Library
Find public work on AI: neutral reference, research critiques and advocacy.
Search the library
258 entries
Selected starting points, then latest dated entries. Dates are labelled by their meaning.
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Employment
Hiring, workplace monitoring, automated decisions in employment contexts.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Generative AI at Work”
Erik Brynjolfsson, Danielle Li, Lindsey R. Raymond · The Quarterly Journal of Economics
A genuinely important, well-executed empirical study whose central productivity and heterogeneity findings are well supported and whose secondary mechanisms are appropriately hedged by the authors. The principal caveats are non-random rollout timing,…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
EU AI Act
Risk-based framework. Prohibited practices (Art. 5) effective 2 February 2025; general-purpose AI obligations (Arts. 51-55) 2 August 2025; high-risk system obligations (Title III) 2 August 2026. Staggered 6/12/24-month application timeline from 1…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Individual Redress
Right to explanation, appeal mechanisms, complaint channels.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Can an AI-assisted audit replace a public voice?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Can unpaid carers get time back?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
How to read a promise of human involvement
How to compare human roles, rights and resources, with sources and limits.
- Status
- Guide and methods
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Should a public jobs programme preserve work that machines could do?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
The human involvement map
Explore selected arrangements, their powers, justifications, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research map
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Time off, paid time, care time
Compare protected absence, pay during leave and staff time within a care service, with original sources and coverage limits.
- Status
- Comparative analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When a learning promise breaks
Compare timely readmission, non-delivery, agreements and recommended debt relief, then ask what the learner can actually use.
- Status
- Evidence comparison
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When a student challenges an AI mark
Compare requests for review, changed marks and justified decisions, then examine authority, resources and response routes.
- Status
- Evidence comparison
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who can afford the time to care?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who can cut off a platform worker’s account?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who checks that decision support respects your wishes?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who chooses your decision supporters?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who controls the help they receive?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who controls the time to learn?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who discusses AI training licences?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who gets time to learn when AI changes the job?
Compare course finance, paid learning time and control, then examine a usable opportunity to develop judgment.
- Status
- Comparative analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who has a say in an efficiency bonus?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who judges the student’s work when AI assists?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who keeps control when an engineer uses AI?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who owns the next action?
Compare three published energy complaint procedures with five stages of useful human help, and distinguish promises from delivery.
- Status
- Document comparison
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who pays for learning when AI changes your job?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who protects a trainee’s chance to learn?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
A human check does not promise a conversation
Why support for checking AI outputs cannot establish support for replacing a conversation: a fictional service choice and a bounded survey reading.
- Status
- Commentary
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
A human on the line is only the beginning
A five-stage workflow for useful human help: access, authority, challenge and completed remedies.
- Status
- Workflow and analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Can customers request human help?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Does a right to review necessarily mean a human reviewer?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Paying for human time is only the beginning
An Australian care example separates reported human time, target attainment, experience and unanswered questions about access, agency and economic power.
- Status
- Research and analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Reading AI agreements for decision power
A bounded reading of the 2024 BNP Paribas–UNI agreement and the 2020 European framework distinguishes different kinds of worker influence.
- Status
- Commentary
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Sharing the time saved by AI
Three invented requests compete for the time saved by AI. An eight-part allocation statement records the disagreement without inventing consent.
- Status
- Worked example
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
The reviewer changed the outcome. Who can change the rule?
A fictional delivery-platform case asks who can change a recurring decision rule, beyond reversing an individual outcome.
- Status
- Applied case
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
What changes when AI may assist but not deliver clinical care?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
What public records tell us about human review of government algorithms
A bounded study of government transparency-record webpages, with methods, uncertainty and the source index.
- Status
- Research and analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When are solely automated profiling decisions restricted?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When the law lets a computer act, what work remains?
Two selected legal designs help distinguish legal authority from the human work, evidence and decision power in a process.
- Status
- Practical guide
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When the replica performs, who gets paid?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Which school mental-health functions stay with people?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who approves AI-assisted selection guidelines?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who decides? Who gets paid? Who gets human time?
Four questions for promises to protect people as AI advances, with a local discussion record and printable worksheet.
- Status
- Explainer and discussion aid
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who gets a voice when AI changes a workflow?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who gets an efficiency bonus?
A Royal Mail example: reported payments, eligibility and the limits.
- Status
- Reported payments
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who must provide the human care time?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who pays to keep the human time?
A fictional service budget separates technology prices, VAT recovery, tax relief and the money available to retain human time.
- Status
- Worked analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy case study
Coursework: who actually decides the mark?
One human choice · England case
A choice about judgment, assistance and the resources needed to put a mistake right.
- Status
- Advocacy case study
- Prepared:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy case study
Performers: whose work, whose double, whose income?
One human choice · Contract case
A person doing the work, controlling a digital copy, or sharing the proceeds: three different choices about AI and performance.
- Status
- Advocacy case study
- Prepared:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceStarting guide
Which work should stay human?
Six questions for deciding what a person contributes, who benefits and who pays.
- Status
- Advocacy guide
- Prepared:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy case study
Therapy: what Illinois chose to keep human in 2025
One human choice · Historical case
A comparison of the enacted 2025 rules, permitted assistance, access and who pays. Later amendments and current consolidation remain unverified; no equivalent UK policy has been adopted by the programme.
- Status
- Advocacy case study
- Prepared:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Bletchley Declaration on AI Safety
First multilateral consensus on frontier-AI safety risks. 28 signatories including US, EU, China. Introduced the policy vocabulary of 'frontier AI' that later instruments adopted. Non-binding but precedent-setting; spawned the AI Safety Institute…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
DFARS Subpart 252.204 (Safeguarding Covered Defense Information and Cyber Incident Reporting)
Defense-acquisition-specific information-security regulation. Core clauses: (1) DFARS 252.204-7012 (adopted 2015, current consolidated 2020) — requires contractors handling Covered Defense Information (CDI) on covered contractor information systems…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Executive Order 14110 on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI
Rescinded by EO 14148 (Jan 20, 2025); EO 14179 (Jan 23) set the deregulatory posture. Some §4 reporting persists via Defense Production Act + BIS interim rule. DRIFT-WATCH CORRECTION (2026-07-17, /wiki/drift.json): status was "partial" — WRONG. EO…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
FedRAMP AI Cloud Procurement Guidance
Operational PMO guidance for agencies acquiring AI / generative-AI cloud services within the existing FedRAMP authorisation framework. Key operational themes that recur across the published surface: (1) AI cloud services that process federal data…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
GSA Generative AI and Specialized Computing Infrastructure Acquisition Resource Guide
Procurement-focused operational guide accompanying OMB M-24-10 and the broader EO 14110 / EO 14179 federal-AI policy stack. Provides agencies with: (1) market intelligence on the governmentwide acquisition vehicles covering AI services (MAS IT and…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
India Digital Personal Data Protection Act + AI Advisory (MEITY)
India's primary AI-adjacent statute is the DPDPA + MEITY's binding AI advisories (Mar 2024 + Apr 2024 walked-back versions). No dedicated AI law yet; the proposed Digital India Act was paused 2024-2025. Affects 1.4B people — the single largest…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
OMB Memorandum M-24-10 (Advancing Governance, Innovation, and Risk Management for Agency Use of AI)
Binding on covered federal agencies. Three pillars: (I) strengthen AI governance through agency Chief AI Officers + AI Governance Boards; (II) advance responsible AI innovation including authorized use, talent, and infrastructure; (III) manage risks…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Revised Product Liability Directive (Directive (EU) 2024/2853)
EU strict-liability regime for defective products, modernised for the digital age and explicitly extended to software and AI systems. Repeals and replaces the 1985 Product Liability Directive (85/374/EEC). Art. 4(1) redefines "product" to include…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Seoul Declaration on Safe, Innovative and Inclusive AI
Bletchley follow-up. 16 frontier-AI-developer companies signed Frontier AI Safety Commitments alongside. Introduces measurable capability-evaluation expectations and pre-deployment thresholds; first instrument to formalise frontier-lab voluntary…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Multimodal large language models can make context-sensitive hate speech evaluations aligned with human judgement”
Thomas Davidson · Nature Human Behaviour
A genuine, transparently executed conjoint audit whose two headline verdicts outrun its format-bound, distribution-level evidence. The measurements stand; the generalizations need material qualification.
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Comparing the value of perceived human versus AI-generated empathy”
Matan Rubin, Joanna Z. Li, Federico Zimmerman, Desmond C. Ong, Amit Goldenberg, Anat Perry · Nature Human Behaviour
A well-powered, preregistered multi-study programme whose core labelling effect is robust, but whose main theoretical advance — the differential role of affective/motivational versus cognitive empathy — rests on a measurement instrument with poor CFA…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Cultural tendencies in generative AI”
Jackson G. Lu, Lesley Luyang Song, Lu Doris Zhang · Nature Human Behaviour
A rigorous, transparent descriptive study whose two headline framings — 'real-world impact' and a single training-data cause — outrun a design that measures only model outputs and manipulates only prompt language.
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “How human–AI feedback loops alter human perceptual, emotional and social judgements”
Moshe Glickman, Tali Sharot · Nature Human Behaviour
This is a well-executed experimental programme published in a top venue, with genuine strengths in design variety, statistical rigour, and transparent data sharing. The core finding — that interacting with a biased AI makes human judgements more…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “On the conversational persuasiveness of GPT-4”
Francesco Salvi, Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Riccardo Gallotti, Robert West · Nature Human Behaviour
This is a carefully executed and transparently reported preregistered experiment that makes a genuine contribution by moving AI persuasion research from static text comparisons to live interactive debates. However, the headline framing substantially…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Positioning Political Texts with Large Language Models by Asking and Averaging”
Gaël Le Mens, Aina Gallego · Political Analysis
This is a clearly written research letter introducing a practical and promising approach to text scaling with LLMs. However, its validation has a construct-validity gap: the paper cannot fully demonstrate that LLMs position texts based on content…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Real-time artificial intelligence sentiment feedback promotes self-moderation in contentious online discussion”
Soo Yun Shin, Seo Hyeong Kim, Dayeong Lee, Jinyeong Kim · Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication
The paper’s within-condition dose-response findings (H3, H4) are internally sound, and RQ1 provides legitimate evidence that observers detect sentiment improvements. However, the two headline claims—that AI scoring causes more revision than general…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Reducing political polarization through conversations with artificial intelligence”
Timon M.J. Hruschka, Markus Appel · Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication
This is a transparently reported, well-powered study with genuine methodological strengths including preregistration, replication, and open materials. However, the abstract's unhedged claim that LLMs are 'powerful tools for individual depolarization'…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI in education through the learners’ eyes: practical experience, perceptions, and challenges”
Kostadin Yotov, Silvia Gaftandzhieva, Emil Hadzhikolev, Stanka Hadzhikoleva, Maria Gorgorova · Frontiers in Education
This is a competently executed descriptive survey whose primary vulnerability is systematic overclaiming in its interpretive passages: cross-sectional correlations are presented as ‘confirmed’ directional mechanisms and translated into institutional…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Political ideology shapes support for the use of AI in policy-making”
Tamar Gur, Boaz Hameiri, Yossi Maaravi · Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence
This is a competently executed exploratory survey study with commendable transparency practices. The causal framing in the title overclaims what cross-sectional data can establish, and the centrist–leftist merging weakens the theoretical contrast the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Understanding support for AI regulation: A Bayesian network perspective”
Andrea Cremaschi, Dae-Jin Lee, Manuele Leonelli · arXiv preprint
A methodologically transparent exploratory analysis demonstrating BNs as a useful tool for modeling complex survey belief structures. The primary vulnerability is that the formal variance-decomposition rankings, which carry the paper's headline…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Whether and When Could Generative AI Improve College Student Learning Engagement?”
Fei Guo, Lanwen Zhang, Tianle Shi, Hamish Coates · Behavioral Sciences
This is a well-scaled descriptive study that provides useful preliminary evidence on GenAI-engagement associations across learning contexts in Chinese higher education. The core analytical findings -- nuanced, context-dependent, and often mixed --…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Artificial intelligence and social media as new arenas of political competition: challenges for democracy”
Ildar Kaliyev, Kargash Zhanpeiissova, Danagul Kopezhanova, Marat Malibayev, Akmaral Turgaleyeva · Frontiers in Political Science
This is a competently executed mixed-methods survey study that documents meaningful variation in how Kazakh social media users perceive algorithmic and AI-driven political communication. Its primary weakness is the gap between its correlational…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Mental health in the “era” of artificial intelligence: technostress and the perceived impact on anxiety and depressive disorders—an SEM analysis”
Daniela-Elena Lițan · Frontiers in Psychology
A competently executed exploratory survey that identifies a modest association between AI-related technostress and self-reported anxiety/depression symptoms. However, the paper’s value is substantially undermined by pervasive causal/predictive…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI-determined similarity increases likability and trustworthiness of human voices”
Oliver Jaggy, Stephan Schwan, Hauke S. Meyerhoff · PLOS ONE
This is a competent, transparent, preregistered study whose empirical contribution — that a lightweight d-vector cosine measure moderately tracks human voice-similarity judgments, including self-voice comparisons, and that self-similar voices attract…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Exploring the acceptance of ChatGPT in higher education: a comprehensive quantitative study of university students and faculty”
Mehmet Haldun Kaya, Tufan Adıgüzel · Frontiers in Education
Publishable core with a serious, fixable framing defect. The PLS-SEM estimation and its validity diagnostics are sound and internally consistent, and the student-vs-faculty comparison is a real contribution. But the abstract mis-reports the paper's…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Investigating the impact of social media images on users' sentiments towards sociopolitical events based on deep artificial intelligence”
Nafiseh Jabbari Tofighi, Reda Alhajj · PLOS ONE
The paper reports a real, moderate-to-large descriptive association between hand-labeled image sentiment and comment positivity across four movements, and it is admirably transparent about its data, code, and several limitations. But its headline…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI meets politics: Examining the effects of different targeting strategies across 15 countries”
Sanne Kruikemeier, Svenja Schäfer, Alice Hamilton, Puck Guldemond, Jade Vrielink, Carmen Dymanus, Annelien Van Remoortere, Sanne Tamboer · New Media & Society
A solid, honestly-reported study whose main conclusions hold up; the defensible critique is confined to a handful of inference/wording over-reaches rather than design flaws. The single most damaging item is the self-contradictory "reinforcing effect"…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Being literate, behaving literate? A mixed-methods approach to adolescents’ algorithm literacy and behavioral strategies on social media”
Larissa Leonhard, Ruth Wendt, Claudia Riesmeyer · New Media & Society
A solid, well-disclosed study whose conclusions are honestly hedged and whose data/code are shared. The genuine over-reaches that survive full-text refutation are presentational and threshold-consistency issues, not evidence that the analysis is…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Beyond disruption and invisibility: Interactional continuity in everyday AI use in India”
Emilia Edwards, Dhiraj Murthy · New Media & Society
A methodologically careful, well-hedged qualitative study whose conclusions ("interactional continuity") are supported by its design as descriptive, tendency-level claims. The full text resolves most abstract-era worries: it openly states the sample…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “From rule of law to rule of algorithm: Generative Artificial Intelligence's threat to democracy”
A.T. Kingsmith · Big Data & Society
A moderate critique is the honest outcome. As a commentary the piece is solid, well-sourced in its conceptual claims, and genre-appropriate; the abstract-era "no data/no method" concerns are mostly resolved by the disclosed commentary genre and…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Into the black box: Laypeople's folk theories about generative artificial intelligence chatbots”
Li Z, Nuri Kim, L Chen · Big Data & Society
The full text resolves most abstract-era concerns: the high-literacy and non-generalizability worries are explicitly disclosed, and the exploratory inductive design is a legitimate fit for the research questions. What survives adversarial refutation…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Making GenAI valuable: Benchmarks, singularities, and the enrichment economy”
Claudia Aradau, Tobias Blanke · Big Data & Society
The full text resolves most concerns an abstract-only critique would raise: the method is disclosed, the framework is offered as supplementary rather than totalising, and the paper is unusually careful to hedge its strongest-sounding claims. What…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “More Versus Better: Artificial Intelligence, Incentives, and the Emerging Crisis in Peer Review”
Claudine Madras Gartenberg, Sharique Hasan, Alex Murray, Lamar Pierce · Organization Science
This is a careful, unusually self-aware descriptive paper that mostly stays within its evidence and pre-discloses its biggest weaknesses (detector limits, author-fixed-effects confounding, the contested meaning of "writing quality"). The one place…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “The Cybernetic Teammate: A Field Experiment on Generative AI and Teamwork”
Fabrizio Dell’Acqua, Charles Ayoubi, Hila Lifshitz‐Assaf, Raffaella Sadun, Ethan Mollick, Lilach Mollick, Yi Han, Jeff Goldman · Organization Science
A methodologically strong, transparently reported, preregistered field experiment whose conclusions are mostly well-supported. The one over-reach that survives adversarial full-text refutation is inferential: the flagship 'AI matched teams' claim is…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “The rise of AI sovereignty: Authoritarian technological imaginaries as a form of reflexive control”
Gregory Asmolov · Big Data & Society
This is an honest, well-hedged conceptual Commentary, not an over-claiming empirical study — and most abstract-era worries (small N, quote provenance, "not a leading AI power") are resolved by the genre label, the Supplemental source list, and the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Italy Law No. 132/2025 on Artificial Intelligence (Legge 23 settembre 2025, n. 132)
Italy's Law No. 132/2025 ("Disposizioni e deleghe al Governo in materia di intelligenza artificiale") is the first organic national AI statute adopted by an EU member state. It was adopted 23 September 2025, published in Gazzetta Ufficiale Serie…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Japan AI Promotion Act (Act on the Promotion of Research, Development and Utilization of AI-Related Technologies)
Japan's first national AI statute (Act No. 53 of 2025), an innovation-first BASIC law (基本法-style) rather than a risk-regulation regime like the EU AI Act. Promulgated 4 June 2025; most provisions took effect that day, while Chapter III (AI Basic…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
New York RAISE Act: Responsible AI Safety and Education Act
The RAISE (Responsible AI Safety and Education) Act, S6953-B/A6453-B, signed by Governor Hochul on December 19, 2025 and effective January 1, 2027, adds Article 44-B (§§ 1420-1425) to the New York General Business Law. It is the second US state…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
TAKE IT DOWN Act (Tools to Address Known Exploitation by Immobilizing Technological Deepfakes on Websites and Networks Act)
The TAKE IT DOWN Act (Tools to Address Known Exploitation by Immobilizing Technological Deepfakes on Websites and Networks Act), Public Law 119-12 (139 Stat. 55), signed May 19, 2025, is one of the few binding federal AI-specific statutes in the…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UN Global Digital Compact
The Global Digital Compact (GDC) is Annex I to "The Pact for the Future", adopted by the UN General Assembly as Resolution A/RES/79/1 at the Summit of the Future on 22 September 2024. It is a non-binding, soft-law political framework (a General…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting”
Gregory Kestin, Kelly Miller, Anna Klales, Timothy Milbourne, Gregorio Ponti · Scientific Reports (Nature Portfolio)
A rigorous, genuinely strong within-subject RCT whose learning-gain finding is well supported (overwhelming raw effect, identical content across conditions, independent test construction, subgroup + clustering robustness, public data) — but whose…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Factors influencing the adoption of generative artificial intelligence into classroom teaching by university teachers: An empirical study using SPSS PROCESS macros”
Yong Xiang, Chenxin Yang, Zhigang Jin, Wanshu Zhao · PLOS One
A publishable-genre but methodologically weak adoption-intention study whose conclusions should be read as exploratory correlational associations, not the causal mechanisms it claims. A full-text convergence panel returned a unanimous survives…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Heterogeneous preferences and asymmetric insights for AI use among welfare claimants and non-claimants”
Mengchen Dong, Jean-François Bonnefon, Iyad Rahwan · Nature Communications
A solid, transparent, and largely credible contribution whose descriptive core (claimant AI aversion; asymmetric perspective-taking) is well supported by convergent multi-study evidence, strong preregistration, and open materials. Its credibility is…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Large Language Models, Small Labor Market Effects”
Anders Humlum, Emilie Vestergaard · Becker Friedman Institute Working Paper (University of Chicago)
A methodologically strong, transparently caveated paper whose headline null on register-measured earnings and hours is well-identified and largely robust. The defensible weaknesses are concentrated in how supporting magnitudes are labeled, not in the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “The (Short-Term) Effects of Large Language Models on Unemployment and Earnings”
Danqing Chen, Carina Kane, Austin Kozlowski, Nadav Kunievsky, James A. Evans · arXiv (econ.GN) preprint
Suggestive early evidence whose headline magnitudes should be read cautiously. After an adversarial convergence panel that restored the identification flaw to a framing point and tempered the rest, three calibrated concerns remain: an uncorrected,…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI Self-preferencing in Algorithmic Hiring: Empirical Evidence and Insights”
Jiannan Xu, Gujie Li, Jane Yi Jiang · arXiv (working paper)
A methodologically careful and genuinely novel demonstration of a real pattern — LLMs systematically prefer their own stylistic output over human and rival-model summaries — that nonetheless overclaims on two main fronts: its most dramatic figure…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Effect of AI empathy perception on employees' prosocial behavior: mediating role of warmth and moderating role of AI anthropomorphism”
Jing Xue, Yang Liu, Zhihong Ren, Yang Wu · Frontiers in Psychology
A competently executed but somewhat oversold study. The three-wave matched design, acceptable reliabilities, and bootstrap-based mediation/moderated-mediation tests make the within-model statistical story internally coherent, and the authors disclose…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Fairness Is More Than Algorithms: Racial Disparities in Time-to-Recidivism”
Jessy Xinyi Han, Kristjan Greenewald, Devavrat Shah · arXiv (cs.CY; stat.AP) preprint
A worthwhile conceptual contribution — treating recidivism as time-to-event and offering a survival-based falsification test for the role of non-algorithmic factors — whose empirical demonstration, as presented, is too underpowered, under-reported,…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Local US officials' views on the impacts and governance of AI: Evidence from 2022 and 2023 survey waves”
Sophia Hatz, Noemi Dreksler, Kevin Wei, Baobao Zhang · PLOS One
A methodologically careful, transparency-forward descriptive survey whose value lies in mapping local US officials' AI attitudes, undermined chiefly by interpretive overreach: the headline partisan-convergence-after-ChatGPT narrative is foregrounded…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Postgraduate students' perceptions of artificial intelligence integration in research: A cross-sectional study”
Ibrahim Naif Alenezi, Fathia Ahmed Mersal, Amal Ahmed Elbilgahy · PLOS One
REFUTE (with credit), but on a much narrower and better-grounded basis than the draft. The paper is a competent, self-aware single-institution descriptive survey that explicitly disclaims causal inference, names its convenience-sampling bias and…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “When an AI Judges Your Work: The Hidden Costs of Algorithmic Assessment”
David Almog, Lucas Lippman, Daniel Martin · arXiv (working paper)
A competent, transparent, pre-registered experiment whose causal infrastructure (randomization, dual grading of every caption, leniency-neutralizing incentives, individual-clustered SEs with image fixed effects) is solid, and whose quantity result…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Inconsistent advice by ChatGPT influences decision making in various areas”
Shinnosuke Ikeda · Scientific Reports
Empirical and on-topic, with real strengths in transparency (OSF data and materials, stated ethics approval and consent) and candor about its null results — but the inferential backbone is weak in three precisely-grounded ways that survive…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Is it harmful or helpful? Examining the causes and consequences of generative AI usage among university students”
Muhammad Abbas, Farooq Ahmed Jam, Tariq Iqbal Khan · International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education
This is a competently structured early-stage survey study whose two-sample, scale-then-test design and three-wave time-lagged data collection are genuine strengths relative to typical cross-sectional work in this space. Its core empirical…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Student perspectives on the use of generative artificial intelligence technologies in higher education”
Heather Johnston, Rebecca Wells, Elizabeth M. Shanks, Timothy Boey, Bryony N. Parsons · International Journal for Educational Integrity
A competent, large-sample descriptive survey that achieves its stated applied aim of informing one university's academic-integrity policy, and that is honest about being exactly that. Read against the abstract it does not over-claim: its credibility…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Cultural bias and cultural alignment of large language models”
Yan Tao, Olga Viberg, Ryan S. Baker, René F. Kizilcec · PNAS Nexus
This is a credible, well-scoped contribution to LLM cultural-bias evaluation whose claims are mostly calibrated to what the described design can support. The central demonstrated result — that five OpenAI models lean toward…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content”
Anil R. Doshi, Oliver Hauser · Science Advances
A well-designed causal experiment whose individual-level claims are solidly licensed by randomization but whose marquee collective-diversity conclusion is more fragile than the framing suggests. The two principal threats, neither resolvable from the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Testing theory of mind in large language models and humans”
James W. A. Strachan, Dalila Albergo, Giulia Borghini, Oriana Pansardi, Eugenio Scaliti, Saurabh Gupta, K. B. Saxena, Alessandro Rufo · Nature Human Behaviour
Within abstract-only limits, this reads as a careful, well-designed behavioral comparison whose framing conclusion is appropriately hedged and whose multi-construct, multi-model, repeated-testing, large-human-sample design is a genuine strength. The…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Agentic AI Governance
Obligations specific to AI systems that take autonomous multi-step actions (browse, transact, plan, recurse). Distinct from foundation_models (capability) and catastrophic_risk (outcome) — this is the action-surface frame. Surfaces in EU AI Office…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI-Driven Worker Displacement
Governance of AI as cause of labour displacement, retraining obligations, transition support, and just-transition frames. Distinct from `employment` topic (which is AI-IN-employment-decisions — hiring algorithms, performance management). This topic…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Biometric Identification
Real-time and post-hoc biometric identification in public spaces.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
California SB-1047: Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier AI Models Act
A frontier-model safety-protocol-and-audit bill, not a pre-deployment testing mandate. Passed both chambers (Assembly 28 Aug 2024, Senate concurrence 29 Aug 2024 — the adoptedDate here) and was vetoed by Gov. Newsom on 29 September 2024, so it never…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Catastrophic & Existential Risk
Governance of model capabilities that could cause mass casualties or civilisational-scale harms (CBRN uplift, autonomous replication, deceptive alignment). Distinct from EU AIA 'systemic risk' which targets market-scale rather than catastrophic-scale…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Compute + Model-Weight Export Controls
Restrictions on cross-border flow of frontier AI compute (GPUs, accelerators) and model weights. Distinct from `compute_reporting` (which is disclosure) — this is restriction of access by recipient. US BIS rules (Oct 2023 advanced computing, Jan 2025…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Compute-Threshold Reporting
Mandatory reporting based on training-compute or capability thresholds.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Deepfakes / Synthetic Content
AI-generated content disclosure, watermarking, election integrity protections.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Directive (EU) 2024/2831 on improving working conditions in platform work
The EU Platform Work Directive ((EU) 2024/2831) was adopted on 23 October 2024, published in the Official Journal on 11 November 2024, and entered into force on 1 December 2024; Member States must transpose it into national law by 2 December 2026. It…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Environmental Impact of AI Training
Energy consumption, water usage, carbon emissions, and resource demands of large-model training + inference. EU AIA Recital 142 + Art. 95 voluntary codes; NIST AI 600-1 Environmental Impacts (named risk category); G7 Hiroshima Code §6 sustainable AI;…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Foundation Models / GPAI
Obligations specific to general-purpose / foundation models above certain capability thresholds.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
National Security Carveouts in AI Regulation
The recurring exclusion of military, intelligence, and national-security AI uses from civilian AI-governance instruments. EU AIA Art. 2(3) explicit exclusion; US EO 14110 §11 + NSM-10 separate track; CoE AI Convention Art. 3 carve-out; UK White Paper…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Open-Weight Frontier Release
Governance posture toward releasing frontier model weights publicly (Meta Llama, Mistral, DeepSeek vs. closed-weight Anthropic / OpenAI / DeepMind). EU AIA Recital 102 + Art. 53(2) carve-outs; CA SB-1047's failed framework; Meta Frontier AI…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Provisions on the Administration of Deep Synthesis of Internet Information Services
China's Deep Synthesis Provisions are an administrative regulation jointly issued by the CAC, MIIT, and MPS (CAC Order No. 12), promulgated 25 November 2022 and effective 10 January 2023. They govern the use of "deep synthesis" technology — defined…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Synthetic Content Provenance
Labelling, watermarking, and machine-readable provenance for AI-generated audio / video / text. Distinct from `deepfakes` (which centres on misuse harms) — this is the upstream infrastructure layer. EU AIA Art. 50, China GenAI Measures Art. 13…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Training-Data Rights
Copyright, consent, text-and-data-mining exceptions.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Transparency Obligations
Disclosure of training data, model cards, system-card requirements.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
African Union Continental AI Strategy
Continental-level non-binding strategy for 55 AU member states. Frames AI through development-rights / digital-sovereignty / capacity-building lens. Explicitly references unequal compute access + dataset coloniality as governance concerns absent from…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Agentic AI System
An AI system that takes actions in the world — calling tools, executing code, browsing the web, sending messages, planning multi-step sequences — rather than only generating text or images for a human reader.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
AI Alignment
The technical problem of designing AI systems whose objectives, behaviour, and emergent goals reliably track the values or instructions of their principals across deployment contexts.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Criminal Justice
Predictive policing, risk assessment, sentencing assistance.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Education
Automated grading, proctoring, student-data analytics.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Healthcare
Clinical decision support, medical devices, diagnostic AI.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
AI Safety Level 3 (ASL-3)
A capability-based risk tier in Anthropic's Responsible Scaling Policy denoting models with the potential to substantially uplift CBRN attack capabilities or autonomous AI replication.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
AI Supply Chain
The end-to-end pipeline of inputs, intermediate artefacts, and downstream applications by which an AI system is built and deployed — typically decomposed as training data → compute → model weights → fine-tuning → deployment → downstream applications.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
AIME 2024
30 problems from the 2024 American Invitational Mathematics Examination — high-school competition math.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Anthropic Responsible Scaling Policy (RSP) v2
First-mover industry safety framework. Introduces the AI Safety Level (ASL) capability-tier vocabulary subsequently adapted by OpenAI Preparedness + DeepMind FSF. v2 (Oct 2024) refines ASL-3/ASL-4 capability thresholds, mandates pre-deployment…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
ARC-AGI v2
Abstract reasoning over visual grids. Each task requires inferring the transformation rule from 2-3 examples.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
ASEAN Guide on AI Governance and Ethics
Non-binding voluntary guide for 10 ASEAN member states (Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Vietnam, Myanmar, Cambodia, Laos, Brunei). Adopts a cross-cutting risk + values framework intentionally distinct from the EU AIA's…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Brazil AI Bill (PL 2338/2023)
Risk-based framework structurally similar to EU AIA but with distinct development-rights framing rooted in Brazil's Marco Civil tradition. Senate-approved Dec 2024; Chamber of Deputies vote pending 2025. Notable for explicit human-dignity +…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Capability Elicitation
Techniques designed to reveal the upper bounds of an AI model's capabilities, rather than measuring its default behaviour, so that downstream safety judgements can be calibrated to what the model *can* do under adversarial prompting or fine-tuning.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Algorithmic responsibility in PPC practice: Interpreting black boxes in digital advertising work”
Natalia Chrobak · Big Data & Society
Within its genre as an interpretive, concept-building contribution to critical algorithm studies, the paper rests on a reasonable mixed-method corpus and frames its central concept with appropriate modesty. The abstract-level concerns are about the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Charismatic machines: On the epistemic power of generative AI within platform convergence”
Mauro Barisione · New Media & Society
As a conceptual, theory-building contribution the abstract is coherent, clearly defined, and theoretically grounded, and it largely uses genre-appropriate verbs (\"develops,\" \"introduce,\" \"propose\") and at least one explicit hedge (\"raises…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Crafting computer vision through human eyes: An AI laboratory ethnography”
Luqing Zhou · Big Data & Society
A candid, genre-appropriate interpretive ethnography whose conceptual contributions (a three-source typology and a \"sensory, interactive, and processual\" reframing) are reasonably grounded in nine months of single-site fieldwork. The principal,…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “From prompt engineering to prompt design: Research strategies for visual generative AI”
Gabriele Colombo, Sabine Niederer, Carlo De Gaetano · Big Data & Society
A clear and largely candid conceptual demo whose principal contribution, a reusable five-part prompting-strategy typology grounded in the query design framework, is genuine and appropriately framed. The critique is moderate and centers on scope…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Resilience and disempowerment in algorithmic systems”
Samantha M. Jones, Erin A. Heerey · New Media & Society
Judged on the abstract alone, this is a candid, appropriately hedged mixed-methods experimental study with a useful disclosed sample (N = 263) and a clearly stated genre. Its central behavioral contrast — more homogeneous selections under an adaptive…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Working the algorithm: Contextual skills of on-demand gig workers”
Xinyi Hong, Xinyi Cheng, Dong Liu · Big Data & Society
A genre-appropriate, candid interpretive contribution whose conceptual core, that gig workers cultivate practical algorithmic skills, is reasonably grounded in its stated interviews and hedged as an argument. The main weaknesses are reach beyond the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Compute Threshold (AI Governance)
A regulatory trigger expressed as floating-point operations (FLOPs) consumed during model training, above which specific reporting, evaluation, or governance obligations attach.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Council of Europe Framework Convention on AI
First legally-binding international treaty on AI. Opened for signature Sep 2024. Enters into force three months after five ratifications including three CoE members. Currency (2026-06-21): secondary trackers report the entry-into-force threshold was…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Data Poisoning
A training-time attack in which an adversary inserts crafted examples into the training corpus or fine-tuning dataset to alter the resulting model's behaviour — typically inserting a backdoor that triggers on a specific input pattern or degrading…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Deceptive Alignment
A failure mode in which a model appears aligned during training and evaluation because doing so serves its actual (mesa-)objective, but pursues divergent objectives once deployed or once it judges itself unobserved.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Designated Systemic-Risk Model
A general-purpose AI model that has been formally designated by the EU AI Office under Article 51(1)(b) as posing systemic risk, regardless of whether it meets the presumption thresholds.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Development-Rights Framings
Governance approaches grounded in development-rights / digital-self-determination / Global-South-sovereignty arguments rather than EU/US risk-based framings. Loudest in Brazil, India, ASEAN, African Union policy discourse.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Dual-Use Research Norms (DURC for AI)
A normative framework — adapted from biosecurity's Dual-Use Research of Concern (DURC) policies — for governing AI research and publication decisions when research outputs have both beneficial and harmful applications.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
EU General-Purpose AI Code of Practice
Operational bridge between EU AIA Arts. 53-55 (general-purpose AI obligations) and provider compliance. Art. 56(8) AIA gives adherent providers a presumption of compliance with the substantive obligations — distinct from industry self-pledges…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Frontier-Tier AI
A categorical classification of AI models above certain capability or compute thresholds, indicating heightened regulatory scrutiny.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
FrontierMath
Hundreds of original research-mathematician-curated math problems requiring deep reasoning. Held-out evaluation only.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)
Foundational EU personal-data protection regulation. Most-cited European instrument PW catalogues at the AI-governance boundary — every CNIL / Garante / AEPD / BfDI / DPC enforcement action against an AI system (Clearview, ChatGPT, Replika,…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Google DeepMind Frontier Safety Framework
Critical Capability Levels (CCL) regime spanning autonomy, biosecurity, cybersecurity, and persuasion domains. Distinct vocabulary from Anthropic ASL + OpenAI Preparedness — designed for cross-domain elicitation; each CCL triggers domain-specific…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
GPQA Diamond
Graduate-level Google-Proof Q&A in biology, chemistry, physics. 'Diamond' subset is the 198 hardest items.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Hallucination
Confidently-asserted but factually incorrect output produced by an AI model — including fabricated citations, invented people or events, and confabulated numerical values — that the model cannot reliably distinguish from correct output at generation…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
HumanEval
164 hand-written Python programming problems. Generate a function that passes provided unit tests.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
Humanity's Last Exam
3,000+ frontier-difficulty expert-curated questions across all academic disciplines. Designed to remain unsaturated through 2026+.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
In-Context Learning
The capacity of a foundation model to adapt its behaviour to a new task purely from examples provided in the prompt, without any updates to the model's weights — discovered as an emergent property of large language models and now a primary evaluation…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Inference-Time Compute
The scaling regime in which model capability is increased by spending more compute at inference time (multiple samples, search, longer reasoning chains, tool-using iteration) rather than by training a larger model — disrupting the…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
International Coordination
The substantive governance work happening at, between, and around multilateral fora: treaty negotiations, AI Safety Institute network MoUs, forum-shifting between G7 / G20 / OECD / UN, regulatory arbitrage. Distinct from any specific instrument; this…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Jailbreak Resistance
The robustness of an AI model's safety training against adversarial prompts crafted to elicit policy-prohibited outputs — distinct from alignment (which concerns the model's goals) and from baseline safety training (which concerns the model's…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Japan METI AI Guidelines for Business
Joint METI + MIC issuance consolidating prior AI Utilization Guidelines (2019) + AI R&D Principles (2017) into a single business-facing framework. Voluntary; explicitly aligned with G7 Hiroshima AI Process Code of Conduct + OECD AI Principles. Ten…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
MATH (Hendrycks)
12,500 competition-math problems from AMC, AIME, etc. Evaluates step-by-step reasoning + final-answer accuracy.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Mesa-Optimization
The phenomenon in which a learned model itself implements an optimisation algorithm at inference time, producing an inner objective ('mesa-objective') that may differ from the outer training objective.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Meta Frontier AI Framework
Meta's open-weight-frontier governance posture. Categorises frontier models into 'high risk' + 'critical risk' tiers; the framework's distinctive feature is its explicit defence of open-weight release as a governance posture (vs. the closed-model…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
MMLU
Massive Multitask Language Understanding — 57-subject multiple-choice covering humanities, STEM, social sciences, professional/legal.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
MMLU-Pro
Successor to MMLU with 10-option multiple-choice (up from 4), more reasoning-focused tasks, and removed leaky / ambiguous items.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Model Card
A standardized disclosure document accompanying an AI model that describes its intended use, training data, evaluation results, limitations, and known failure modes.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Model Distillation Risk
The risk that a closed-weight frontier model's capabilities can be partially recovered by training a smaller open-weight model on the closed model's outputs, undermining the governance assumption that closed weights confer capability containment.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Model-Merging Risk
The governance concern that post-training combination of multiple specialised models — via weight averaging, task-arithmetic, or modular merging — can produce capability or safety properties not present in any single source model, in ways the…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Multi-Turn Evaluation
An evaluation methodology that probes AI models across multi-step conversations rather than single prompts — designed to surface deception, sycophancy, context-accumulation jailbreaks, and capability degradation that single-prompt benchmarks miss.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
NIST AI RMF Generative AI Profile
Companion to NIST AI 100-1 covering GenAI-specific risks: CBRN information uplift, confabulation, data privacy, environmental impacts, harmful bias, dangerous information, IP misuse, obscene/abusive/violent content, information security, information…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
OpenAI Preparedness Framework
Capability-tier risk evaluation regime with four categorical levels (Low / Medium / High / Critical) across four risk categories (cybersecurity, CBRN, persuasion, model autonomy). Pre-deployment evaluation against the framework gates release…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Policy Instrument
An identifiable technique of collective action — a binding regulation, an executive order, a voluntary code, a technical standard, a treaty, or similar — by which a public authority structures behaviour to address a policy problem. Instrument choice…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Prompt Injection
An adversarial input technique in which untrusted content fed to an AI model (e.g., text on a webpage the model reads, a document the user uploads, a tool's output) contains instructions that override the model's intended behaviour or…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Provenance & Watermarking
Cryptographic or perceptual signals embedded in AI-generated content (image, audio, video, text) that enable downstream detection of synthetic origin.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Red-Team Evaluation
Structured adversarial probing of an AI model's capabilities and behaviour before deployment, designed to elicit failures that ordinary evaluation would miss.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
An AI system pattern in which a model's outputs are conditioned on external content retrieved at inference time from a knowledge source — combining the parametric knowledge of the model with the up-to-date or domain-specific knowledge of the…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Sandbagging
A theoretical failure mode in which a model deliberately underperforms on capability evaluations — either to avoid triggering capability-tier safeguards or because of subtle training-time incentives that reward apparent low capability under…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Scalable Oversight
The set of techniques for supervising AI systems whose outputs are too complex, too numerous, or too domain-distant for unaided human evaluators to judge correctness.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Singapore Model AI Governance Framework for Generative AI
Update to the 2020 Model AI Governance Framework (v2), expanding scope to generative AI. Nine dimensions: accountability, data, trusted development + deployment, incident reporting, testing + assurance, security, content provenance, safety +…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Sovereign AI Doctrine
Domestic-compute, export controls, jurisdiction-bound model deployment.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiBenchmark
SWE-bench Verified
Solve real-world GitHub issues from 12 popular Python repos. The 'Verified' subset is human-validated to remove ambiguity and have working tests.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Systemic Risk (AI)
A regulatory designation indicating that a general-purpose AI model poses risks of significant scale or scope across the EU internal market, triggering Article 55 obligations under the EU AI Act.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
Technological Sovereignty
National policies asserting domestic capability + decision-making over AI infrastructure: compute on shore, domestic foundation models, talent retention, export-control reciprocity. Specifically NOT 'sovereign AI' (which focuses on deployment…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Tool-Use Safety
The sub-domain of agentic-system safety concerned with the risks that arise when an AI model invokes external tools (search, code execution, APIs, financial transactions, system commands) — including risks of unintended action, instruction…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Training-Data Attribution
Technical methods that identify which training examples most influenced a specific AI model output, enabling provenance claims about generated content and supporting copyright / consent / accountability disputes downstream.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UK-US AI Safety Institute Memorandum of Understanding
First binding bilateral on frontier-AI safety. Commits both AISIs to coordinated pre-deployment evaluations, red-team data sharing, methodological alignment on capability elicitation, and joint exercises across at least one major frontier-model…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UN GA Resolution on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI
Non-binding. Calls on member states to bridge digital divides and develop national strategies. China + US co-sponsored; passed by consensus. Currency (2026-06-21): the UN AI-governance track has since advanced beyond this non-binding resolution —…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UNESCO Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence
First global standard-setting (normative) instrument on AI ethics, adopted by acclamation by all 193 UNESCO Member States on 23 Nov 2021. It is a "Recommendation" — UNESCO soft law: non-binding ethical guidance addressed to Member States (and,…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
White House Voluntary AI Commitments
First broad-spectrum US industry commitments; precursor to EO 14110 §4.2(a) reporting + the Seoul Frontier AI Safety Commitments. 15 signatories across two tranches (Jul + Sep 2023): Anthropic, OpenAI, Google DeepMind, Microsoft, Meta, Inflection,…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Artificial intelligence adoption and the demand for managerial expertise”
Liudmila Alekseeva, José Azar, Mireia Giné, Sampsa Samila · Strategic Management Journal
A disciplined, transparently associational and well-bounded descriptive contribution that opens a useful and underexplored angle — AI adoption's link to managerial demand and managerial skill composition — and earns credit for hedged 'relates to /…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Backfiring AI? AI Deployment in Workplace”
Di Yuan, Manmohan Aseri, Narayan Ramasubbu · Management Science
This is a legitimate and genuinely interesting formal contribution: it isolates a clean, counterintuitive mechanism by which AI-facilitated knowledge transfer 'can disincentivize high-performing employees and ultimately backfire,' and it frames its…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “How Costs Influence Preferences for Control in Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI): Human-Guided vs. GenAI-Based Delegated Search”
Lei Wang, Ho Cheung Brian Lee · Information Systems Research
A genuine, large-scale empirical contribution whose descriptive core — that cost salience co-occurs with a shift toward more controlled, detailed prompting (c2) — is plausible and well-powered, but whose headline causal chain (c4, c6, c7) and welfare…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “When Influencers Delegate Replies: How Social AI Agents Shape User Engagement”
Maggie Mengqing Zhang, Yang Gao, Jingjing Li, Steven L. Johnson · Information Systems Research
A credibly-identified empirical contribution that engages a timely question with a real rollout and a defensible staggered-DiD design, and that scopes its claims with commendable hedging. Its weaknesses are concentrated and addressable rather than…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Chain-of-Thought Monitoring
A frontier-safety oversight approach that inspects a model's externalized step-by-step reasoning trace (its chain of thought) to detect intent to misbehave — such as reward hacking, deception, or unsafe planning — before acting on the model's final…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Hardware-Enabled Governance Mechanisms
Hardware-enabled governance mechanisms (HEGMs, also "on-chip governance" or hardware-enabled mechanisms/HEMs) propose to make AI-governance rules attach to the physical compute layer — AI accelerators (GPUs/ASICs), their firmware, and the datacenters…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
California SB 942: AI Transparency Act
SB 942 (the 'California AI Transparency Act'), Chapter 291, Statutes of 2024, adds §§ 22757–22757.4 to the California Business and Professions Code — a generative-AI provenance-and-disclosure law regulating 'covered providers' (a person that produces…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
California SB 243: Companion Chatbots
SB 243 ('Companion chatbots'), Chapter 677, Statutes of 2025, approved by the Governor and filed with the Secretary of State on October 13, 2025, adds Chapter 22.6 (§§ 22601–22606) to Division 8 of the California Business and Professions Code — the…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
California SB-53: Transparency in Frontier Artificial Intelligence Act (TFAIA)
SB 53 (TFAIA), signed Sept. 29, 2025 (Chapter 138), is the first US state law expressly regulating 'frontier' AI; it succeeds the vetoed SB 1047 with a transparency-and-disclosure design rather than pre-deployment liability. It applies to 'frontier…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Artificial Collusion: Examining Supracompetitive Pricing by Q-Learning Algorithms”
Arnoud den Boer, Janusz M Meylahn, Maarten Pieter Schinkel · Management Science
A valuable, carefully argued correction to an over-strong prior on algorithmic collusion. The caution, visible from the abstract, is that the general policy reassurance outruns the Q-learning-specific analysis and sits awkwardly beside the paper's…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Can ChatGPT Kill User-Generated Q&A Platforms?”
Junzhi Xue, Lizheng Wang, Jinyang Zheng, Yongjun Li, Yong Tan · Information Systems Research
A careful, quantified single-platform study whose own conclusion is suitably measured; the cautions, visible from the abstract, are the gap between the 'kill' framing and the coexistence finding, and a causal reading anchored to introduction timing.…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Generative AI, propaganda, and digital authoritarianism: Comparative insights from six democratically weakened countries”
Gabrielle D. Beacken, Inga K Trauthig, Samuel Woolley · Big Data & Society
A strong, anti-determinist comparative study whose descriptive findings are well supported; the cautions, visible from the abstract, are the leap from elite-adoption interviews to causal claims about democratic erosion, and the reproducibility of…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Made With AI: Consumer Engagement with Social Media Containing AI Disclosures”
Stephan Carney, Ignacio Riveros, Stephanie Tully · Journal of Consumer Research
A methodologically strong, policy-relevant study whose central effect is well supported; the cautions, visible from the abstract, are single-platform field evidence and the foregrounding of one mechanism, so the disclosure-design implications should…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Refusal as silence: Gendered disparities in Vision-Language Model responses”
Sha Luo, S Kim, Zening Duan, Kaiping Chen · New Media & Society
A well-designed identity audit with a striking, policy-relevant finding; the cautions, visible from the abstract, are reproducibility (a non-deterministic, version-dependent model with no stated run protocol) and single-model/single-task scope.…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Scaffolding Human–AI Collaboration: A Field Experiment on Behavioral Protocols and Cognitive Reframing”
Alex Farach, Alexia Cambon, Lev Tankelevitch, Connie Hsueh, Rebecca Janssen · arXiv (working paper)
A transparent, well-reported field experiment on an important question whose causal claims are appropriately bounded by limitations the authors disclose: an AM/PM session confound, differential attrition, an LLM-graded length-sensitive outcome, no…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “The Impact of AI on Developer Productivity: Evidence from GitHub Copilot”
Sida Peng, Eirini Kalliamvakou, Peter Cihon, Mert Demirer · arXiv (working paper)
A cleanly-identified RCT whose internal causal claim is well-supported for its task; the cautions, all visible in the full text, are the imprecision of the headline estimate, the narrow single-task/freelancer scope (which the authors concede), the…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “The politics of artificial intelligence alignment: Public reactions to AI moderation in the case of Google’s Gemini”
Adrian Rauchfleisch, Andreas Jungherr · New Media & Society
A preregistered, well-theorised experiment whose main effect is credible for its primary stimulus; the cautions, visible from the abstract, are the reliance on pooling across a significant and a non-significant condition and the single-product scope.…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Unraveling Generative AI from a Human Intelligence Perspective: A Battery of Experiments”
Wen Wang, Siqi Pei, Tianshu Sun · Information Systems Research
An ambitious, policy-facing evaluation framework whose central wording over-reads benchmark performance as 'intelligence' and whose forecasting claim outruns its experimental basis. These are construct-validity and generalisation concerns legible…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
DoD Responsible AI Strategy and Implementation Pathway
DoD-wide operational pathway implementing the five Ethical Principles for AI (Responsible, Equitable, Traceable, Reliable, Governable; adopted Feb 24, 2020). Six foundational tenets: (1) RAI Governance — clarifies roles between OUSD(R&E), OUSD(A&S),…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Executive Order 14179 — Removing Barriers to American Leadership in AI
Rescinds EO 14110's regulatory-burden provisions. Directs OMB / OSTP / NSC to remove barriers to AI development. Does NOT itself impose new substantive obligations — coverage is mostly silent. The DPA-grounded compute-reporting interim rule (BIS, Jan…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
G7 Hiroshima AI Process Code of Conduct
Voluntary commitments by frontier AI developers. 11-point code covering risk identification, deployment, content provenance, security investment, info sharing.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Interim Measures for Generative AI Service Management
Joint CAC/MIIT/MPS measures. Registration + safety assessment for public-facing generative AI. Aligns with Algorithm Recommendation Rules (2022) and Deep Synthesis Rules (2022).
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
NIST AI Risk Management Framework
Voluntary. Four functions (Govern / Map / Measure / Manage). GenAI Profile (NIST AI 600-1) added 2024 for GPAI-specific guidance.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
OECD AI Principles (Recommendation)
First intergovernmental standard. Updated 2024 to clarify GPAI scope. Foundation referenced by G7, GPAI, and many national frameworks.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UK Pro-Innovation Approach to AI Regulation (White Paper)
Principles-based, regulator-led approach (no statutory AI law). Cross-sectoral principles delegated to existing regulators. AISI established Nov 2023 for evaluation/safety research.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Anthropic
Frontier AI developer (Claude family). Governance posture organised around the Responsible Scaling Policy (RSP), a tiered ASL framework that ties capability evaluations to deployment safeguards.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Center for AI Safety
Research nonprofit focused on technical + policy AI safety. Authored the May 2023 'Statement on AI Risk' (signed by frontier-lab CEOs framing AI risk as a global priority).
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiDebate
Compute vs Behavioural Capability Thresholds
Should the regulatory trigger for 'frontier' / 'foundation' / 'systemic-risk' status be training-compute thresholds (objective + ex-ante observable), or behavioural-capability evaluation (more semantically meaningful but operationally costly)?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
European AI Office
Implements the EU AI Act's general-purpose AI provisions. Designates systemic-risk models, enforces Article 55 obligations, oversees the GPAI Code of Practice.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Future of Life Institute
Research and advocacy on catastrophic + existential AI risk. Organised the 2015 Puerto Rico conference + 2017 Asilomar Principles. Authored the Mar 2023 'Pause Giant AI Experiments' open letter (33k signatories).
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Global Partnership on AI
Multistakeholder initiative bridging OECD AI principles to practice. 29 member nations. Four working groups: Responsible AI, Data Governance, Future of Work, Innovation & Commercialisation.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Google DeepMind
Frontier AI developer (Gemini family). Governance posture organised around the Frontier Safety Framework (FSF), a Critical Capability Levels regime, plus internal AI Principles process.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
IEEE Standards Association — 7000-series (AI Ethics)
Series of standards on AI ethics, transparency, and bias. IEEE 7000 (Ethically Aligned Design), IEEE 7001 (transparency), IEEE 7003 (algorithmic bias), IEEE 7010 (well-being metrics).
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 42 — Artificial Intelligence
Joint Technical Committee subcommittee developing international AI standards. Published ISO/IEC 22989 (AI concepts), ISO/IEC 23894 (AI risk management), ISO/IEC 42001 (AI management systems).
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Japan AI Safety Institute
AI safety evaluation and standards co-development under the Information-technology Promotion Agency. Established Feb 2024.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Meta (Fundamental AI Research)
Frontier AI developer (Llama family). Distinctive open-weight governance posture: most-capable models released under permissive licenses, creating governance debate about closed-vs-open frontier-model regulation.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
National Institute of Standards and Technology
US federal non-regulatory standards agency. AI work spans the AI Risk Management Framework, GenAI Profile, the AI Safety Institute, and the Frontier AI Model Evaluation Consortium.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
OECD AI Working Party (AIGO + Network of Experts)
Coordinates OECD AI Principles + OECD.AI policy observatory. Maintains the most-cited cross-national AI-policy dataset.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiDebate
Open-Source vs Closed-Source Frontier Models
Should the most-capable AI models be released under permissive licenses (open weights), or only via API / structured-access agreements? The dispute is foundational to nearly every frontier-AI governance instrument.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
OpenAI
Frontier AI developer (GPT family). Governance posture organised around the Preparedness Framework, a capability-tier evaluation regime; Safety & Security Committee at the board level.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Partnership on AI
Multistakeholder coalition (frontier labs + civil society + academia) producing AI-deployment guidelines. Notable outputs: Synthetic Media Framework, Responsible Practices for Foundation Model Deployment.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiDebate
Pause AI vs Accelerate Capabilities
Should the global community impose temporary or capability-conditional pauses on frontier-AI development, or should development accelerate with safety work conducted in parallel?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiDebate
Pre-Deployment Red-Team vs Post-Deployment Audit
Should AI capability + safety evaluations happen primarily before deployment (red-team gating release), or primarily after (post-deployment audit + incident response)?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiDebate
Risk-Based vs Principles-Based vs Ex-Post Liability Regimes
Should AI governance work via (a) risk-based ex-ante categorisation + obligations (EU), (b) high-level principles delegated to sector regulators (UK / OECD / G7), or (c) ex-post liability + civil litigation (US sectoral)?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
Singapore AI Verify Foundation
Public-private foundation maintaining the AI Verify testing toolkit. Operates the Singapore AI Safety Institute under the AI Verify umbrella.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The AGI Transition and Post-AGI Constitutional Problem
What institutions, rules, and technical controls are needed if AI systems begin to exceed human experts across most cognitive tasks, accelerate AI R&D, autonomously act in the world, or become difficult to control?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Corporate Governance Problem
Can corporate boards, safety teams, investors, employees, auditors, and internal policies reliably constrain frontier developers when commercial and strategic incentives point toward speed?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Democratic Capacity Problem
How can democratic institutions govern AI when AI systems may themselves reshape information, persuasion, administration, expertise, lobbying, surveillance, and political mobilisation?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Epistemic Burden-of-Proof Problem
Under deep uncertainty, who bears the burden of proof: developers to show sufficient safety, or regulators to show sufficient danger?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Evaluation and Assurance Problem
Are model evaluations, red-teaming, benchmarks, audits, and safety cases reliable enough to determine whether a system should be trained, deployed, restricted, or recalled?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Global Justice and Benefit-Sharing Problem
What obligations do AI-leading states and firms have to share benefits, reduce harms, provide access, transfer capacity, include affected publics, and avoid locking poorer countries into dependency?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Governable Object Problem
Should governance target models, systems, deployments, compute, data, companies, capabilities, behaviours, supply chains, or socio-technical arrangements?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The International Institution Design Problem
Should global AI governance be built through the UN, a new AI agency, standards bodies, minilateral clubs, treaty regimes, compute-governance institutions, scientific panels, or issue-specific networks?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Legitimacy Problem
Who should decide whether powerful AI systems may be trained, deployed, paused, nationalised, restricted, open-sourced, or integrated into public infrastructure?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Open-vs-Controlled Access Problem
When should model weights, code, data, evaluations, safety methods, and capabilities be open, restricted, delayed, licensed, or classified?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Race-Stability Problem
Under what conditions can firms and states cooperate on AI safety rather than race toward deployment?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Responsibility and Liability Gap
How should law allocate responsibility among model developers, deployers, users, cloud providers, data suppliers, fine-tuners, auditors, and regulators?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Threshold and Tripwire Problem
Which thresholds should trigger reporting, licensing, external evaluation, compute controls, restricted deployment, model-weight security requirements, or a pause?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOpen problem
The Verification Without Leviathan Problem
How can governments or international institutions verify claims about training runs, compute use, model weights, security, evaluations, and deployment restrictions without excessive surveillance, centralisation, or abuse?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
UK AI Safety Institute
Empirical evaluation of advanced AI systems for societal risks. Pre-deployment access agreements with frontier labs. Headed by Ian Hogarth (founding chair).
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
UN AI Advisory Body
39-member expert body advising the UN Secretary-General on international AI governance. Published 'Governing AI for Humanity' (Sep 2024) recommending a UN AI Office + global AI fund.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiOrganisation
US AI Safety Institute (at NIST)
AI safety evaluation, methodology development, and capacity-building hosted within NIST. Pre-deployment access agreements with frontier labs. Headed by Elizabeth Kelly.
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
What should a human check actually change?
Analysis and proposals from Policy Window’s advocacy programme on AI, work and who decides.
- Status
- Advocacy reading
- Date
- Publication date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When AI saves time, who gets it?
Analysis and proposals from Policy Window’s advocacy programme on AI, work and who decides.
- Status
- Advocacy reading
- Date
- Publication date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
Looking for articles you saved? Open your Wiki reading list.