Skip to content
Human by choice
A Policy Window advocacy programmeWiki · neutral reference ↗

HBC-M021 · Brazil

Who chooses your decision supporters?

Distinguish chosen support from someone deciding for you.

Published 15 November 2026

What the source says

Source summary

Brazil’s Civil Code Article 1.783-A, inserted in 2015, describes a person with a disability choosing at least two suitable, trusted people with existing ties to provide information for civil decisions. The person requests the arrangement. Its terms set limits, commitments and duration, respecting their will, rights and interests. The judge hears participants personally, with multidisciplinary assistance and public-prosecutor input. Decisions within agreed limits affect third parties; contract counterparties may request countersignatures. Transaction disputes with a supporter involving risk or significant harm go to the judge. Upheld misconduct complaints lead to removal; replacement requires hearing the person and must be in their interest. The person may request termination at any time; supporters need judicial consideration to leave. This inspected text does not establish funded or available support, an AI ban, effectiveness or current individual applicability.

Research date: 2026-11-15. See the sources, versions and relevant passages.

This profile examines specific roles and activities. It does not establish that an entire profession is reserved for people.

Compare chosen decision support with personal-assistance services.

HBC analysis

Why preserve a human role here?

Possible justification
An AI tool might explain a form; that is different from entrusting someone with interpreting your wishes. The case for a human role can rest on accountable relationships and a person’s choice of help, rather than an assumption that every person is safer than every machine. Test whether the arrangement expands the person’s own choices.
Strongest objection considered
The UN disability-rights committee’s General Comment No. 1, paragraph 29, calls for support based on the person’s will and preferences, affordable access and a right to refuse, change or end support. Use that standard to question gatekeeping, delay and supporter dominance; this is not a finding that the Brazilian mechanism complies with or violates the Convention.
Who might benefit or be excluded
Ask whose preferred supporters are recognised, whose communication is accepted, who can obtain independent help and whose time is unpaid. Do not assume relatives are safe, all assistance is unpaid or recipient protection justifies neglecting supporters’ working conditions.
Resources and costs to investigate
Compare access to trusted help with time, costs, accessible communication, independent advice and workable ways to change an arrangement. No measured budget, waiting time or wages are estimated.
An alternative to compare
Compare informal voluntary support, a recognised chosen-support arrangement and an independent human advice service. Test where AI assistance expands a person’s choices and where it weakens accountability or control.
What to check before using this elsewhere
Identify who chooses, who can refuse, what decisions remain theirs, who resolves conflict and how support ends. Test safeguards against both abuse and unjustified substitution. A relational role is not proof that AI should never be used.
Evidence that could change the assessment
Trace completed cases in which a person’s expressed choice prevailed despite disagreement, and cases of delay, refusal or unwanted influence. Accessible assistance achieving equal autonomy at lower burden would weaken a more restrictive design.

These are HBC’s judgments and questions for further research. They do not show actual benefits or costs, establish workers’ preferences or authorise us to speak for affected people.

Three questions about the effects

People’s say and decision-making power
Can affected people get useful information, make choices, challenge a failure or help shape a collective decision?
Income and economic power
Who receives pay or bargaining power, who bears costs and who is excluded?
Access to human services
Can people who need a human obtain one, including those outside a service or contract?

We have not evaluated results across all three aims for any example. A written duty, payment or right to review does not show whether these aims are achieved.

Questions that need more research

  • Trace a completed request, disagreement and termination: who expressed the choice, what happened and how long did it take?
  • Compare access for people with and without trusted networks, including independent support and who pays.
  • Examine whether a proposed AI tool helps the person communicate their wishes or shifts authority to someone else.

Sources and versions checked

Follow the links to the passages listed below. Sources can change. The date we checked a source does not confirm every later change or whether the rule applies to you.

  1. BR15S

    Brazil Civil Code: chosen support ↗

    Where to look
    Article 1.783-A, caput,§§1–11
    Version checked
    Senado-hosted consolidated text inspected 15 November 2026
  2. CRPD14S

    UN disability-rights committee: legal capacity ↗

    Where to look
    GeneralComment 1(2014), paragraph 29(b),(d)–(g), p 7
    Version checked
    Official UN text inspected 15 November 2026

Back to the map and comparison selection