raw":"10.1080/09662839.2022.2101885","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/09662839.2022.2101885","sourceId":"lit-andrea-calderaro-stella-blumfelde-artificial-intellige","sourceTitle":"Artificial intelligence and EU security: the false promise of digital sovereignty"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/13501763.2024.2318475","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/13501763.2024.2318475","sourceId":"lit-daniel-m-m-gge-eu-ai-sovereignty-for-whom-to-what-end","sourceTitle":"EU AI sovereignty: for whom, to what end, and to whose benefit?"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.03314","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.03314","sourceId":"concept-inference-time-compute","sourceTitle":"Inference-Time Compute"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2021/1173","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2021/1173"},{"raw":"(BIS, 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(bis, 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"sovereignty-ledger","heading":"The ledger: price tags and boomerang effects","citations":[{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2021/1173","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2021/1173"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2026/150","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2026/150"}]}]},{"slug":"development-rights-framing","kind":"topic","title":"Development-Rights Framings","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/development-rights-framing","total":16,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"definitional-contestation","heading":"Definitional contestation","citations":[{"raw":"10.1177/1527476418796632","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/1527476418796632","sourceId":"lit-nick-couldry-ulises-a-mejias-data-colonialism-rethinki","sourceTitle":"Data Colonialism: Rethinking Big Data's Relation to the Contemporary Subject"},{"raw":"10.1007/s13347-023-00687-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s13347-023-00687-8","sourceId":"lit-james-muldoon-boxi-a-wu-artificial-intelligence-in-the","sourceTitle":"Artificial Intelligence in the Colonial Matrix of Power"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.17481","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.17481","sourceId":"lit-srivastava-bullock-ai-global-governance-digital-sovereignty","sourceTitle":"AI, Global Governance, and Digital Sovereignty"},{"raw":"A/RES/78/265","kind":"provision","key":"A/RES/78/265"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"}]},{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.70164","sourceId":"lit-huw-roberts-mariarosaria-taddeo-luciano-floridi-a-fram","sourceTitle":"A Framework for Evaluating Global AI Governance Initiatives"},{"raw":"10.1017/dap.2024.26","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/dap.2024.26","sourceId":"lit-jake-okechukwu-effoduh-ugochukwu-ejike-akpudo-jude-dze","sourceTitle":"Toward a trustworthy and inclusive data governance policy for the use of artificial intelligence in Africa"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"A/RES/78/265","kind":"provision","key":"A/RES/78/265"},{"raw":"§ 16","kind":"provision","key":"§ 16"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1111/1758-5899.12965","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1758-5899.12965","sourceId":"lit-sakiko-fukuda-parr-elizabeth-gibbons-emerging-consensu","sourceTitle":"Emerging Consensus on 'Ethical AI': Human Rights Critique of Stakeholder Guidelines"},{"raw":"10.1145/3531146.3533200","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3531146.3533200","sourceId":"lit-marie-therese-png-at-the-tensions-of-south-and-north-c","sourceTitle":"At the Tensions of South and North: Critical Roles of Global South Stakeholders in AI Governance"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10290-021-00417-2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10290-021-00417-2"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.427","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.427","sourceId":"lit-min-jiang-models-of-state-digital-sovereignty-from-the","sourceTitle":"Models of State Digital Sovereignty From the Global South: Diverging Experiences From China, India and South Africa"},{"raw":"A/RES/78/265","kind":"provision","key":"A/RES/78/265"},{"raw":"Art. 2(1)(c))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2(1)(c))"}]}]},{"slug":"international-coordination","kind":"topic","title":"International Coordination","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/international-coordination","total":12,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s43681-021-00083-y:","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s43681-021-00083-y","sourceId":"lit-schmitt-mapping-global-ai-governance-a-nascent-regime","sourceTitle":"Mapping global AI governance: a nascent regime in a fragmented landscape"},{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"},{"raw":"(OECD 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(oecd 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiae073","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiae073","sourceId":"lit-roberts-hine-taddeo-floridi-global-ai-governance-barri","sourceTitle":"Global AI governance: barriers and pathways forward"},{"raw":"10.1093/isr/viad040","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/isr/viad040","sourceId":"lit-tallberg-erman-furendal-geith-klamberg-lundgren-the-gl","sourceTitle":"The Global Governance of Artificial Intelligence: Next Steps for Empirical and Normative Research"},{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.04699","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.04699","sourceId":"lit-ho-barnhart-trager-bengio-et-al-international-institut","sourceTitle":"International Institutions for Advanced AI"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"},{"raw":"arXiv:2409.02779","kind":"arxiv","key":"2409.02779","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-peter-barnett-michael-gerovitch-roman-ha","sourceTitle":"Governing dual-use technologies: Case studies of international security agreements and lessons for AI governance"},{"raw":"(OECD 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(oecd 2024)"},{"raw":"(NIST 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(nist 2024)"}]}]},{"slug":"agentic-systems-governance","kind":"topic","title":"Agentic AI Governance","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/agentic-systems-governance","total":12,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches: the mechanisms behind the coverage","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10010","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2025.10010","sourceId":"lit-ana-maria-corr-a-sara-garsia-abdullah-elbi-better-toge","sourceTitle":"Better together? Human oversight as means to achieve fairness in the European AI Act governance"},{"raw":"Art. 14(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14(3)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(1)(b)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines: where the governance debate genuinely diverges","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2504.03255","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.03255"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.07913","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.07913","sourceId":"lit-noam-kolt-governing-ai-agents","sourceTitle":"Governing AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.14143","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.14143","sourceId":"lit-lewis-hammond-alan-chan-jesse-clifton-et-al-cooperativ","sourceTitle":"Multi-Agent Risks from Advanced AI"},{"raw":"Art. 14).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14)."}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory: recent and pending developments","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658948","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658948","sourceId":"lit-alan-chan-carson-ezell-max-kaufmann-kevin-wei-lewis-ha","sourceTitle":"Visibility into AI Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.09674","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.09674","sourceId":"lit-tobin-south-samuele-marro-thomas-hardjono-robert-mahar","sourceTitle":"Authenticated Delegation and Authorized AI Agents"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]}]},{"slug":"open-weight-release","kind":"topic","title":"Open-Weight Frontier Release","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/open-weight-release","total":18,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":10,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adp1848","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adp1848","sourceId":"lit-rishi-bommasani-sayash-kapoor-kevin-klyman-shayne-long","sourceTitle":"Considerations for governing open foundation models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.07918","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.07918","sourceId":"lit-sayash-kapoor-rishi-bommasani-kevin-klyman-shayne-long","sourceTitle":"On the Societal Impact of Open Foundation Models"},{"raw":"Article 53(1)(a)-(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 53(1)(a)-(b)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 53(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"},{"raw":"Art. 17)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 17)"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(c))","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(c))"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3.2","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3.2"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(c)).","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(c))."}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3593013.3593981","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3593013.3593981","sourceId":"lit-irene-solaiman-the-gradient-of-generative-ai-release-m","sourceTitle":"The Gradient of Generative AI Release: Methods and Considerations"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659005","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659005","sourceId":"lit-andreas-liesenfeld-mark-dingemanse-rethinking-open-sou","sourceTitle":"Rethinking open source generative AI: open-washing and the EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.2139/ssrn.4543807","kind":"doi","key":"10.2139/ssrn.4543807","sourceId":"lit-david-gray-widder-sarah-west-meredith-whittaker-open-f","sourceTitle":"Open (For Business): Big Tech, Concentrated Power, and the Political Economy of Open AI"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2412.07097","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.07097","sourceId":"lit-xiangyu-qi-boyi-wei-nicholas-carlini-et-al-on-evaluati","sourceTitle":"On Evaluating the Durability of Safeguards for Open-Weight LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.09227","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.09227","sourceId":"lit-elizabeth-seger-noemi-dreksler-richard-moulange-et-al","sourceTitle":"Open-Sourcing Highly Capable Foundation Models: An evaluation of risks, benefits, and alternative methods for pursuing open-source objectives"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3(c)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3(c)"},{"raw":"§ 22757.3.2)","kind":"provision","key":"§ 22757.3.2)"},{"raw":"(IISS, 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(iiss, 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"synthetic-content-provenance","kind":"topic","title":"Synthetic Content Provenance","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/synthetic-content-provenance","total":15,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.4","sourceId":"lit-mimi-zou-and-lu-zhang-navigating-china-s-regulatory-ap","sourceTitle":"Navigating China's regulatory approach to generative artificial intelligence and large language models"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10676-023-09728-4","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10676-023-09728-4","sourceId":"lit-alistair-knott-dino-pedreschi-raja-chatila-et-al-incl","sourceTitle":"Generative AI models should include detection mechanisms as a condition for public release"},{"raw":"Article 50(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50(2)"},{"raw":"Article 50(4)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50(4)"},{"raw":"Art. 50(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(2)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2411.18479","kind":"arxiv","key":"2411.18479"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11156","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11156","sourceId":"lit-vinu-sankar-sadasivan-aounon-kumar-sriram-balasubraman","sourceTitle":"Can AI-Generated Text be Reliably Detected?"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.04378","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.04378","sourceId":"lit-hanlin-zhang-benjamin-l-edelman-danilo-francati-daniel","sourceTitle":"Watermarks in the Sand: Impossibility of Strong Watermarking for Generative Models"},{"raw":"Art. 50(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(2)"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory — what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.70041","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.70041","sourceId":"lit-bram-rijsbosch-gijs-van-dijck-and-konrad-kollnig-missi","sourceTitle":"Missing the Mark: Adoption of Watermarking for Generative AI Systems in Practice and Implications Under the New EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1145/3610061","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3610061","sourceId":"lit-k-j-kevin-feng-nick-ritchie-pia-blumenthal-andy-parson","sourceTitle":"Examining the Impact of Provenance-Enabled Media on Trust and Accuracy Perceptions"},{"raw":"Article 50","kind":"provision","key":"Article 50"},{"raw":"Art. 50).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50)."},{"raw":"(Loeb & Loeb 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(loeb & loeb 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"compute-export-controls","kind":"topic","title":"Compute + Model-Weight Export Controls","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/compute-export-controls","total":12,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.16980/jitc.19.1.202302.129","kind":"doi","key":"10.16980/jitc.19.1.202302.129","sourceId":"lit-do-joon-park-shuzhi-liu-a-study-on-the-economic-effect","sourceTitle":"A Study on the Economic Effects of U.S. Export Controls on Semiconductors to China"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2021/821","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2021/821"},{"raw":"Art. 9)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9)"},{"raw":"(CSIS 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(csis 2024)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1162/isec_a_00351","kind":"doi","key":"10.1162/isec_a_00351","sourceId":"lit-henry-farrell-abraham-l-newman-weaponized-interdepende","sourceTitle":"Weaponized Interdependence: How Global Economic Networks Shape State Coercion"},{"raw":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","sourceId":"lit-megha-shrivastava-and-amrita-jash-china-s-semiconducto","sourceTitle":"China's semiconductor conundrum: understanding US export controls and their efficacy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2404.18308","kind":"arxiv","key":"2404.18308","sourceId":"lit-james-petrie-near-term-enforcement-of-ai-chip-export-c","sourceTitle":"Near-Term Enforcement of AI Chip Export Controls Using a Firmware-Based Design for Offline Licensing"},{"raw":"(Anthropic 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(anthropic 2024)"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory — what is changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.16980/jitc.19.1.202302.129","kind":"doi","key":"10.16980/jitc.19.1.202302.129","sourceId":"lit-do-joon-park-shuzhi-liu-a-study-on-the-economic-effect","sourceTitle":"A Study on the Economic Effects of U.S. Export Controls on Semiconductors to China"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.techfore.2024.123749","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.techfore.2024.123749","sourceId":"lit-chan-yuan-wong-henry-wai-chung-yeung-shaopeng-huang-ja","sourceTitle":"Geopolitics and the changing landscape of global value chains and competition in the global semiconductor industry: Rivalry and catch-up in chip manufacturing in East Asia"},{"raw":"(BIS 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(bis 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"environmental-impact-of-training","kind":"topic","title":"Environmental Impact of AI Training","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/environmental-impact-of-training","total":15,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":7,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106326","sourceId":"lit-andr-ebert-joseph-alder-ralf-herbrich-philipp-hacker-a","sourceTitle":"AI, Climate, and Regulation: From Data Centers to the AI Act"},{"raw":"10.1145/3381831","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3381831","sourceId":"lit-roy-schwartz-jesse-dodge-noah-a-smith-oren-etzioni-gre","sourceTitle":"Green AI"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(a)"},{"raw":"Art. 40(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 40(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 40(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 40(2))"},{"raw":"Art. 95(2)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 95(2)(b)"},{"raw":"Art. 95(2)(b)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 95(2)(b))."}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658542","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658542","sourceId":"lit-alexandra-sasha-luccioni-yacine-jernite-emma-strubell","sourceTitle":"Power Hungry Processing: Watts Driving the Cost of AI Deployment?"},{"raw":"10.1109/mm.2022.3163226","kind":"doi","key":"10.1109/mm.2022.3163226","sourceId":"lit-udit-gupta-young-geun-kim-sylvia-lee-jordan-tse-hsien","sourceTitle":"Chasing Carbon: The Elusive Environmental Footprint of Computing"},{"raw":"10.1145/3724499","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3724499","sourceId":"lit-pengfei-li-jianyi-yang-mohammad-a-islam-shaolei-ren-ma","sourceTitle":"Making AI Less 'Thirsty': Uncovering and Addressing the Secret Water Footprint of AI Models"},{"raw":"Art. 40(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 40(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 95).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 95)."}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/advs.202100707","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/advs.202100707","sourceId":"lit-lo-c-lannelongue-jason-grealey-michael-inouye-green-al","sourceTitle":"Green Algorithms: Quantifying the Carbon Footprint of Computation"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.joule.2023.09.004","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.joule.2023.09.004","sourceId":"lit-alex-de-vries-the-growing-energy-footprint-of-artifici","sourceTitle":"The growing energy footprint of artificial intelligence"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"}]}]},{"slug":"national-security-carveouts","kind":"topic","title":"National Security Carveouts in AI Regulation","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/national-security-carveouts","total":20,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":9,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches: how the carveout is constructed","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/17579961.2025.2470589","sourceId":"lit-ezgi-yazici-toward-a-global-standard-for-ethical-ai-re","sourceTitle":"Toward a global standard for ethical AI regulation: addressing gaps in AI-driven biometric and high-resolution satellite imaging in the EU AI Act"},{"raw":"10.4337/9781035323036.00011","kind":"doi","key":"10.4337/9781035323036.00011","sourceId":"lit-irena-barkane-lolita-buka-prohibited-ai-surveillance-p","sourceTitle":"Prohibited AI surveillance practices in the Artificial Intelligence Act: promises and pitfalls in protecting fundamental rights"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 2(3))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2(3))"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"Art. 5","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5"},{"raw":"§4.8","kind":"provision","key":"§4.8"},{"raw":"(CoE 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(coe 2024)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines: the \"exclusively\" boundary and the competence contest","citations":[{"raw":"10.59704/292082becc7cc8e6","kind":"doi","key":"10.59704/292082becc7cc8e6","sourceId":"lit-plixavra-vogiatzoglou-the-ai-act-national-security-exc","sourceTitle":"The AI Act National Security Exception: room for manoeuvres?"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2026.106282","sourceId":"lit-chiara-gallese-predictive-policing-and-predictive-just","sourceTitle":"Predictive policing and predictive justice: Ethics, data protection, and the AI act"},{"raw":"10.1111/1468-2230.12652","kind":"doi","key":"10.1111/1468-2230.12652","sourceId":"lit-monika-zalnieriute-a-struggle-for-competence-national","sourceTitle":"A Struggle for Competence: National Security, Surveillance and the Scope of EU Law at the Court of Justice of European Union"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 2(3))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2(3))"},{"raw":"(Tzanou & Vogiatzoglou 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(tzanou & vogiatzoglou 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory","heading":"Trajectory: what is changing (2024–2026)","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/err.2024.97","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/err.2024.97","sourceId":"lit-francesca-palmiotto-the-ai-act-roller-coaster-the-evol","sourceTitle":"The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation"},{"raw":"10.1017/ajil.2022.35","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ajil.2022.35","sourceId":"lit-monika-zalnieriute-big-brother-watch-and-others-v-the","sourceTitle":"Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom"},{"raw":"Art. 5)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5)"},{"raw":"Art. 2(3)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 2(3)"},{"raw":"Fed. Reg. 8741","kind":"provision","key":"Fed. Reg. 8741"},{"raw":"§3(f)","kind":"provision","key":"§3(f)"}]}]},{"slug":"ai-worker-displacement","kind":"topic","title":"AI-Driven Worker Displacement","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/ai-worker-displacement","total":14,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"regulatory-approaches","heading":"Regulatory approaches","citations":[{"raw":"10.1257/jep.33.2.3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1257/jep.33.2.3","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-and-pascual-restrepo-automation-and-new","sourceTitle":"Automation and New Tasks: How Technology Displaces and Reinstates Labor"},{"raw":"10.1086/705716","kind":"doi","key":"10.1086/705716","sourceId":"lit-acemoglu-restrepo-robots-and-jobs-evidence-from-us-lab","sourceTitle":"Robots and Jobs: Evidence from US Labor Markets"},{"raw":"Article 26","kind":"provision","key":"Article 26"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"§6","kind":"provision","key":"§6"},{"raw":"§6(a)-(b)","kind":"provision","key":"§6(a)-(b)"}]},{"sectionId":"key-fault-lines","heading":"Key fault lines","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/epolic/eiae042","sourceId":"lit-daron-acemoglu-the-simple-macroeconomics-of-ai","sourceTitle":"The simple macroeconomics of AI"},{"raw":"10.1257/jep.29.3.3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1257/jep.29.3.3","sourceId":"lit-david-h-autor-why-are-there-still-so-many-jobs-the-his","sourceTitle":"Why Are There Still So Many Jobs? The History and Future of Workplace Automation"}]},{"sectionId":"trajectory-whats-changing","heading":"Trajectory / what's changing","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/qje/qjae044","sourceId":"lit-erik-brynjolfsson-danielle-li-and-lindsey-r-raymond-ge","sourceTitle":"Generative AI at Work"},{"raw":"10.1257/jep.29.3.3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1257/jep.29.3.3","sourceId":"lit-david-h-autor-why-are-there-still-so-many-jobs-the-his","sourceTitle":"Why Are There Still So Many Jobs? The History and Future of Workplace Automation"},{"raw":"§6","kind":"provision","key":"§6"},{"raw":"(SHRM 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(shrm 2025)"},{"raw":"(Hunton 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(hunton 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"frontier-tier","kind":"concept","title":"Frontier-Tier AI","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/frontier-tier","total":19,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: two ways a model is sorted into the frontier tier","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2))"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History: from neutral usage to a governance category (2018–2024)","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent-concepts","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts: frontier vs GPAI, foundation model, and systemic risk","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s44206-023-00068-w","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s44206-023-00068-w","sourceId":"lit-gutierrez-aguirre-uuk-boine-franklin-a-proposal-for-a","sourceTitle":"A Proposal for a Definition of General Purpose Artificial Intelligence Systems"},{"raw":"arXiv:2108.07258","kind":"arxiv","key":"2108.07258","sourceId":"lit-bommasani-et-al-on-the-opportunities-and-risks-of-foun","sourceTitle":"On the Opportunities and Risks of Foundation Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Art. 51","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"}]},{"sectionId":"contestation","heading":"Contestation: is the compute boundary the right line at all?","citations":[{"raw":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","kind":"doi","key":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","sourceId":"lit-lehdonvirta-w-hawkins-compute-north-vs-compute-south-t","sourceTitle":"Compute North vs. Compute South: The Uneven Possibilities of Compute-based AI Governance Around the Globe"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2))","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2))"}]}]},{"slug":"asl-3","kind":"concept","title":"AI Safety Level 3 (ASL-3)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/asl-3","total":11,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: the two-standard, if-then architecture","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History: from RSP v1.0 to v3.x","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","sourceId":"lit-hacker-engel-mauer-regulating-chatgpt-and-other-large","sourceTitle":"Regulating ChatGPT and other Large Generative AI Models"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent","heading":"Relation to adjacent capability-tier concepts","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"systemic-risk","kind":"concept","title":"Systemic Risk (AI)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/systemic-risk","total":16,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":6,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: what makes an AI risk \"systemic\"","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.07780","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.07780"},{"raw":"Article 3(65)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 3(65)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 3(65)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3(65))."},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History: a borrowed term, codified in stages","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Article 34","kind":"provision","key":"Article 34"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2022/2065","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2022/2065"},{"raw":"Article 3(65)","kind":"provision","key":"Article 3(65)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent-concepts","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2407.05694","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.05694"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]}]},{"slug":"designated-systemic","kind":"concept","title":"Designated Systemic-Risk Model","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/designated-systemic","total":17,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"definition-and-the-two-designation-pathways","heading":"Definition and the Two Designation Pathways","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 55.","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55."},{"raw":"Art. 51(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(1)(b)"}]},{"sectionId":"how-the-mechanism-operates","heading":"How the Designation Mechanism Operates","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance-and-engaged-provisions","heading":"Governance Relevance and Engaged Provisions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2403.08501","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.08501","sourceId":"lit-lennart-heim-tim-fist-janet-egan-sihao-huang-stephen-z","sourceTitle":"Governing Through the Cloud: The Intermediary Role of Compute Providers in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"},{"raw":"Art. 51(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(1)(b)"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","kind":"doi","key":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","sourceId":"lit-lehdonvirta-w-hawkins-compute-north-vs-compute-south-t","sourceTitle":"Compute North vs. Compute South: The Uneven Possibilities of Compute-based AI Governance Around the Globe"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"Art. 51(1)(b)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(1)(b)"}]}]},{"slug":"compute-threshold","kind":"concept","title":"Compute Threshold (AI Governance)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/compute-threshold","total":17,"distinctSources":14,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: how training compute is measured and why it is governable","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2203.15556","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.15556","sourceId":"lit-jordan-hoffmann-sebastian-borgeaud-arthur-mensch-et-al","sourceTitle":"Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.08501","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.08501","sourceId":"lit-lennart-heim-tim-fist-janet-egan-sihao-huang-stephen-z","sourceTitle":"Governing Through the Cloud: The Intermediary Role of Compute Providers in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51(2)).","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51(2))."}]},{"sectionId":"critiques","heading":"Open critiques and debates","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2407.05694","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.05694"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.05812","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.05812"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.09618","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.09618"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14981","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14981","sourceId":"lit-anka-reuel-ben-bucknall-stephen-casper-tim-fist-lennar","sourceTitle":"Open Problems in Technical AI Governance"}]},{"sectionId":"geopolitics","heading":"Distributional and geopolitical stakes of compute-based governance","citations":[{"raw":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","kind":"doi","key":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","sourceId":"lit-lehdonvirta-w-hawkins-compute-north-vs-compute-south-t","sourceTitle":"Compute North vs. Compute South: The Uneven Possibilities of Compute-based AI Governance Around the Globe"},{"raw":"10.1177/0308518X251369704","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0308518x251369704","sourceId":"lit-justin-kollar-andrew-stokols-geopolitical-ecologies-of","sourceTitle":"Geopolitical ecologies of cloud capitalism: Territorial restructuring and the making of national computing power in the U.S. and China"},{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"}]}]},{"slug":"red-team-evaluation","kind":"concept","title":"Red-Team Evaluation","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/red-team-evaluation","total":11,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"precise-definition-and-distinctions","heading":"Precise Definition and Boundary Distinctions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"}]},{"sectionId":"how-it-works-mechanisms","heading":"Mechanisms and Capability Scope","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","sourceId":"lit-groh-sankaranarayanan-singh-kim-lippman-picard-human-d","sourceTitle":"Human detection of political speech deepfakes across transcripts, audio, and video"},{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance and Instrument Engagement","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)(i)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)(i)"},{"raw":"§1","kind":"provision","key":"§1"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"}]}]},{"slug":"model-card","kind":"concept","title":"Model Card","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/model-card","total":16,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"anatomy-and-distinctions","heading":"Anatomy and Conceptual Distinctions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","sourceId":"lit-petros-terzis-michael-veale-no-lle-gaumann-law-and-the","sourceTitle":"Law and the Emerging Political Economy of Algorithmic Audits"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-uptake-and-codification","heading":"From Voluntary Norm to Binding Codification","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"}]},{"sectionId":"definitional-instability-and-scope","heading":"Definitional Instability of the Regulated Object","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","sourceId":"lit-hacker-engel-mauer-regulating-chatgpt-and-other-large","sourceTitle":"Regulating ChatGPT and other Large Generative AI Models"},{"raw":"10.1007/s44206-023-00068-w","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s44206-023-00068-w","sourceId":"lit-gutierrez-aguirre-uuk-boine-franklin-a-proposal-for-a","sourceTitle":"A Proposal for a Definition of General Purpose Artificial Intelligence Systems"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"}]},{"sectionId":"limits-evidence-and-open-questions","heading":"Limits, Evidence, and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3632753","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3632753","sourceId":"lit-henrik-palmer-olsen-thomas-troels-hildebrandt-corneliu","sourceTitle":"The Right to Transparency in Public Governance: Freedom of Information and the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Public Agencies"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"}]}]},{"slug":"alignment","kind":"concept","title":"AI Alignment","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/alignment","total":12,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: how alignment is attempted in practice","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2203.02155","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.02155"},{"raw":"arXiv:1706.03741","kind":"arxiv","key":"1706.03741"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.15217","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.15217"},{"raw":"arXiv:2212.08073","kind":"arxiv","key":"2212.08073"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History of the idea and term","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.131.3410.1355","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.131.3410.1355"},{"raw":"arXiv:1706.03741","kind":"arxiv","key":"1706.03741"},{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2203.02155","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.02155"},{"raw":"arXiv:2212.08073","kind":"arxiv","key":"2212.08073"},{"raw":"(Russell 2017)","kind":"author_year","key":"(russell 2017)"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent-concepts","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1606.06565","kind":"arxiv","key":"1606.06565"},{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"}]}]},{"slug":"deceptive-alignment","kind":"concept","title":"Deceptive Alignment","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/deceptive-alignment","total":12,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: the three conditions and the routes to looking aligned","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.08379","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.08379"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent-concepts","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2209.00626","kind":"arxiv","key":"2209.00626"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.08379","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.08379"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2209.00626","kind":"arxiv","key":"2209.00626"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.08379","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.08379"},{"raw":"arXiv:2401.05566","kind":"arxiv","key":"2401.05566"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.14093","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.14093"},{"raw":"arXiv:2506.18032","kind":"arxiv","key":"2506.18032"},{"raw":"(Hubinger 2019)","kind":"author_year","key":"(hubinger 2019)"}]}]},{"slug":"mesa-optimization","kind":"concept","title":"Mesa-Optimization","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/mesa-optimization","total":9,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: base optimizer, mesa-objective, and when learned search arises","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2210.01790","kind":"arxiv","key":"2210.01790"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent-concepts","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts: goal misgeneralization, specification gaming, deceptive alignment","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2210.01790","kind":"arxiv","key":"2210.01790"},{"raw":"arXiv:2105.14111","kind":"arxiv","key":"2105.14111"},{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History: from \"optimization daemons\" to a contested empirical question","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1906.01820","kind":"arxiv","key":"1906.01820","sourceId":"concept-mesa-optimization","sourceTitle":"Mesa-Optimization"},{"raw":"arXiv:2211.15661","kind":"arxiv","key":"2211.15661"},{"raw":"arXiv:2212.07677","kind":"arxiv","key":"2212.07677"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]}]},{"slug":"scalable-oversight","kind":"concept","title":"Scalable Oversight","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/scalable-oversight","total":17,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: how the core techniques try to beat the supervision gap","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1810.08575","kind":"arxiv","key":"1810.08575","sourceId":"concept-scalable-oversight","sourceTitle":"Scalable Oversight"},{"raw":"arXiv:1811.07871","kind":"arxiv","key":"1811.07871"},{"raw":"arXiv:1805.00899","kind":"arxiv","key":"1805.00899"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.14125","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.14125"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.05802","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.05802"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"A short development history of the term and agenda","citations":[{"raw":"10.23915/distill.00014","kind":"doi","key":"10.23915/distill.00014"},{"raw":"arXiv:1606.06565","kind":"arxiv","key":"1606.06565"},{"raw":"arXiv:1706.03741","kind":"arxiv","key":"1706.03741"},{"raw":"arXiv:1805.00899","kind":"arxiv","key":"1805.00899"},{"raw":"arXiv:1811.07871","kind":"arxiv","key":"1811.07871"},{"raw":"arXiv:1810.08575","kind":"arxiv","key":"1810.08575","sourceId":"concept-scalable-oversight","sourceTitle":"Scalable Oversight"},{"raw":"arXiv:2211.03540","kind":"arxiv","key":"2211.03540"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.05802","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.05802"},{"raw":"arXiv:2312.09390","kind":"arxiv","key":"2312.09390"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts it is often conflated with","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1706.03741","kind":"arxiv","key":"1706.03741"},{"raw":"arXiv:2204.05862","kind":"arxiv","key":"2204.05862"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"}]}]},{"slug":"capability-elicitation","kind":"concept","title":"Capability Elicitation","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/capability-elicitation","total":16,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"definition-and-distinctions","heading":"Definition and Distinctions from Adjacent Methods","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.03693","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.03693"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"}]},{"sectionId":"mechanisms-and-techniques","heading":"Mechanisms: How Capabilities Are Surfaced","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2310.03693","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.03693"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance and Instrument Engagement","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14981","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14981","sourceId":"lit-anka-reuel-ben-bucknall-stephen-casper-tim-fist-lennar","sourceTitle":"Open Problems in Technical AI Governance"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)"}]}]},{"slug":"dual-use-research-taxonomy","kind":"concept","title":"Dual-Use Research Norms (DURC for AI)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/dual-use-research-taxonomy","total":15,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"from-biosecurity-durc-to-ai-the-borrowed-frame","heading":"From Biosecurity DURC to AI: The Borrowed Frame","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:1908.09203","kind":"arxiv","key":"1908.09203","sourceId":"lit-irene-solaiman-miles-brundage-jack-clark-amanda-askell","sourceTitle":"Release Strategies and the Social Impacts of Language Models"},{"raw":"(OSTP 2014)","kind":"author_year","key":"(ostp 2014)"}]},{"sectionId":"mechanisms-the-three-release-postures","heading":"Mechanisms: The Three Release Postures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:1908.09203","kind":"arxiv","key":"1908.09203","sourceId":"lit-irene-solaiman-miles-brundage-jack-clark-amanda-askell","sourceTitle":"Release Strategies and the Social Impacts of Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"(METR 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(metr 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance-soft-law-meets-research-stage-gaps","heading":"Governance Relevance: Soft Law Meets Research-Stage Gaps","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)(ii)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)(ii)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 5","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 5"},{"raw":"§3","kind":"provision","key":"§3"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-does-the-biosecurity-analogy-hold","heading":"Debates: Does the Biosecurity Analogy Hold?","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14933","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14933","sourceId":"lit-shayne-longpre-robert-mahari-ariel-lee-et-al-consent-i","sourceTitle":"Consent in Crisis: The Rapid Decline of the AI Data Commons"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]}]},{"slug":"provenance-watermarking","kind":"concept","title":"Provenance & Watermarking","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/provenance-watermarking","total":15,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"two-technical-lineages-and-their-distinctions","heading":"Two Technical Lineages and Their Distinctions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","sourceId":"lit-keith-raymond-harris-ai-or-your-lying-eyes-some-shortc","sourceTitle":"AI or Your Lying Eyes: Some Shortcomings of Artificially Intelligent Deepfake Detectors"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","sourceId":"lit-groh-sankaranarayanan-singh-kim-lippman-picard-human-d","sourceTitle":"Human detection of political speech deepfakes across transcripts, audio, and video"}]},{"sectionId":"detection-mechanisms-and-robustness","heading":"Detection Mechanisms and Robustness","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41467-024-51998-z","sourceId":"lit-groh-sankaranarayanan-singh-kim-lippman-picard-human-d","sourceTitle":"Human detection of political speech deepfakes across transcripts, audio, and video"},{"raw":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s13347-024-00700-8","sourceId":"lit-keith-raymond-harris-ai-or-your-lying-eyes-some-shortc","sourceTitle":"AI or Your Lying Eyes: Some Shortcomings of Artificially Intelligent Deepfake Detectors"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance-and-cross-jurisdictional-alignment","heading":"Governance Relevance and Cross-Jurisdictional Alignment","citations":[{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.435","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.435","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-a-teleological-interpretation-of-the-defi","sourceTitle":"A Teleological Interpretation of the Definition of DeepFakes in the EU Artificial Intelligence Act—A Purpose-Based Approach to Potential Problems With the Word 'Existing'"},{"raw":"10.1002/poi3.406","kind":"doi","key":"10.1002/poi3.406","sourceId":"lit-mateusz-abuz-deep-fakes-and-the-artificial-intelligenc","sourceTitle":"Deep fakes and the Artificial Intelligence Act—An important signal or a missed opportunity?"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Art. 50(2)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(2)"},{"raw":"Art. 50(4)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50(4)"},{"raw":"§4.5","kind":"provision","key":"§4.5"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","kind":"doi","key":"10.5325/jinfopoli.15.2025.0004","sourceId":"lit-valentine-ugwuoke-and-madelyn-rose-sanfilippo-the-curr","sourceTitle":"The Current Landscape of Deepfake Legislation in the United States"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106024","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106024","sourceId":"lit-beatriz-kira-when-non-consensual-intimate-deepfakes-go","sourceTitle":"When non-consensual intimate deepfakes go viral: The insufficiency of the UK Online Safety Act"},{"raw":"10.1145/3613904.3642382","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3613904.3642382","sourceId":"lit-rebecca-umbach-nicola-henry-gemma-faye-beard-and-colle","sourceTitle":"Non-Consensual Synthetic Intimate Imagery: Prevalence, Attitudes, and Knowledge in 10 Countries"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11156","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11156","sourceId":"lit-vinu-sankar-sadasivan-aounon-kumar-sriram-balasubraman","sourceTitle":"Can AI-Generated Text be Reliably Detected?"},{"raw":"§5","kind":"provision","key":"§5"}]}]},{"slug":"policy-instrument","kind":"concept","title":"Policy Instrument","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/policy-instrument","total":13,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"resource-typology-and-distinctions","heading":"The Resource Typology and What It Distinguishes","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","kind":"doi","key":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","sourceId":"lit-lehdonvirta-w-hawkins-compute-north-vs-compute-south-t","sourceTitle":"Compute North vs. Compute South: The Uneven Possibilities of Compute-based AI Governance Around the Globe"},{"raw":"(Salamon 2002)","kind":"author_year","key":"(salamon 2002)"}]},{"sectionId":"how-instrument-choice-operates","heading":"How Instrument Choice Operates as Substance","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance-mapping-the-mix","heading":"Governance Relevance: Mapping the AI Instrument Mix","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/ilm.2025.1","sourceId":"lit-council-of-europe-introductory-note-by-marc-rotenberg","sourceTitle":"Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law (Council Eur.) — with Introductory Note"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-convergence-or-permanent-mix","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/ia/iiaf105","sourceId":"lit-mark-robinson-the-establishment-of-an-international-ai","sourceTitle":"The establishment of an international AI agency: an applied solution to global AI governance"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"§3)","kind":"provision","key":"§3)"},{"raw":"(Russell 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(russell 2024)"}]}]},{"slug":"ai-supply-chain","kind":"concept","title":"AI Supply Chain","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/ai-supply-chain","total":19,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"stage-decomposition-and-chokepoint-logic","heading":"Stage Decomposition and the Chokepoint Logic","citations":[{"raw":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","kind":"doi","key":"10.1609/aies.v7i1.31683","sourceId":"lit-lehdonvirta-w-hawkins-compute-north-vs-compute-south-t","sourceTitle":"Compute North vs. Compute South: The Uneven Possibilities of Compute-based AI Governance Around the Globe"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"}]},{"sectionId":"compute-thresholds-and-data-legality-as-levers","heading":"Compute Thresholds and Data Legality as Stage-Specific Levers","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-allocation-across-the-chain","heading":"Governance Allocation Across the Chain","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 25","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 25"},{"raw":"§4.2","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2"},{"raw":"§3","kind":"provision","key":"§3"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1177/0308518X251369704","kind":"doi","key":"10.1177/0308518x251369704","sourceId":"lit-justin-kollar-andrew-stokols-geopolitical-ecologies-of","sourceTitle":"Geopolitical ecologies of cloud capitalism: Territorial restructuring and the making of national computing power in the U.S. and China"},{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","sourceId":"lit-martin-kretschmer-bartolomeo-meletti-lionel-bently-gab","sourceTitle":"Copyright and AI in the UK: Opting-In or Opting-Out?"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"(CISA 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(cisa 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"training-data-attribution","kind":"concept","title":"Training-Data Attribution","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/training-data-attribution","total":19,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"precise-definition-and-distinctions","heading":"Precise definition and the influence-versus-extraction distinction","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","sourceId":"lit-kaigeng-li-hong-wu-yupeng-dong-copyright-protection-du","sourceTitle":"Copyright protection during the training stage of generative AI: Industry-oriented U.S. law, rights-oriented EU law, and fair remuneration rights for generative AI training under the UN's international governance regime for AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2308.03296","kind":"arxiv","key":"2308.03296","sourceId":"concept-training-data-attribution","sourceTitle":"Training-Data Attribution"}]},{"sectionId":"how-it-works","heading":"Technical mechanisms and their scaling limits","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","sourceId":"lit-longpre-mahari-et-al-data-provenance-initiative-a-larg","sourceTitle":"A large-scale audit of dataset licensing and attribution in AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2002.08484","kind":"arxiv","key":"2002.08484"},{"raw":"arXiv:2308.03296","kind":"arxiv","key":"2308.03296","sourceId":"concept-training-data-attribution","sourceTitle":"Training-Data Attribution"},{"raw":"(Koh & Liang 2017)","kind":"author_year","key":"(koh & liang 2017)"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Regulatory and litigation engagement","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","sourceId":"lit-longpre-mahari-et-al-data-provenance-initiative-a-larg","sourceTitle":"A large-scale audit of dataset licensing and attribution in AI"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106056","sourceId":"lit-kaigeng-li-hong-wu-yupeng-dong-copyright-protection-du","sourceTitle":"Copyright protection during the training stage of generative AI: Industry-oriented U.S. law, rights-oriented EU law, and fair remuneration rights for generative AI training under the UN's international governance regime for AI"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(d)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(d)"},{"raw":"Art. 53(1)(c)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53(1)(c)"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"(Havlikova 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(havlikova 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Open questions: efficacy, remedy, and the consensus gap","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","sourceId":"lit-petros-terzis-michael-veale-no-lle-gaumann-law-and-the","sourceTitle":"Law and the Emerging Political Economy of Algorithmic Audits"},{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"arXiv:2308.03296","kind":"arxiv","key":"2308.03296","sourceId":"concept-training-data-attribution","sourceTitle":"Training-Data Attribution"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14933","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14933","sourceId":"lit-shayne-longpre-robert-mahari-ariel-lee-et-al-consent-i","sourceTitle":"Consent in Crisis: The Rapid Decline of the AI Data Commons"}]}]},{"slug":"prompt-injection","kind":"concept","title":"Prompt Injection","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/prompt-injection","total":15,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: why models cannot separate data from instructions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2302.12173","kind":"arxiv","key":"2302.12173","sourceId":"concept-prompt-injection","sourceTitle":"Prompt Injection"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.12815","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.12815"},{"raw":"arXiv:2211.09527","kind":"arxiv","key":"2211.09527"}]},{"sectionId":"defense-paradigms","heading":"Open debate: is prompt injection solvable, and at which layer?","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2310.12815","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.12815"},{"raw":"arXiv:2404.13208","kind":"arxiv","key":"2404.13208"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.06363","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.06363"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.05451","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.05451"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.00061","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.00061"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.18813","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.18813"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History: from a 2022 naming to an agentic threat model","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2211.09527","kind":"arxiv","key":"2211.09527"},{"raw":"arXiv:2302.12173","kind":"arxiv","key":"2302.12173","sourceId":"concept-prompt-injection","sourceTitle":"Prompt Injection"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.12815","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.12815"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.13352","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.13352"},{"raw":"(OWASP 2023)","kind":"author_year","key":"(owasp 2023)"},{"raw":"(Willison 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(willison 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"agentic-system","kind":"concept","title":"Agentic AI System","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/agentic-system","total":13,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: the agent loop and its principal variants","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2210.03629","kind":"arxiv","key":"2210.03629","sourceId":"concept-agentic-system","sourceTitle":"Agentic AI System"},{"raw":"arXiv:2302.04761","kind":"arxiv","key":"2302.04761"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11366","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11366"},{"raw":"arXiv:2304.03442","kind":"arxiv","key":"2304.03442"}]},{"sectionId":"definitional-debate","heading":"Open debate: a contested, marketing-stretched category","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2407.01502","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.01502"},{"raw":"arXiv:2508.05338","kind":"arxiv","key":"2508.05338"},{"raw":"arXiv:2505.10468","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.10468"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"History: from rational agents to autonomous-replication evaluations","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2210.03629","kind":"arxiv","key":"2210.03629","sourceId":"concept-agentic-system","sourceTitle":"Agentic AI System"},{"raw":"arXiv:2302.04761","kind":"arxiv","key":"2302.04761"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11366","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11366"},{"raw":"arXiv:2304.03442","kind":"arxiv","key":"2304.03442"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.02649","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.02649"},{"raw":"(Fortune 2023)","kind":"author_year","key":"(fortune 2023)"}]}]},{"slug":"tool-use-safety","kind":"concept","title":"Tool-Use Safety","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/tool-use-safety","total":13,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":2,"sections":[{"sectionId":"unit-of-analysis-and-distinctions","heading":"Unit of Analysis and Distinctions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.15324","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.15324","sourceId":"lit-shevlane-farquhar-garfinkel-et-al-model-evaluation-for","sourceTitle":"Model evaluation for extreme risks"},{"raw":"arXiv:2306.03809","kind":"arxiv","key":"2306.03809","sourceId":"lit-soice-rocha-cordova-specter-esvelt-can-large-language","sourceTitle":"Can large language models democratize access to dual-use biotechnology?"}]},{"sectionId":"adversarial-mechanisms-and-mitigations","heading":"Adversarial Mechanisms and Mitigations","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adn0117","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adn0117","sourceId":"lit-bengio-hinton-yao-song-et-al-managing-extreme-ai-risks","sourceTitle":"Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress"},{"raw":"arXiv:2404.13208","kind":"arxiv","key":"2404.13208"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.07300","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.07300","sourceId":"lit-jonas-schuett-markus-anderljung-alexis-carlier-leonie","sourceTitle":"From Principles to Rules: A Regulatory Approach for Frontier AI"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"Art. 14","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s11098-025-02301-3","sourceId":"lit-atoosa-kasirzadeh-two-types-of-ai-existential-risk-dec","sourceTitle":"Two types of AI existential risk: decisive and accumulative"},{"raw":"10.1126/science.adn0117","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adn0117","sourceId":"lit-bengio-hinton-yao-song-et-al-managing-extreme-ai-risks","sourceTitle":"Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress"},{"raw":"Art. 14-style","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 14-style"}]}]},{"slug":"multi-turn-evaluation","kind":"concept","title":"Multi-Turn Evaluation","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/multi-turn-evaluation","total":15,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"definition-and-distinctions","heading":"Definition and Distinctions from Single-Turn Benchmarks","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3593013.3594067.","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","sourceId":"lit-hacker-engel-mauer-regulating-chatgpt-and-other-large","sourceTitle":"Regulating ChatGPT and other Large Generative AI Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2306.05685","kind":"arxiv","key":"2306.05685","sourceId":"concept-multi-turn-evaluation","sourceTitle":"Multi-Turn Evaluation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"}]},{"sectionId":"mechanisms","heading":"Mechanisms: What Trajectories Surface That Snapshots Hide","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14981","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14981","sourceId":"lit-anka-reuel-ben-bucknall-stephen-casper-tim-fist-lennar","sourceTitle":"Open Problems in Technical AI Governance"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance: Instruments and Provisions Engaged","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3632753","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3632753","sourceId":"lit-henrik-palmer-olsen-thomas-troels-hildebrandt-corneliu","sourceTitle":"The Right to Transparency in Public Governance: Freedom of Information and the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Public Agencies"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","sourceId":"lit-petros-terzis-michael-veale-no-lle-gaumann-law-and-the","sourceTitle":"Law and the Emerging Political Economy of Algorithmic Audits"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14981","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14981","sourceId":"lit-anka-reuel-ben-bucknall-stephen-casper-tim-fist-lennar","sourceTitle":"Open Problems in Technical AI Governance"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"}]}]},{"slug":"data-poisoning","kind":"concept","title":"Data Poisoning","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/data-poisoning","total":17,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":6,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism-and-attack-taxonomy","heading":"Mechanism and Attack Taxonomy","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"arXiv:2302.10149","kind":"arxiv","key":"2302.10149","sourceId":"concept-data-poisoning","sourceTitle":"Data Poisoning"}]},{"sectionId":"distinguishing-adjacent-attack-surfaces","heading":"Distinguishing Adjacent Attack Surfaces","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","sourceId":"lit-longpre-mahari-et-al-data-provenance-initiative-a-larg","sourceTitle":"A large-scale audit of dataset licensing and attribution in AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14933","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14933","sourceId":"lit-shayne-longpre-robert-mahari-ariel-lee-et-al-consent-i","sourceTitle":"Consent in Crisis: The Rapid Decline of the AI Data Commons"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance-and-instrument-coverage","heading":"Governance Relevance and Instrument Coverage","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Art. 15","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 15"},{"raw":"Art. 15(5)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 15(5)"},{"raw":"Art. 55","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55"},{"raw":"§2.9","kind":"provision","key":"§2.9"},{"raw":"Art. 7","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 7"}]},{"sectionId":"open-questions-and-the-verification-gap","heading":"Open Questions and the Verification Gap","citations":[{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3658970","sourceId":"lit-petros-terzis-michael-veale-no-lle-gaumann-law-and-the","sourceTitle":"Law and the Emerging Political Economy of Algorithmic Audits"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"Art. 3","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 3"},{"raw":"(Havlikova 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(havlikova 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"model-distillation-risk","kind":"concept","title":"Model Distillation Risk","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/model-distillation-risk","total":16,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism-cross-organisational-distillation","heading":"From Benign Compression to Cross-Boundary Capability Transfer","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:1503.02531","kind":"arxiv","key":"1503.02531","sourceId":"concept-model-distillation-risk","sourceTitle":"Model Distillation Risk"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"(Stanford, 2023)","kind":"author_year","key":"(stanford, 2023)"}]},{"sectionId":"why-it-breaks-containment-assumptions","heading":"Why It Undercuts the Closed-Weight Containment Assumption","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-engagement-and-enforcement-gap","heading":"Governance Surfaces That Engage — and the Enforcement Gap","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.08501","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.08501","sourceId":"lit-lennart-heim-tim-fist-janet-egan-sihao-huang-stephen-z","sourceTitle":"Governing Through the Cloud: The Intermediary Role of Compute Providers in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"the-contested-evidence-base","heading":"Contested Evidence: Substantive Transfer or Surface Mimicry?","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2305.15717","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.15717"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.12948","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.12948"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"}]}]},{"slug":"jailbreak-resistance","kind":"concept","title":"Jailbreak Resistance","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/jailbreak-resistance","total":14,"distinctSources":12,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: attack families and defence families","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2307.15043","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.15043","sourceId":"concept-jailbreak-resistance","sourceTitle":"Jailbreak Resistance"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.08419","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.08419"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.02483","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.02483"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.03684","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.03684"},{"raw":"arXiv:2501.18837","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.18837"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.04313","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.04313"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques","heading":"Open critiques: is reported jailbreak success measuring the right thing?","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2402.10260","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.10260"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.10694","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.10694"},{"raw":"arXiv:2404.01318","kind":"arxiv","key":"2404.01318"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.04249","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.04249"},{"raw":"Art. 55)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55)"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2307.02483","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.02483"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.07300","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.07300","sourceId":"lit-jonas-schuett-markus-anderljung-alexis-carlier-leonie","sourceTitle":"From Principles to Rules: A Regulatory Approach for Frontier AI"}]}]},{"slug":"model-merging-risk","kind":"concept","title":"Model-Merging Risk","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/model-merging-risk","total":16,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"precise-definition-and-distinctions","heading":"Definition and Distinctions From Adjacent Risks","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","sourceId":"lit-longpre-mahari-et-al-data-provenance-initiative-a-larg","sourceTitle":"A large-scale audit of dataset licensing and attribution in AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.11746","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.11746","sourceId":"concept-model-merging-risk","sourceTitle":"Model-Merging Risk"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]},{"sectionId":"how-it-works","heading":"Mechanisms: Why Safety Is Not Preserved Under Merging","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3593013.3594067","sourceId":"lit-hacker-engel-mauer-regulating-chatgpt-and-other-large","sourceTitle":"Regulating ChatGPT and other Large Generative AI Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.11746","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.11746","sourceId":"concept-model-merging-risk","sourceTitle":"Model-Merging Risk"},{"raw":"arXiv:2203.05482","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.05482"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance and the Regulatory-Unit Problem","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s12027-025-00869-1","sourceId":"lit-martina-hulok-the-eu-model-of-ai-governance-regulating","sourceTitle":"The EU model of AI governance: regulating artificial intelligence through law and policy"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikag002","sourceId":"lit-arne-radeisen-open-foundation-models-and-tdm-exception","sourceTitle":"Open Foundation Models and TDM Exceptions to Copyright – Building Blocks for an AI Ecosystem"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14933","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14933","sourceId":"lit-shayne-longpre-robert-mahari-ariel-lee-et-al-consent-i","sourceTitle":"Consent in Crisis: The Rapid Decline of the AI Data Commons"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.11746","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.11746","sourceId":"concept-model-merging-risk","sourceTitle":"Model-Merging Risk"}]}]},{"slug":"inference-time-compute","kind":"concept","title":"Inference-Time Compute","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/inference-time-compute","total":12,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":3,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism-and-distinction-from-training-scaling","heading":"Mechanism and Distinction from Training-Time Scaling","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2408.03314","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.03314","sourceId":"concept-inference-time-compute","sourceTitle":"Inference-Time Compute"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"}]},{"sectionId":"empirical-record","heading":"The Empirical Record","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2408.03314","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.03314","sourceId":"concept-inference-time-compute","sourceTitle":"Inference-Time Compute"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance and the Threshold Problem","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 51)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51)"},{"raw":"§4.2(a)","kind":"provision","key":"§4.2(a)"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2403.08501","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.08501","sourceId":"lit-lennart-heim-tim-fist-janet-egan-sihao-huang-stephen-z","sourceTitle":"Governing Through the Cloud: The Intermediary Role of Compute Providers in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"}]}]},{"slug":"sandbagging","kind":"concept","title":"Sandbagging","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/sandbagging","total":8,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism","heading":"Mechanism: actors, methods, and calibration","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2406.07358","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.07358","sourceId":"concept-sandbagging","sourceTitle":"Sandbagging"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.19550","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.19550"}]},{"sectionId":"adjacent-concepts","heading":"Relation to adjacent concepts","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2311.08379","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.08379"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.14093","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.14093"},{"raw":"arXiv:2604.28182","kind":"arxiv","key":"2604.28182"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-debates","heading":"Open critiques and validity debates","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2412.04984","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.04984"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.19550","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.19550"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.01784","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.01784"}]}]},{"slug":"hallucination","kind":"concept","title":"Hallucination","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/hallucination","total":17,"distinctSources":11,"provisionAnchors":4,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism-and-typology","heading":"Mechanism and Typology","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2202.03629","kind":"arxiv","key":"2202.03629","sourceId":"concept-hallucination","sourceTitle":"Hallucination"},{"raw":"arXiv:2509.04664","kind":"arxiv","key":"2509.04664"},{"raw":"arXiv:2401.11817","kind":"arxiv","key":"2401.11817"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-surfaces","heading":"Governance Surfaces and Engaging Provisions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Art. 13)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 13)"},{"raw":"Art. 53)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53)"},{"raw":"Art. 85","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 85"},{"raw":"Art. 86","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 86"}]},{"sectionId":"sectoral-stakes-healthcare","heading":"Sectoral Stakes: The Healthcare Test Case","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01544-y","sourceId":"lit-gary-e-weissman-toni-mankowitz-genevieve-p-kanter-unre","sourceTitle":"Unregulated large language models produce medical device-like output"},{"raw":"10.21037/jmai-2025-196","kind":"doi","key":"10.21037/jmai-2025-196","sourceId":"lit-aditya-loganathan-michael-friedman-tayab-waseem-et-al","sourceTitle":"Current state of Food and Drug Administration-approved artificial intelligence/machine learning medical devices: pathways, transparency, and evidence gaps"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01717-9","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01717-9","sourceId":"lit-boris-babic-i-glenn-cohen-ariel-dora-stern-yiwen-li-me","sourceTitle":"A general framework for governing marketed AI/ML medical devices"},{"raw":"10.1038/s41746-025-01618-x","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s41746-025-01618-x","sourceId":"lit-vijaytha-muralidharan-madelena-y-ng-shada-alsalamah-sa","sourceTitle":"Global Initiative on AI for Health (GI-AI4H): strategic priorities advancing governance across the United Nations"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3757415","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3757415","sourceId":"lit-mireia-yurrita-himanshu-verma-agathe-balayn-kars-alfri","sourceTitle":"Identifying Algorithmic Decision Subjects' Needs for Meaningful Contestability"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"arXiv:2401.11817","kind":"arxiv","key":"2401.11817"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.18236","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.18236"},{"raw":"(Charlotin 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(charlotin 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"in-context-learning","kind":"concept","title":"In-Context Learning","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/in-context-learning","total":12,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":3,"sections":[{"sectionId":"definition-and-distinctions","heading":"Precise Definition and Distinctions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"arXiv:2005.14165","kind":"arxiv","key":"2005.14165","sourceId":"concept-in-context-learning","sourceTitle":"In-Context Learning"}]},{"sectionId":"how-it-works","heading":"Mechanisms and Empirical Substance","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance Relevance and Engaged Provisions","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2502.00003","kind":"arxiv","key":"2502.00003","sourceId":"lit-matteo-pistillo-pablo-villalobos-defending-compute-thr","sourceTitle":"Defending Compute Thresholds Against Legal Loopholes"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"Art. 55(1)(a)","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 55(1)(a)"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and Open Questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1145/3632753","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3632753","sourceId":"lit-henrik-palmer-olsen-thomas-troels-hildebrandt-corneliu","sourceTitle":"The Right to Transparency in Public Governance: Freedom of Information and the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Public Agencies"},{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14981","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14981","sourceId":"lit-anka-reuel-ben-bucknall-stephen-casper-tim-fist-lennar","sourceTitle":"Open Problems in Technical AI Governance"}]}]},{"slug":"retrieval-augmented-generation","kind":"concept","title":"Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/retrieval-augmented-generation","total":16,"distinctSources":10,"provisionAnchors":5,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism-and-architecture","heading":"Mechanism and architecture","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:2005.11401","kind":"arxiv","key":"2005.11401","sourceId":"concept-retrieval-augmented-generation","sourceTitle":"Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)"}]},{"sectionId":"distinctions-and-failure-modes","heading":"Distinctions from pure-LLM generation and residual failure modes","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/idpl/ipae013","sourceId":"lit-taner-kuru-lawfulness-of-the-mass-processing-of-public","sourceTitle":"Lawfulness of the mass processing of publicly accessible online data to train large language models"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"Art. 9","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 9"}]},{"sectionId":"governance-relevance","heading":"Governance relevance and the regulated/unregulated layer split","citations":[{"raw":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","kind":"doi","key":"10.1007/s10506-024-09412-y","sourceId":"lit-david-fern-ndez-llorca-emilia-g-mez-ignacio-s-nchez-ga","sourceTitle":"An interdisciplinary account of the terminological choices by EU policymakers ahead of the final agreement on the AI Act: AI system, general purpose AI system, foundation model, and generative AI"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.clsr.2024.106066","sourceId":"lit-novelli-casolari-hacker-spedicato-floridi-generative-a","sourceTitle":"Generative AI in EU law: Liability, privacy, intellectual property, and cybersecurity"},{"raw":"Art. 53","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 53"},{"raw":"Art. 50","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 50"},{"raw":"§2.12","kind":"provision","key":"§2.12"},{"raw":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689","kind":"provision","key":"Regulation (EU) 2024/1689"}]},{"sectionId":"debates-and-open-questions","heading":"Debates and open questions","citations":[{"raw":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","kind":"doi","key":"10.1038/s42256-024-00878-8","sourceId":"lit-longpre-mahari-et-al-data-provenance-initiative-a-larg","sourceTitle":"A large-scale audit of dataset licensing and attribution in AI"},{"raw":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","kind":"doi","key":"10.1093/grurint/ikaf093","sourceId":"lit-martin-kretschmer-bartolomeo-meletti-lionel-bently-gab","sourceTitle":"Copyright and AI in the UK: Opting-In or Opting-Out?"},{"raw":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","kind":"doi","key":"10.1145/3630106.3659051","sourceId":"lit-sarah-sterz-kevin-baum-sebastian-biewer-holger-hermann","sourceTitle":"On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives"},{"raw":"arXiv:2302.12173","kind":"arxiv","key":"2302.12173","sourceId":"concept-prompt-injection","sourceTitle":"Prompt Injection"}]}]},{"slug":"chain-of-thought-monitoring","kind":"concept","title":"Chain-of-Thought Monitoring","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/chain-of-thought-monitoring","total":16,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"open-critiques","heading":"Open critiques and threats to the approach","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2510.27338","kind":"arxiv","key":"2510.27338"},{"raw":"arXiv:2507.11473","kind":"arxiv","key":"2507.11473","sourceId":"concept-chain-of-thought-monitoring","sourceTitle":"Chain-of-Thought Monitoring"},{"raw":"arXiv:2511.11584","kind":"arxiv","key":"2511.11584"},{"raw":"arXiv:2510.19851","kind":"arxiv","key":"2510.19851"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.09762","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.09762"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.06769","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.06769"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"A short history of the debate","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2305.04388","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.04388"},{"raw":"arXiv:2503.11926","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.11926"},{"raw":"arXiv:2505.05410","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.05410"},{"raw":"arXiv:2507.11473","kind":"arxiv","key":"2507.11473","sourceId":"concept-chain-of-thought-monitoring","sourceTitle":"Chain-of-Thought Monitoring"}]},{"sectionId":"evidence-table","heading":"Flagship studies at a glance","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2503.11926","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.11926"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.04388","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.04388"},{"raw":"arXiv:2505.05410","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.05410"},{"raw":"arXiv:2507.11473","kind":"arxiv","key":"2507.11473","sourceId":"concept-chain-of-thought-monitoring","sourceTitle":"Chain-of-Thought Monitoring"}]},{"sectionId":"relation-to-oversight","heading":"Relation to other oversight levers","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2503.11926","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.11926"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.04388","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.04388"}]}]},{"slug":"hardware-enabled-governance","kind":"concept","title":"Hardware-Enabled Governance Mechanisms","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/hardware-enabled-governance","total":16,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":1,"sections":[{"sectionId":"mechanism-families","heading":"The four mechanism families","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11341","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11341","sourceId":"lit-shavit-what-does-it-take-to-catch-a-chinchilla-verifyi","sourceTitle":"What does it take to catch a Chinchilla? Verifying Rules on Large-Scale Neural Network Training via Compute Monitoring"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"}]},{"sectionId":"technical-crux","heading":"Technical crux: the hardware root of trust","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2407.14981","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.14981","sourceId":"lit-anka-reuel-ben-bucknall-stephen-casper-tim-fist-lennar","sourceTitle":"Open Problems in Technical AI Governance"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"}]},{"sectionId":"history","heading":"Development timeline","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2303.11341","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.11341","sourceId":"lit-shavit-what-does-it-take-to-catch-a-chinchilla-verifyi","sourceTitle":"What does it take to catch a Chinchilla? Verifying Rules on Large-Scale Neural Network Training via Compute Monitoring"},{"raw":"arXiv:2402.08797","kind":"arxiv","key":"2402.08797","sourceId":"lit-sastry-heim-belfield-anderljung-brundage-et-al-computi","sourceTitle":"Computing Power and the Governance of Artificial Intelligence"},{"raw":"arXiv:2408.16074","kind":"arxiv","key":"2408.16074","sourceId":"lit-akash-r-wasil-tom-reed-jack-william-miller-peter-barne","sourceTitle":"Verification methods for international AI agreements"},{"raw":"arXiv:2506.03409","kind":"arxiv","key":"2506.03409"},{"raw":"(HFAC 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(hfac 2026)"}]},{"sectionId":"policy-landscape","heading":"Policy landscape and counter-arguments","citations":[{"raw":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","kind":"doi","key":"10.1080/23311886.2025.2528450","sourceId":"lit-megha-shrivastava-and-amrita-jash-china-s-semiconducto","sourceTitle":"China's semiconductor conundrum: understanding US export controls and their efficacy"},{"raw":"10.1017/S0020818325101070","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/s0020818325101070","sourceId":"lit-stephen-weymouth-digital-disintegration-techno-blocs-a","sourceTitle":"Digital Disintegration: Techno-Blocs and Strategic Sovereignty in the AI Era"},{"raw":"10.1016/j.techfore.2024.123749","kind":"doi","key":"10.1016/j.techfore.2024.123749","sourceId":"lit-chan-yuan-wong-henry-wai-chung-yeung-shaopeng-huang-ja","sourceTitle":"Geopolitics and the changing landscape of global value chains and competition in the global semiconductor industry: Rivalry and catch-up in chip manufacturing in East Asia"},{"raw":"arXiv:2405.10799","kind":"arxiv","key":"2405.10799","sourceId":"lit-heim-koessler-training-compute-thresholds-features-and","sourceTitle":"Training Compute Thresholds: Features and Functions in AI Regulation"},{"raw":"Art. 51","kind":"provision","key":"Art. 51"},{"raw":"(Castro 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(castro 2024)"},{"raw":"(NVIDIA 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(nvidia 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"swe-bench-verified","kind":"benchmark","title":"SWE-bench Verified","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/swe-bench-verified","total":15,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"contamination-and-gaming","heading":"Contamination & gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2410.09024","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.09024","sourceId":"lit-maksym-andriushchenko-alexandra-souly-mateusz-dziemian","sourceTitle":"AgentHarm: A Benchmark for Measuring Harmfulness of LLM Agents"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.06992","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.06992"},{"raw":"arXiv:2506.12286","kind":"arxiv","key":"2506.12286"},{"raw":"arXiv:2505.20411","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.20411"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2026)"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-and-limitations","heading":"Critiques & limitations","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2410.06992","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.06992"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.06770","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.06770"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2024)"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2026)"}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-and-trajectory","heading":"Saturation & score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"10.1126/science.adj0998","kind":"doi","key":"10.1126/science.adj0998","sourceId":"lit-eloundou-manning-mishkin-rock-gpts-are-gpts-labor-mark","sourceTitle":"GPTs are GPTs: Labor market impact potential of LLMs"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.06770","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.06770"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2024)"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2026)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2026)"}]}]},{"slug":"mmlu","kind":"benchmark","title":"MMLU","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/mmlu","total":9,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation and score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2009.03300","kind":"arxiv","key":"2009.03300"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.08774","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.08774"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.01574","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.01574"}]},{"sectionId":"label-errors-limitations","heading":"Label errors and item-quality critiques","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2406.04127","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.04127"},{"raw":"arXiv:2108.07258","kind":"arxiv","key":"2108.07258","sourceId":"lit-bommasani-et-al-on-the-opportunities-and-risks-of-foun","sourceTitle":"On the Opportunities and Risks of Foundation Models"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-gaming","heading":"Contamination, gaming, and contamination-resistant variants","citations":[{"raw":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","kind":"doi","key":"10.1017/cfl.2024.2","sourceId":"lit-hannah-ruschemeier-generative-ai-and-data-protection","sourceTitle":"Generative AI and data protection"},{"raw":"arXiv:2412.15194","kind":"arxiv","key":"2412.15194"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.01574","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.01574"}]}]},{"slug":"mmlu-pro","kind":"benchmark","title":"MMLU-Pro","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/mmlu-pro","total":9,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"construct-what-it-measures","heading":"Construct & what it actually measures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2406.01574","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.01574"},{"raw":"arXiv:2108.07258","kind":"arxiv","key":"2108.07258","sourceId":"lit-bommasani-et-al-on-the-opportunities-and-risks-of-foun","sourceTitle":"On the Opportunities and Risks of Foundation Models"}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation & score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2406.01574","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.01574"},{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-limitations","heading":"Critiques & limitations","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2406.01574","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.01574"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.19470","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.19470"},{"raw":"arXiv:2409.02257","kind":"arxiv","key":"2409.02257"},{"raw":"arXiv:2108.07258","kind":"arxiv","key":"2108.07258","sourceId":"lit-bommasani-et-al-on-the-opportunities-and-risks-of-foun","sourceTitle":"On the Opportunities and Risks of Foundation Models"}]}]},{"slug":"gpqa-diamond","kind":"benchmark","title":"GPQA Diamond","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/gpqa-diamond","total":10,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"construct-validity","heading":"Construct and what it actually measures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2311.12022","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.12022"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation and score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2311.12022","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.12022"},{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"},{"raw":"(OpenAI 2024)","kind":"author_year","key":"(openai 2024)"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-format","heading":"Contamination, format sensitivity, and gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2311.12022","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.12022"},{"raw":"arXiv:2509.01790","kind":"arxiv","key":"2509.01790"},{"raw":"arXiv:2506.04734","kind":"arxiv","key":"2506.04734"}]}]},{"slug":"arc-agi-v2","kind":"benchmark","title":"ARC-AGI v2","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/arc-agi-v2","total":16,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":7,"sections":[{"sectionId":"construct-what-it-measures","heading":"Construct & what it actually measures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2505.11831","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.11831"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"},{"raw":"§7.2).","kind":"provision","key":"§7.2)."},{"raw":"§1).","kind":"provision","key":"§1)."}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation & score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2505.11831","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.11831"},{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2203.15556","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.15556","sourceId":"lit-jordan-hoffmann-sebastian-borgeaud-arthur-mensch-et-al","sourceTitle":"Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models"},{"raw":"§5","kind":"provision","key":"§5"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-and-gaming","heading":"Contamination & gaming resistance","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2505.11831","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.11831"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:1810.03993","kind":"arxiv","key":"1810.03993","sourceId":"concept-model-card","sourceTitle":"Model Card"},{"raw":"§1.2","kind":"provision","key":"§1.2"},{"raw":"§2).","kind":"provision","key":"§2)."},{"raw":"§3).","kind":"provision","key":"§3)."},{"raw":"§8.2).","kind":"provision","key":"§8.2)."}]}]},{"slug":"humaneval","kind":"benchmark","title":"HumanEval","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/humaneval","total":8,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"construct-what-it-measures","heading":"Construct & what it actually measures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2107.03374","kind":"arxiv","key":"2107.03374"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.06770","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.06770"}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation & score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2107.03374","kind":"arxiv","key":"2107.03374"},{"raw":"arXiv:2303.08774","kind":"arxiv","key":"2303.08774"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.01210","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.01210"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-and-gaming","heading":"Contamination & gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2407.07565","kind":"arxiv","key":"2407.07565"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.04811","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.04811"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.01210","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.01210"}]}]},{"slug":"math-benchmark","kind":"benchmark","title":"MATH (Hendrycks)","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/math-benchmark","total":11,"distinctSources":7,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation and score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2103.03874","kind":"arxiv","key":"2103.03874"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.14858","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.14858"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.20050","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.20050"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-gaming","heading":"Contamination and gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2103.03874","kind":"arxiv","key":"2103.03874"},{"raw":"arXiv:2310.18018","kind":"arxiv","key":"2310.18018"},{"raw":"arXiv:2311.04850","kind":"arxiv","key":"2311.04850"},{"raw":"arXiv:2406.13990","kind":"arxiv","key":"2406.13990"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.20050","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.20050"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-limitations","heading":"Critiques and limitations","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2103.03874","kind":"arxiv","key":"2103.03874"},{"raw":"arXiv:2305.20050","kind":"arxiv","key":"2305.20050"},{"raw":"arXiv:2410.07985","kind":"arxiv","key":"2410.07985"}]}]},{"slug":"aime-2024","kind":"benchmark","title":"AIME 2024","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/aime-2024","total":11,"distinctSources":9,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"construct-what-it-actually-measures","heading":"Construct & what it actually measures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2503.21934","kind":"arxiv","key":"2503.21934"},{"raw":"arXiv:2507.12885","kind":"arxiv","key":"2507.12885"},{"raw":"arXiv:2504.07086","kind":"arxiv","key":"2504.07086"}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-score-trajectory","heading":"Saturation & score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.12948","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.12948"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"(MathArena 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(matharena 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-gaming","heading":"Contamination & gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2510.02386","kind":"arxiv","key":"2510.02386"},{"raw":"arXiv:2507.10532","kind":"arxiv","key":"2507.10532"},{"raw":"arXiv:2505.23281","kind":"arxiv","key":"2505.23281"},{"raw":"arXiv:2507.12885","kind":"arxiv","key":"2507.12885"}]}]},{"slug":"humanitys-last-exam","kind":"benchmark","title":"Humanity's Last Exam","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/humanitys-last-exam","total":10,"distinctSources":8,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation and score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.14249","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.14249"},{"raw":"arXiv:2203.15556","kind":"arxiv","key":"2203.15556","sourceId":"lit-jordan-hoffmann-sebastian-borgeaud-arthur-mensch-et-al","sourceTitle":"Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2001.08361","kind":"arxiv","key":"2001.08361","sourceId":"lit-jared-kaplan-sam-mccandlish-tom-henighan-tom-b-brown-b","sourceTitle":"Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-gaming","heading":"Contamination and gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2501.14249","kind":"arxiv","key":"2501.14249"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2201.05159","kind":"arxiv","key":"2201.05159","sourceId":"lit-toby-shevlane-structured-access-an-emerging-paradigm-f","sourceTitle":"Structured access: an emerging paradigm for safe AI deployment"}]},{"sectionId":"critiques-limitations","heading":"Critiques and limitations","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2602.13964","kind":"arxiv","key":"2602.13964"},{"raw":"arXiv:2108.07258","kind":"arxiv","key":"2108.07258","sourceId":"lit-bommasani-et-al-on-the-opportunities-and-risks-of-foun","sourceTitle":"On the Opportunities and Risks of Foundation Models"},{"raw":"(FutureHouse 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(futurehouse 2025)"}]}]},{"slug":"frontiermath","kind":"benchmark","title":"FrontierMath","url":"https://policywindow.org/wiki/frontiermath","total":10,"distinctSources":6,"provisionAnchors":0,"sections":[{"sectionId":"construct-validity","heading":"Construct: what it actually measures","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2411.04872","kind":"arxiv","key":"2411.04872"},{"raw":"arXiv:2206.07682","kind":"arxiv","key":"2206.07682","sourceId":"lit-jason-wei-yi-tay-rishi-bommasani-colin-raffel-barret-z","sourceTitle":"Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models"},{"raw":"(Burnham 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(burnham 2025)"}]},{"sectionId":"saturation-trajectory","heading":"Saturation and score trajectory","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2411.04872","kind":"arxiv","key":"2411.04872"},{"raw":"arXiv:2403.13793","kind":"arxiv","key":"2403.13793","sourceId":"lit-mary-phuong-matthew-aitchison-elliot-catt-et-al-google","sourceTitle":"Evaluating Frontier Models for Dangerous Capabilities"},{"raw":"arXiv:2307.03718","kind":"arxiv","key":"2307.03718","sourceId":"lit-anderljung-barnhart-korinek-et-al-frontier-ai-regulati","sourceTitle":"Frontier AI Regulation: Managing Emerging Risks to Public Safety"}]},{"sectionId":"contamination-gaming","heading":"Contamination, access asymmetry, and gaming","citations":[{"raw":"arXiv:2108.07258","kind":"arxiv","key":"2108.07258","sourceId":"lit-bommasani-et-al-on-the-opportunities-and-risks-of-foun","sourceTitle":"On the Opportunities and Risks of Foundation Models"},{"raw":"arXiv:2201.05159","kind":"arxiv","key":"2201.05159","sourceId":"lit-toby-shevlane-structured-access-an-emerging-paradigm-f","sourceTitle":"Structured access: an emerging paradigm for safe AI deployment"},{"raw":"arXiv:2411.04872","kind":"arxiv","key":"2411.04872"},{"raw":"(Burnham 2025)","kind":"author_year","key":"(burnham 2025)"}]}]}]}