Library
Find public work on AI: neutral reference, research critiques and advocacy.
Search the library
57 entries · Public services
Clear filtersSelected starting points, then latest dated entries. Dates are labelled by their meaning.
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
EU AI Act
Risk-based framework. Prohibited practices (Art. 5) effective 2 February 2025; general-purpose AI obligations (Arts. 51-55) 2 August 2025; high-risk system obligations (Title III) 2 August 2026. Staggered 6/12/24-month application timeline from 1…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Can an AI-assisted audit replace a public voice?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Can unpaid carers get time back?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
How to read a promise of human involvement
How to compare human roles, rights and resources, with sources and limits.
- Status
- Guide and methods
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Should a public jobs programme preserve work that machines could do?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
The human involvement map
Explore selected arrangements, their powers, justifications, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research map
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Time off, paid time, care time
Compare protected absence, pay during leave and staff time within a care service, with original sources and coverage limits.
- Status
- Comparative analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When a learning promise breaks
Compare timely readmission, non-delivery, agreements and recommended debt relief, then ask what the learner can actually use.
- Status
- Evidence comparison
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When a student challenges an AI mark
Compare requests for review, changed marks and justified decisions, then examine authority, resources and response routes.
- Status
- Evidence comparison
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who can afford the time to care?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who can cut off a platform worker’s account?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who checks that decision support respects your wishes?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who chooses your decision supporters?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who controls the help they receive?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who controls the time to learn?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who discusses AI training licences?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who gets time to learn when AI changes the job?
Compare course finance, paid learning time and control, then examine a usable opportunity to develop judgment.
- Status
- Comparative analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who has a say in an efficiency bonus?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who judges the student’s work when AI assists?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who keeps control when an engineer uses AI?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who owns the next action?
Compare three published energy complaint procedures with five stages of useful human help, and distinguish promises from delivery.
- Status
- Document comparison
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who pays for learning when AI changes your job?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who protects a trainee’s chance to learn?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
A human on the line is only the beginning
A five-stage workflow for useful human help: access, authority, challenge and completed remedies.
- Status
- Workflow and analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Can customers request human help?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Does a right to review necessarily mean a human reviewer?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Paying for human time is only the beginning
An Australian care example separates reported human time, target attainment, experience and unanswered questions about access, agency and economic power.
- Status
- Research and analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
What changes when AI may assist but not deliver clinical care?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
What public records tell us about human review of government algorithms
A bounded study of government transparency-record webpages, with methods, uncertainty and the source index.
- Status
- Research and analysis
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When are solely automated profiling decisions restricted?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
When the replica performs, who gets paid?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Which school mental-health functions stay with people?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who approves AI-assisted selection guidelines?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who decides? Who gets paid? Who gets human time?
Four questions for promises to protect people as AI advances, with a local discussion record and printable worksheet.
- Status
- Explainer and discussion aid
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who gets a voice when AI changes a workflow?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who gets an efficiency bonus?
A Royal Mail example: reported payments, eligibility and the limits.
- Status
- Reported payments
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy reading
Who must provide the human care time?
Selected human-involvement arrangement: inspected text, HBC justification, objections, alternatives and source editions.
- Status
- Research profile
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy case study
Coursework: who actually decides the mark?
One human choice · England case
A choice about judgment, assistance and the resources needed to put a mistake right.
- Status
- Advocacy case study
- Prepared:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- AdvocacyHuman by choiceAdvocacy case study
Therapy: what Illinois chose to keep human in 2025
One human choice · Historical case
A comparison of the enacted 2025 rules, permitted assistance, access and who pays. Later amendments and current consolidation remain unverified; no equivalent UK policy has been adopted by the programme.
- Status
- Advocacy case study
- Prepared:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Executive Order 14110 on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI
Rescinded by EO 14148 (Jan 20, 2025); EO 14179 (Jan 23) set the deregulatory posture. Some §4 reporting persists via Defense Production Act + BIS interim rule. DRIFT-WATCH CORRECTION (2026-07-17, /wiki/drift.json): status was "partial" — WRONG. EO…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
OMB Memorandum M-24-10 (Advancing Governance, Innovation, and Risk Management for Agency Use of AI)
Binding on covered federal agencies. Three pillars: (I) strengthen AI governance through agency Chief AI Officers + AI Governance Boards; (II) advance responsible AI innovation including authorized use, talent, and infrastructure; (III) manage risks…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI meets politics: Examining the effects of different targeting strategies across 15 countries”
Sanne Kruikemeier, Svenja Schäfer, Alice Hamilton, Puck Guldemond, Jade Vrielink, Carmen Dymanus, Annelien Van Remoortere, Sanne Tamboer · New Media & Society
A solid, honestly-reported study whose main conclusions hold up; the defensible critique is confined to a handful of inference/wording over-reaches rather than design flaws. The single most damaging item is the self-contradictory "reinforcing effect"…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Italy Law No. 132/2025 on Artificial Intelligence (Legge 23 settembre 2025, n. 132)
Italy's Law No. 132/2025 ("Disposizioni e deleghe al Governo in materia di intelligenza artificiale") is the first organic national AI statute adopted by an EU member state. It was adopted 23 September 2025, published in Gazzetta Ufficiale Serie…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting”
Gregory Kestin, Kelly Miller, Anna Klales, Timothy Milbourne, Gregorio Ponti · Scientific Reports (Nature Portfolio)
A rigorous, genuinely strong within-subject RCT whose learning-gain finding is well supported (overwhelming raw effect, identical content across conditions, independent test construction, subgroup + clustering robustness, public data) — but whose…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Factors influencing the adoption of generative artificial intelligence into classroom teaching by university teachers: An empirical study using SPSS PROCESS macros”
Yong Xiang, Chenxin Yang, Zhigang Jin, Wanshu Zhao · PLOS One
A publishable-genre but methodologically weak adoption-intention study whose conclusions should be read as exploratory correlational associations, not the causal mechanisms it claims. A full-text convergence panel returned a unanimous survives…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Fairness Is More Than Algorithms: Racial Disparities in Time-to-Recidivism”
Jessy Xinyi Han, Kristjan Greenewald, Devavrat Shah · arXiv (cs.CY; stat.AP) preprint
A worthwhile conceptual contribution — treating recidivism as time-to-event and offering a survival-based falsification test for the role of non-algorithmic factors — whose empirical demonstration, as presented, is too underpowered, under-reported,…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Criminal Justice
Predictive policing, risk assessment, sentencing assistance.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Education
Automated grading, proctoring, student-data analytics.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance topic
AI in Healthcare
Clinical decision support, medical devices, diagnostic AI.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
Council of Europe Framework Convention on AI
First legally-binding international treaty on AI. Opened for signature Sep 2024. Enters into force three months after five ratifications including three CoE members. Currency (2026-06-21): secondary trackers report the entry-into-force threshold was…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiConcept
Hallucination
Confidently-asserted but factually incorrect output produced by an AI model — including fabricated citations, invented people or events, and confabulated numerical values — that the model cannot reliably distinguish from correct output at generation…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UN GA Resolution on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI
Non-binding. Calls on member states to bridge digital divides and develop national strategies. China + US co-sponsored; passed by consensus. Currency (2026-06-21): the UN AI-governance track has since advanced beyond this non-binding resolution —…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UNESCO Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence
First global standard-setting (normative) instrument on AI ethics, adopted by acclamation by all 193 UNESCO Member States on 23 Nov 2021. It is a "Recommendation" — UNESCO soft law: non-binding ethical guidance addressed to Member States (and,…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
California SB 243: Companion Chatbots
SB 243 ('Companion chatbots'), Chapter 677, Statutes of 2025, approved by the Governor and filed with the Secretary of State on October 13, 2025, adds Chapter 22.6 (§§ 22601–22606) to Division 8 of the California Business and Professions Code — the…
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- CritiqueCritical AI — by Policy WindowPaper critique
Comment on “Generative AI, propaganda, and digital authoritarianism: Comparative insights from six democratically weakened countries”
Gabrielle D. Beacken, Inga K Trauthig, Samuel Woolley · Big Data & Society
A strong, anti-determinist comparative study whose descriptive findings are well supported; the cautions, visible from the abstract, are the leap from elite-adoption interviews to causal claims about democratic erosion, and the reproducibility of…
- Status
- Published critique
- Published:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiGovernance instrument
UK Pro-Innovation Approach to AI Regulation (White Paper)
Principles-based, regulator-led approach (no statutory AI law). Cross-sectoral principles delegated to existing regulators. AISI established Nov 2023 for evaluation/safety research.
- Status
- Public reference
- Reference review:
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
- ReferenceWikiDebate
Risk-Based vs Principles-Based vs Ex-Post Liability Regimes
Should AI governance work via (a) risk-based ex-ante categorisation + obligations (EU), (b) high-level principles delegated to sector regulators (UK / OECD / G7), or (c) ex-post liability + civil litigation (US sectoral)?
- Status
- Public reference
- Date
- Review date not recorded
- Publisher:
- Policy Window
Looking for articles you saved? Open your Wiki reading list.